It is May 1483, and Roger the Chapman is getting out of London as fast and as covertly as he can. Why? In solving some mysteries for his wife’s relatives, he stumbled on plot led by Lord Hastings against the Lord Protector, Richard of Gloucester. While Roger admires Richard, who in turn thinks highly of Roger and his investigative skills, he does not want the latter to command him to stay in London to investigate the conspiracy. You see Roger is an independent man who loves the open road—sometimes even more than he loves his family.
When Roger reaches home in Bristol, not only are his wife and children waiting for him, but also Timothy Plummer—Richard’s spymaster. It seems Richard does not need him to investigate the Hastings conspiracy, but wants him to solve the mystery of the abuduction of a boy and the murder of the boy’s tutor. The boy, Francis Lovell’s ward, came to London to become a companion to the new boy king. Before he could join the king at the Tower, he was at Baynard’s Castle where he disappeared and his tutor was found dead with a knife in his back in a locked room.
Roger is able to solve how the murder took place, but before he can identify the perpetrator(s) he has to figure out the reason why the boy was abducted. The kidnappers were not interested in just any boy—they targeted this specific boy who seems unremarkable. As in the other mysteries in this series, Roger’s reaches his solution as a result of divine guidance rather than through deductive reasoning. When Roger left the monastic life in favor of that of a peddler, God had a plan to use him to right some wrongs by solving crimes—or at least so Roger believes. Chance encounters and strange dreams lead him to the solutions. Thus, at the beginning of the novel Roger encounters an odd family living off the beaten path. Those people wind up playing a part in the mystery. Unbelievable coincidence, some might say, but the reader understands that Roger’s steps were directed by God. And God sends Roger an important clue when he dreams of the Dowager Duchess of York rattling off the names of all of the kidnapped boy’s numerous uncles and brothers. (Roger did witness such a scene, amazed at the duchess's ability.)
The solution involves a pagan cult—not too dissimilar to the mystery in another book in the series,The Green Man. What makes this book of particular interest is that it gives us Roger witnessing the crucial events leading to Richard’s accession to the throne. Roger arrives in London on June 13–the day of the famous council meeting—and he doesn’t leave until after Richard’s coronation on July 6. Although admiring Richard as a man of honor and principle, he has noted a certain ruthlessness in him since accompanying him on the Scottish campaign. (See The Green Man.). When hearing the news that Hastings has been summarily executed, Roger is uneasy. Roger remains so even when Plummer assures him that Hastings is under arrest awaiting trial. There’s not any difference between no trial and a trial with a predetermined verdict, he muses. Then, Richard summons him not so much for a progress report on the case as to sound him out as a sort of Everyman. What would Roger think if he deposes his nephew and assumes the throne? Well, Roger is disturbed, and believes that the move would not be a popular one. Roger witnessed the angelic-looking, fair-haired boy riding into London and the women, their maternal instincts awakened, drooling over the little darling. Although Roger believes that Richard is the rightful king since he investigated the issue of Edward IV’s legitimacy for him, there is no definitive proof of that and Roger is skeptical of the pre-contract claim. Richard should refer the matter to an episcopal court, in any case. As for continuing threats to the duke’s life, Richard should just appeal to the “people” for support.
In the end, Richard comes to Roger’s rescue when the latter has finds the kidnapped boy who is about to be done in by his abductors. Thanking him for his service, Richard adds that “this time you have also saved the life of a young boy, a very precious thing.” Words that Roger will cause to reflect on in the future. But for the immediate future, Roger will rejoice at Richard’s coronation, and enjoy the feast that follows before heading home.