A well-researched and insightful book on the British soldier’s experience in North America during the Seven Years War.
Brumwell disputes the idea that British soldiers were unprepared for wilderness warfare, and argues that they learned to adapt to the battlefield and ultimately overcame it. He also argues against the notion that the army was polarized between lower-class soldiers and upper-class officers, and argues that the army was mostly met by admiration from colonists, rather than scorn (a large number of colonists sought to join the regular army, after all). Brumwell also describes how British soldiers, while not always understanding the ways of the Indians, often adapted their methods.
The narrative is readable, and Brumwell does a great job humanizing the soldiers, although he doesn’t really delve into their background much. He is also good at describing the conditions they fought under, and how they changed from theater to theater.
A solid, refreshing and well-argued work.