This is a review of all three volumes as it really has to be viewed as one complete work, and all three parts are an absolute must...
Anyway, having just finished the third of three deluxe editions of Alan Moore and JH Williams III's Promethea, I'm still finding it difficult to express just how mind-blowingly brilliant I found the whole series. It seems to be seen by many as a relatively minor Moore work, but I consider it easily among the best things he ever did.
The League of Extraordinary Gentlemen is the title from his ABC line of comics that gets all the attention, but give me Promethea (and certainly Top 10 and probably Tom Strong) over it any day of the week. Not least because the League books suffered from a really off-putting amount of cynicism in them, as well as the sense that as they went along, they were less interested in compelling stories and characters than referencing as many obscure literary characters as possible.
Which is, of course, ironic considering how the main complaint about Promethea is that it's just a long-winded summation of Moore's religious beliefs. I mean, it kind of is that, especially in the final issue, but it's so much more than that too.
For a start, it's arguably the least cynical thing that Moore has ever written. More than that, I would say that it's one of the most uplifting, genuinely spiritual comics I have ever read - and I've read a whole lot of them. Admittedly part of this comes down to the fact that as a relatively religious Jew, I found the kabbalistic aspects of the book to be much easier to hook into than I'm sure many, if not, most readers will, and I was shocked to see just how much Tarot and the kind of "magic" practiced by Moore draws from it. I'm usually more drawn to the more rationalistic tradition in Judaism than the kabbalistic, but I was already fairly familiar with the Tree of Life stuff and the Sephirot and have long appreciated these concepts as a more serious and believable way to view God than the usual, fairly childish, "old dude in the sky" approach.
I mean, I still found 80% of the more New Agey stuff... extraneous, shall we say, what with my viewing Kabbalah through a Jewish rather than Gnostic lens, but I still found his exploration of consciousness, creativity, Oneness and human connectedness genuinely beautiful, even transcendent. And a real balm for all the horrible stuff happening in the world.
I am, therefore, genuinely curious to see how hardened atheists react to the book. Not in the sense of whether it "converted" them, but if they find something to hook onto, emotionally, in all the "hocus pocus".
I truly think they will, though, because there's so much more to Promethea than just its "spiritual" aspects. It's exceptionally inventive and imaginative. It's a total masterclass in comics storytelling. It is plainly heartfelt, genuinely hopeful and I thought the characters were pretty wonderful. And it's also very, very funny at times, with tons of gags especially coming from the quirky futuristic New York that Moore clearly put a lot of effort into creating.
Well, him and JH Williams III, I mean.
Williams is, very simply, every bit as much a part of the genius of the book as Moore is - arguably even more so. I thought it was his work on Batwoman that saw his art take a quantum leap forward, but nope, it's all right here. And then some. All the incredible layouts, shifting styles (often in one panel) and immaculate line work. His work on promethea is genuinely nothing less than awe-inspiring, which really could not be more fitting for such a comic.
Special props too, of course, to Mick Gray (inks), Jeromy Cox (colours) and Todd Klein (letters and design), as they contributed enormously to bringing the very best out of Williams's spectacular pencils.
Which is why, though I do wish they were sewn-bound rather than glued, these deluxe prestige editions are the best way to read this book - outside of, I presume, the Absolute editions. They are oversized and absolutely gorgeous, with tons of great bonus material too, including a couple of Moore's complete scripts, extensive examinations of the art process and even pages from other ABC titles in which Promethea appears. They're fairly expensive (though nowhere near the Absolutes) but absolutely well worth the price. Hell, even if you inexplicably have no use for the writing whatsoever, I can easily recommend just buying them as art books.
I only wish the stuff that Moore worked on after this had even one tenth of Promethea - and much of the ABC line's - appeal to me. Though if we do ignore everything that came out afterwards, this would make one hell of a swan song for arguably the greatest writer the comic book medium has ever known.