Mild listed spoilers below:
Trying to avoid major spoilers by name.
This series has been a wild roller-coaster of a ride. I love the series, but I think I need to give myself a long break before I reading through series again, due to the emotional scenes that break me...
Started reading this way back in elementary school. I stopped for some reason, then got the other books a few years later and continued into high school and college. To say that this series has been apart of my childhood is an understatement! I much prefer the recent artist's cover illustrations of the books' north american versions to the UK ones.
Something strange is that I predicted a few of the things that happened, back when the last book came out in 2013... pretty closely. Like Elena's identity, the book's color, etc. Though there were still some things that surprised me.
This book is also has some surprisingly dark moments. It didn't feel too out of place, but just different. This added to the suspense, mostly.
This last book was on hold for *9 years... so there was quite the expectation built up. I wondered if this book would come out at all for years.
I think this may have affected some of the quality of the final product of the book. I can understand taking a one or two year break, but its' not a great idea for a writer to take this long of a break.
It doesn't ruin the whole book, but certain parts felt rushed or confusing.
Overall, the book is still quite satisfying.
The usual stuff is there- an action packed adventure, with twists and turns.
I appreciated the emotional depth added to Nero. The book does a great job exploring character flaws, and how the characters' personalities work well together, or not. Sometimes writers are too afraid to have character flaws because they think that'll make the audience reject them entirely, when really it adds complexity and does the opposite.
Some nice callbacks to things that happened earlier in the series.
Its' somewhat conclusive, only, not as conclusive as I'd have like it to be.
My two biggest problems with the book is the twists don't really work, and some sections felt confusing.
There are a few major twists which in my opinion don't quite stick the landing well.
One scene with Nero arguing with one antagonist felt a little flat, in terms of motivation...
One major twist I can't decide if I love or hate. I sort of predicted it... sort of.
Part of the challenge of bieng a writer is tying plot threads from earlier back together. It sort of works... but its' not always believable, or contrary to what was established before.
Some things like the return of the Sinestre family, and explaining how the 'voice' works, didn't quite work for me.
As for pacing issues... the problem mentioned was present in previous books, but I didn't notice it as a problem, as much.
Its' more to do with the artists' writing style. He has an action scene go from point A to point B, then try to say, 'while it looked like _blank happened_, actually at the same time something else happened.'
It could have been clearer conveying this. The section in Italy fleeing the mansion in particularily felt quite confusing. Kind of a narrative mess... One character dissappeared unceremoniously, leaving no clue as to if she survived or not... only to turn up later conveniently. It gives one account, but then gives another account contradicting that... Also the last chapter of the book.
The author has also had some inconsistencies throught the series with the lore. Such as, how long the HIVE school-years are, and the school bieng established in the 60s', but some people bieng students from 30 years ago... I noticed this but it didn't bother me too much, other than bieng a little confusing.
There were also some unfulfilled things set up from the last book which didn't get mentioned. An example bieng the Robert Flack guy bieng out to expose Otto and his school, the remaining disciples, and cloning tech still bieng out there, Penny hating Otto and Wing and not coming to terms with her feelings. The biggest thing is the ending bieng sort of open ending.
It's kind of a better ending than expected, but it ends a little too abruptly. I would have liked a little more info to clarify some stuff. What is this place Wing and Shelby run? Why did they chose this and not running their own villainous enterprise for example?
The antagonist in this book is somewhat of a trope subversion. You expect the over-arching villain to come back like Voldemort does in Harry Potter as the final book's villain. I expected Overlord to be brought back.
She felt a little too overpowered at points, like even after returning to face her with the new tricks up the gangs' sleeve... it fails? Really...?.
The solution at the end felt plot device-y.
Although I do admire how I remembered that the author brought up similar stakes back in book 2 with Cypher talking about the horror of an AI controlling a whole military's arsenal, and multiple whole militaries.
Could have been better, but its' not too bad.