I did not like this book at all. Not for a Mansell anyway. If it were written by anyone else, I might have given it more stars, but for Jill Mansell, it was just severely disappointing.
This is my third book for Mansell, and I was over the moon about the first two books I read for her, and thought I would be about this one too - as the reviews were outstanding - but I wasn't.
I didn't like the characters, I felt they were all shallow, and irritating. A lot of it was unrealistic, and everyone seemed to be falling in love in a matter of days! The twists and turns made no sense, and everything seemed a little TOO coincidental. And this book has pretty much VERY LITTLE to do with Maddy and Kerr - the supposed main characters of the book. It had a lot more to do with the secondary characters - mainly Kate and her family.
Yes, I found a lot of the text funny, but I never said Mansell wasn't funny. She's a good writer, she's capable of writing incredible books. So the writing was good, it's the plot I hated. I do have one remark though, at some point Will says, "let me just grab a shower" and that really bothered me because it makes no sense. You can't GRAB a shower, you take one, you have one, but you don't GRAB one. Sheesh! I really needed to get that one out.
Back to the story now, I think Den deserved a much larger part in the story than he was given, since the whole "concept" revolved around him and the accident he was involved in. Especially after everything you find out in the end, I think Mansell robbed him off his story, which I think would've been a very good one. This book should have been about Den, rather than Kerr, and should have revolved more around their family rather than Kate's extremely shallow and broken family.
And I really, really hate stories about cheating spouses. Honestly, I despise that. It is never right to cheat on your spouse, it is never okay. Cheating is hurtful and wrong. And I hate when people take that and make it into a story with a happy ending. A husband cheats on his wife, a wife cheats on her husband, but somehow everything works out great for them, and they live happily ever after. And verbal abuse is not okay either, it is often times worse than physical abuse, so again, I hated that Mansell used those aspects for her characters and made them seem like good people at the end.
So all of that being said and done, I did not completely hate the book. I know, go on, roll your eyes, "really?! you could've fooled me!", but I didn't! I enjoyed many parts of it. I just did not like the overall plot and a lot of the characters roles. I've read a couple of Mansell's books and I know the difference. And this is why I'm being hard on her and on this book, because I know she's capable of a lot more. This just isn't up to par with her other books.
I'm still a Mansell fan, and I most definitely will be reading each and every one of her other books, but I don't expect every book to earn 5 stars out of me either.
This one certainly didn't.