I can't decide whether this book is brilliant or horrific.
Brilliant
~First book I've read in a LONG time where the students' names seem authentic (Babette, Miracle, Jazzmin, Raul).
~Harry isn't miraculously "cured" of naughty behavior...
~...AND HE KEEPS MESSING UP.
~Benjamin's too-small spare set of clothes made me LOL.
~Classroom meetings, thinking chairs, super-cheesy teacher -- sounds like a real classroom to me!
Horrific
~What if a teacher uses this book TOTALLY SERIOUSLY, rather than with a half-smile at its earnestness (which is how I would probably use it)?
~Honestly, if a teacher used this book with a completely straight face, I'd love to see how students react to its message.