A compelling and moving new memoir of Afghanistan. An unforgettable portrait of daily life - and death - in the stricken country of Afghanistan, told from a unique perspective.
A good title, nice cover & interesting premise drew me to this book when I first saw it on the shelf. However, after reading the initial chapters I quickly began to doubt my choice & by the halfway mark I was considering giving up - something I resist ever doing with books.
As someone who taught English for a long time & as such read hundreds upon hundreds of examples of teenage writing over the years, I was straight away struck by the familiar style of writing - reminiscent of an earnest & able fifteen year old, armed with a more than adequate vocabulary & good intentions. I kept wondering how an editor hadn't stripped out all the over-written, often repetitive description, until I read the jacket properly & realised that the author was the editor, as well as the publisher, & it shows. Probably a third of the book could have been given the chop, without detracting from the narrative in any way.
However, writing style aside, what concerns me most about this book, having lived in the Middle East & as a current post-graduate student of Middle Eastern studies myslef, are the images & ideas about the region portrayed by the writer. Having embarked on her PhD I'm sure that Magsie Hamilton-Little has encountered the concept of Orientalism, from which point she might wish to review her own writing. One example is the plight of Afghani women, which was used as one justification for the US invasion; the author appeals to the same Western, white, middle class, saving the world mentality. Throw some money at it all will be better. Save the poor people of the world!!!
Everytime a woman was referred to as a burka, I cringed. When the author makes no effort to learn someone's name & inappropriately refers to him as Ghengis, I cringed (Note: this individaul is also referred to as Balckbeard). References to sparkling Afghan (read Afghani, which is the academically accpeted term) eyes made me cringe. Again & again place & people are described in cliched caricature, a hodge-podge of mixed metaphors, heavy handed similes & awkward, over-writen adjectives.
I appreciate Magsie Hamilton-Little's intentions but I can't say that her book has done anything to educate or enlighten its readers, to break-down stereotypes or advance Western notions about Afghanistan & its people.
The events and feelings which underpin the very personal story that Magsie Hamilton-Little tells in this book is interesting and poignant. However, I felt that it was disjointed and the way that it was written failed to stir the emotions which other books about recent Afghan history, both fiction and non-fiction, have roused in me.
One of the points which is made towards the end of the book is totally in line with the way that I have thought for most of my life: education is key to the resolution of every conflict in the world.
I am proud to say that my step-mother was the founding headmistress of the first integrated school in Northern Ireland. There are now more than fifty. Ensuring that children from every section of society will mix from their earliest moments of life teaches them that we all have more in common with others than we have differences. Those differences are very important, and learning about them from each other is a great way to educate. What a rich tapestry of beliefs we have in this world! We should celebrate those differences rather than set out to kill those who do not share our beliefs.
Back off my soap box and back to the book: there are some very sad and touching moments, especially towards the end of the book. There are also some very amusing events, and a few little twists. Whilst there is a lot of value in Magsie relating her own experiences, I just felt that a very experienced ghost writer could have made the whole story a lot more powerful.
This story doesn't take too much effort to read, so I would definitley recommend it to you if you are looking for a quick read which will tell you something about modern Afghanistan.
Just barely scraping to 3 stars. I think a better editor on it could have made this book 4 stars for me. There were really large gaps in the story line. I didn't know how much time had passed from one chapter to the next. I didn't understand connections on why things were happening. It needed another 30-40 pages to it to really do the story justice. Obviously the author's time in Afganistan was life changing, but I never felt satisfied with the explanations of things.
A powerful and moving account of a very extraordinary episode in this strong woman's life, and a window onto the real life of the people of Afghanistan. The writing is a little rough in places, but lyrical in others. I thought it was a beautiful book and was sorry not to have more of it.
Got this out from the library today, and spent the rest of the day reading it. Made me appreciate a lot of things I take absolutely for granted. Bit of an indication of timescales would have been good, but apart from that I enjoyed it.
A memorable account of a journey into Afghanistan and into ones fears. Brave and inspiring but a tad cliched at the end...'it's only in the darkness that you see the stars'
A narrowly focused dive into the experience of one Englishwoman, and one Afghani family, in Afghanistan in 2006. I have to admit that the author's personal story interested me less than her often beautiful (if overwritten) descriptions of the sights, smells and sounds of Afghanistan but it was a worthwhile, short read.
Gave up half way through with this book. The story seemed fragmented and the scenes didn't have a lead up to them so you were left with a lot of questions. It felt like most of the story was missing. Didn't get me engaged at all.
Caught at the edge of the Tavistock Square bombing in 2005, Hamilton-Little, a student at SOAS, feels compelled to go to Kabul, Afghanistan, to try to understand. She goes, and plunges into the turmoil and danger of the country, also making deep friendships.
In the second half of the book the author recounts how she and her friends struggle to find one of their number who has disappeared, kidnapped. The bravery of the group, the strength and humanity shine through the tragedy of the war that engulfs their lives and continues in Afghanistan now.
It was all much too real to be a novel, much too random, to insignificant - and yet an amazingly heroic and tragic story is told - at times poetically, and, throughout, honestly.
I understand that this was based on true events and yeah I read about half and in the end I had to give up. I am fascinated by the Afghani culture but after reading The Kite Runner and A Thousand Splendid Suns this really did nothing for me. It was a slow moving plot and didn't enlighten me in anyway about something I didn't already know. It is more like a brief document of events, almost report like rather than a novel that's meant to grab the readers attention. Nice idea, nice cover, nice name, bad book.