Had Potential But Fell Flat
16 May 2021
I guess the fact that this book doesn’t have a Wikipedia page dedicated to it says quite a lot about it, namely that it really is pretty forgettable. Mind you, I thought that the idea did have potential, especially with the setting, but in the end I really couldn’t really get into it, and it simply devolved into another of the many quest stories out there that has the main character come out of it at the end much wiser and having a greater understanding of herself than previously.
One of the main reasons that I grabbed this book was that I wanted to buy something from the second-hand bookshop that I was visiting at the time, and I hadn’t actually read anything by Andre Norton (who happens to be a female writer, though ironically many of her pen names happen to be male, which I found to be rather odd because there were quite a few female fantasy writers back in the 80s). Another interesting thing that I discovered about Norton was that she wrote the first novel that was based on the Dungeons and Dragons roleplaying game, at the request of Gary Gygax himself. Mind you, based upon what I could find out about it, it wasn’t particularly good, but then again neither are many of the other books based upon the Dungeons and Dragons game.
The interesting thing I found about this story is that it is set in a world which is visited by space travelers who come here to trade. In part, the main city reminded me of Malacca, and the other trading ports that were set up by the merchants to facilitate trade with the interior. In part it seemed as if there might be some concepts of colonialism, but it turned out that there wasn’t. Yeah, that is one of the things I’d like to see in a fantasy/Sci-fi novel, and that is exploring colonialism, particularly from the point of view of the colonised. Unfortunately, this book wasn’t it.
The main character is sort of interesting, but once again it is a trope that you tend to see time and time again. She is unique, living in a city of thieves, and because she doesn’t have that many connections she has to scrape together what she can from the crumbs that are thrown her way. However, she encounters Thom, one of the spacemen, who discovers that she possesses an item that may lead to the location of his lost brother. Yeah, as you can see, this book just seems to be full of the tropes that you find in many, many of the Science Fiction/Fantasy books that seem to compete with each other for our attention these days.
As I suggested, I really did want to like this book, but unfortunately it is one of those stories that sort of had quite a lot of promise, but seems to fail in its execution. I could suggest that this was because it was written back in the 80s, but even back in the 80s there was scope for books that explore concepts as opposed to just being another story that is pretty much a copy of countless numbers of other stories, just with the names changed, and a few other things as well.
Sure, I might not have read many of her other works, and unfortunately this seems to be a rather disappointing entrance to the works of a rather prolific author.