In this third installment of the Inspector Green series, Frankin deals with the complex and emotionally charged issue of sexual abuse, but does so in a thoughtful and sensitive way.
Mathew Fraser was a shy, quiet teacher who enjoyed working with children. Over a decade ago, one of his students, six-year-old Rebecca Whelan, accused him of sexually molesting her. In the sensational trail that followed, Mathew was found not guilty, but what followed the trial and that judgement ruined his life. He lost his job, his friends deserted him and he became a reclusive, anxiety driven, paranoid young man. He sought help from professionals, took his prescribed medications and attended weekly group therapy sessions. It was at those sessions, he met Janice Turner, a young woman who also suffered with mental health issues. They began a friendship, meeting weekly for a walk and spending time in casual conversation. When Mathew did not turn up for either their regularly scheduled group therapy session or their walk, Janice became worried. She phoned his apartment, but couldn’t get through. After six days and growing increasingly worried, she headed to his apartment, surprised to find the door unlocked. When she entered, she was assaulted by the overwhelming smell of half-eaten rotting food in the kitchen. She could hardly make sense of what she saw lining the walls and filling every space on the tables, chairs and the floor. There were piles of old documents everywhere and the shelves were full of more articles and books on law and psychology. But what stops Janice in her tracks is that wherever Matt has gone, he has left his beloved dog Modo behind, closed off in the bedroom without food and water. She knows something is very wrong. It looks like Matt left abruptly and has now been gone for several days. Thinking back to their last group meeting, Janice remembers finding Matt skittish and he seemed to think someone was out to get him.
Worried for Matt’s safety she reports him missing at the police station, but feels no one is taking her seriously. When she spots Inspector Green, she grabs him, glad to finally talk to someone in authority. She shares the evidence she has that worries her and Green, his curiosity piqued, agrees to check it out, hoping to calm her. When he checks Mathew’s apartment, he understands Janice Tanner’s concerns.
Green’s research into Mathew Fraser’s police file reveals the allegations of sexual abuse made by Rebecca Whelan over a decade ago and wonders if the piles of documents in Mathew’s apartment are related to that case. If so, why was he researching it now, decades after it happened and after he was declared not guilty? Did he find information he was desperate to keep hidden from someone who was threatening him? Or is someone, who believes Matt was guilty, about to exact revenge. Something very urgent and compelling had taken Matt away. Had he gone on his own, or did someone force him to leave? Green seizes Mathew’s computer hoping to find more clues, but much of it has been wiped clean. There is one file titled “Mistwalker” which he finds curious, but like the others, is empty.
This is the plodding detective work Green enjoys and the only police work he has ever wanted to do. It is not the work expected in his job as Inspector, one when he is expected to attend meetings, liaise with other agencies, review statistics and reports and lead others working cases in the field. That is the type of middle management work he takes every opportunity to avoid in favor of an opportunity to grab an interesting case. He likes to partner with his longtime friend and colleague Detective Brian Sullivan and they make an excellent team, despite their differences in temperament and rank. Green is impulsive and uses his unrestrained imagination to make wild intuitive leaps, while Sullivan is practical and has his feet firmly on the ground. At this time, Brian is investigating a rooming house death in Vanier and as the case proceeds a point comes when Green begins to wonder if there is a remote chance the two cases are connected.
Fradkin explores the frustration and difficulty the authorities experience investigating sex crimes involving children. They must uncover the facts while at the same time, balance the privacy of the victims with the rights of the accused. The public judge sex crimes as heinous, considers sex offenders as evil doers and pedophiles as the lowest of the low. In cases that go to trial, many will not remember an acquittal, only the terrible allegations of what allegedly happened, always mindful an acquittal does not mean the accused was innocent, only that the prosecution was not able to prove guilt beyond a reasonable doubt. These cases invoke passion and moral outrage, targeted at the accused and the lawyers that defend them, the authorities investigating the case and the community organizations created to defend and support vulnerable victims. Even those who must defend those charged with an offence, experience difficulty when they do not believe their client is innocent, but are bound to provide them with the best defense they can muster. Families are torn apart by these events, professionals are stressed trying to protect patient client confidentiality, by their carefully consideration about what they can and cannot say, while also feeling duty bound to protect the public. Those who are wrongly accused may try to start a new life, but often fail, as news of the alleged crimes always seems to spread. The victims are often taunted by schoolmates, neighbors keep their distance, talk in whispers and hushed tones and families often relocate move to avoid the uncomfortable fallout.
What I enjoy about this series is the strict focus on the crime and the path Green takes to solve it. Most readers of crime fiction try to solve the mystery before the detective does, often finding they do not have access to all the information and when the crime is solved, feel put out or disappointed. Not so in this series. Fradkin keeps her readers in Green’s head, as he chases down clues, follows every lead, and creates every possible theory of how the crime occurred. Once Green is on a case, he becomes obsessed, gets little sleep, forgets to eat or accept that a day only has twenty-four hours, and pays little attention to his wife Sharon and their young son Tony.
During this investigation someone from his past will suddenly appear, creating more chaos in his life as he tries to solve the crime, keep his marriage together, learn how to father his young son and close the case.
This book is the best in the series so far and readers will appreciate it even more if they read the books in order.