This review contains SPOILERS.
*
*
*
*
I was really disappointed with this installment of the series (for the record, I had rated part 1 of this series 4 stars).
Good points: I did like the idea of providing backstories for various important side characters, such as Quinn and Tzader. In general, I still like the main character, Evalle. I did like the world building in the first book.
Bad points: This is admittedly a subjective impression, but I couldn't help the feeling that this book felt like a first draft, in that a lot of things needed to be 'smoothed over', as it were, through editing and rewriting. Here are some reasons why.
(i) Nonsensical character actions. Making sure that characters' actions made sense in light of their personalities as well as in light of what events were taking place. There were a large number of instances where characters did things and an attempt at an explanation of their actions was provided, yet both the explanation and their actions just didn't make sense. For example, (and this is a big one) the significance of the fact that only the Alterants with Belador blood are able to resist the magical fog that the Medb put into the atmosphere, as well as the fact that these Alterants are different from all other Alterants, is mentioned by the 'bad guys' in the novel. The Belador Alterants can be differentiated from the rest by the fact that they have glowing green eyes. The good guys, including the main character, have no knowledge of that fact that this difference even exists, yet when the fog begins to descend, several individuals suddenly 'notice' the 'crucial' difference that is the presence vs. lack of green eyes (I'm exaggerating a little here and not explaining this entirely well, but this sudden 'brilliance' on the part of the characters did feel ridiculously convenient to me with regards to the plot of the story). This is only one example, but there were so many instances where I had to simply keep reading despite actions that made no sense on the characters' part, that I really wanted to throw the book against a wall. Or something.
(ii) Petty and ridiculous deities. I have difficulty understanding why *ANYONE* would want to follow and/or bow down to gods as PETTY and RIDICULOUS as the gods depicted in this series of novels, and who seem to run things. While I understand that the various magical races featured in these novels essentially have little choice in this regard, it seems to me that at some point power is not enough, and that anyone who is as incredibly petty and selfish as these gods seem to be simply does not merit being worshipped. Given the depiction of the deities featured in these novels, I find it somewhat unbelievable, psychologically speaking, that so many would blindly follow such gods. For example, the goddess of the Beladors, Macha, is shown constantly modifying her own appearance in order to make herself even more physically beautiful. She also severely chastises Brina, the queen of the Beladors, for not being appropriately respectful (i.e. think bootlicking here), and arranges things so that Brina cannot marry the man she loves. Because apparently this is incredibly important in the grand scheme of things for some reason... Yet if this is the case, why couldn't she at least show some sympathy towards the people in question? Basically, this goddess and others essentially come across as useless wastes of space, power, and resources, which makes the idea of people serving these selfish beings seem rather ridiculous. As another ridiculous example, the gods in charge of a tribunal which winds up judging Evalle (i.e. the main character), seem to lack any capacity of compassion or understanding: Evalle tries her utmost to fulfill their impossible tasks yet when she fails, there is no understanding on their part that the task was virtually impossible to begin with. This also struck me as a rather silly way to create 'drama' by having the main character be imprisoned yet again for failing to complete a task which was obviously impossible (i.e. this happens at the end of the book). What was the point?
Personally, I felt like telling the lot of them to take a hike across the cosmos.
(iii) The grammar in this book is atrocious. THIS BOOK NEEDS AN EDITOR STAT!
(iv) Evil gods messing with people's love lives. Why would a goddess CARE whether or not Romeo and Juliet's (er... I meant Brina and Tzader's but whatever...) craptastic-eternal-love (TM) was fulfilled? Wouldn't goddesses have better things to do than make people's love lives complicated? Like, oh... I don't know... Help save the world and/or the galaxy, maybe? This seemed to me like an entirely contrived and silly way of creating romantic 'drama', and reminded me of some (abysmal and godawful) romance novels I'd read over the years. 'Nuff said.
(v) The plot felt pointless. When the major part of the 'drama' in the novel is created because petty gods assigned an impossible task (yet no one even thought to tell them it was impossible and that they were being petty) and the main character (of course) failed to complete said impossible task and the petty gods were still petty and imprisoned her because they were petty, I have to say that... The whole plot began to feel rather contrived and POINTLESS. In other words, it was somewhat obvious that the characters were never going to get a 'fair shake', so why should we care? And why did people care about what selfish deities wanted in the first place (I certainly didn't)? Yuck.
(vi) The neverending crisis plot (TM). The characters seemed to 'lurch' from one crisis to the next without having any kind of plan. Ever. I will grant you that they found themselves in one crisis after another with very little TIME to elaborate any plan, but still. After a while, this meandering from one crisis to another felt rather exhausting and pointless to me as a reader. (It also made up about 99% of the book so I'll let you guess how I felt at the end...)
Honestly, what boggles my mind is that this was published without the rather substantial editing and revisions which would have been (to my mind) needed. But I have to agree with a friend of mine here: no one bothers editing books these days, apparently (at least partly because people seem to buy crappy books regardless of their crapiness, honestly).
I feel rather cheated, personally, given the fact that I gave the first book and this series a chance (I rated the first book 4 stars).
Anyways, JMHO (and disappointed) opinion.