Richard Hofstadter once said that the Emancipation Proclamation “had all the moral grandeur of a bill of lading”. Howard says that political desires killed the “moral momentum” of Radical Reconstruction and the 13th, 14th and 15th amendments had to lie dormant as seeds for a hundred more years. He reminds us that even Lyndon Johnson hesitated to revoke the Compromise of 1877 while modern day abolitionists were being murdered in Mississippi. Johnson’s refusal in invoke federal law/power to protecting blacks in the 60’s connected him, in his continuing to ignore the Constitution, directly to the failure of Reconstruction. Order since then had always been maintained at the expense of blacks in the South.
History is taught to most of us to be the result of legislation and things Presidents did and rarely the result of social agitation. Activists are rarely treated with public esteem because of a simple rule: historically to ruin an activist, one merely paints them in print as an extremist. America has a way of “forgetting” how many “extremists” through our history made our country better in the end and instead puts the spotlight on Lincoln and other come-late-to-the-party centrist compromisers. But extremism need not be immoral. Howard’s legacy is to show all Americans that throughout our history when progress toward equality happens it is through it’s “agitators, radicals and ‘extremists’ – black and white together” who “are giving the United States it’s only living reminder that it was once a revolutionary nation.” I love Howard. ☺ Also the labeling of non-extremists as extremists, such as abolitionist William Lloyd Garrison, has long been the established technique to effectively sideline even these moderates as well as the true agitators in the public discourse.
It wasn’t until the Los Angeles Riots that the myth of “negro passivity” finally ended. On a more inclusive tone, Howard includes in these great essays Ella Baker saying, “Remember, we are not fighting for the freedom of the Negro alone but for the freedom of the human spirit, a larger spirit that encompasses all of mankind.” On the other non-inclusive hand, I found the best distillation of American racist white patriarchal thinking so far in this chilling true story of Howards: A Newsweek writer was bluntly told during the Civil Rights movement “We killed two-year-old Indian babes to get this country, and you want to give it to the niggers?”
Wide-open stand up solidarity across all color boundaries against such a mindset is our only hope in fighting the dominant white patriarchal capitalist culture. Another amazing book by Howard and a great preparation for reading bell hooks and Angela Davis…