Jack Hart has certainly edited some good book about men and sexuality.
But this starts to get a bit repetitive after a while, their first time mostly seems to be the perfect male species, with a large member, perfect steel blue eyes, perfect muscles and/or six packs who drives the American muscle car - I believe most of these stories are more fantasy than fact. Just to good to be true. Sadly I don't think one of the stories finished where the first time turned into a long-term relationship.
But if you are into fantasy (as gay men describe their first same-sex experience) then this is an interesting read.