Who is this for, exactly? That was the question I kept coming back to while reading Football for Dummies, which I read on a lark while perusing football-related titles on Audible. It was free, so why not? The difficulty of listening to such a diagram-heavy book, of course, led me to break down and buy it on Kindle, which I think was worth it. About a third, maybe half of Football for Dummies is informationally rich, and a great primer for those like me who want to go a bit deeper than the average fan, while not wanting to be totally overloaded with knowledge.
Yet, even in that task, Football for Dummies falls a bit short, spending too much time, for example, on outmoded defensive concepts. This is fine in a vacuum, of course, but the book gets pretty bogged down in trying to straddle historical stage-setting and actually explaining the game. To be fair, however, it's not like there's anything I could have reasonably expected to replace such content. Indeed, everything more I'd want from it would probably be unnecessary, since Long et al. do a good job of covering the fundamentals. Thus, while I was left wanting a little more, I think the bases are covered well enough to earn the "for Dummies" moniker.
Then again, there's so much dang fluff here, and to give it credit for how useful the meat-and-potatoes sections are is also to ignore the book's bizarre sequencing. You almost wonder if they needed to hit a page count: I'm sure few who pick up this book are particularly interested in the various "Top 10" lists that fill the back stretch of it, for example.
Ultimatelym Football for Dummies is a successful text for people who already have a mild interest in the sport, and it will serve them decently well as an informational tome. I don't think I'd give it to a football-agnostic partner, though, and it speaks to the difficulty of selling an incredibly complex, often dull game to those unconcerned with the fervent fandom surrounding it.