I first came across Anita Blake in the early '90s when the first books were coming out. I was living in St. Louis at the time, and my small circle of friends were all excited to see a series from a local author on the bookshelves, and with a unique take on fantasy: set in our own city, with a badass woman as the lead character. After a few volumes, I had gotten a little bored with the series and the new books got backlogged on my shelf, and then I stopped buying them at all. A few months ago, I decided to pick up the audiobook of this first of Anita's adventures... probably because it was cheap.
As we here in the 2020s know, there are a few things about this series that haven't aged well in the intervening 30-ish years. Let's get the worst out of the way: parts of it are quite rape-y. Many of the creatures of the night are not big on consent, whether it's Jean-Claude's putting a kind of territorial marker on Anita, or the actual threat of rape. Anita ends up afraid or terrified a lot of the time, and it's kind of cool that she isn't a stone-cold badass 100% of the time. But since so many of the horror situations are like this, it's an uncomfortable way of showing vulnerability in a character, to put it mildly.
Urban fantasy existed before Guilty Pleasures, but it didn't get huge until after Anita's debut. It isn't a genre that's aged all that well, or maybe it's more accurate to say it was a fad subgenre for a while but isn't anymore. The "girly ghetto"--the genre or category that women authors get shunted off to and then sneered at for writing same-y crap--has moved from UF to YA in the meantime.
And let's give an ironic salute to the cover. I switched to this version of the cover because it's the one that was used on the first edition (which I still have in a box somewhere), and it is so awful. It's evident throughout this book that Anita is reluctantly attracted to Jean-Claude, and here he doesn't look attractive at all. And that purple bar at the top of the cover makes the book look like it's under a romance or YA imprint. It has a cheesy charm, I guess. Speaking of things that haven't aged well, in the book Jean-Claude looks like a glam rocker, with shoulder-length hair and lace at his cuffs and collar... well, we thought that was pretty sexy at the time.
Moving on to other things. Anita has a kind of noir-ish narrative first-person voice. Since I haven't read any noir myself, I have to take other people's word about this. Anita inserts a lot of snarky quips into her narrative--"peachy," "bully for me," etc. She also uses lots of similes, some of which don't make much sense. She also says "dear God" a LOT. (and the narrator always delivered that line in a throaty voice which amused me more than it made me sympathize with her shock.) St. Louis has its fair share of night clubs and underground monster lairs and spooky graveyards, and a lot of the story takes place at night, so it does have a feeling of a dark or secret world that ordinary people only see if they end up being victims of it.
At the very beginning of the series, Anita's main power is that she's an animator, someone who can use animal sacrifices to raise the dead. I like how this power causes an internal conflict for Anita. She is religious enough that she can carry a cross around and have it actually affect vampires she comes across, since in this world holy symbols only work on vamps when one has strong faith. Since she believes that one's soul leaves this world after death, she considers vampires as non-human, as walking corpses. She sees her attraction to Jean-Claude as his attempting to control her emotions, rather than an attraction to a dead person, coming from within herself. There's a character she meets during this book who ends up dying and being brought back to life, and there's a scene that I found very affecting where she sends this zombie, who she knew personally during what ended up being the last part of their life, to their eternal rest.
I haven't said anything about the mystery in this book, and that's because I tend to think of mystery plots in UF as unimportant, or at best secondary to getting to know the characters and setting. Aside from Jean-Claude, who's a real standout in my opinion, there's Edward a.k.a. "Death," and Nikolaos (sp?) the thousand-year-old head vampire of St. Louis. Ronnie is a good supporting character for Anita, especially since it seems she doesn't get along with women all that well otherwise. Setting-wise, I didn't get a very strong sense of St. Louis as I remember it. Just a couple of images felt unique to it, the cobblestone streets of downtown being an example very early in the book. Maybe the city will be filled in with more detail later in the series.
The audiobook kind of bothered me at first. The producers added this really cheesy music during scenes with action or suspense, and it distracted me from the story. But once I got used to it, it was fun and made Anita's adventures feel like an entertaining B movie. I further amused myself by wondering if they'd break out some porn sax for the sex scenes later in the series. The narrator's silly accents for Jean-Claude and others added to the campy effect. The occasional times that things got a bit sexy or serious were done well, though.
I intend to keep listening to the audiobooks for a few more volumes, though I doubt I'll ever be up to date with the series, whether by listening or reading. There's the possibility of my having some kind of personal revolution where I make it past the first handful of volumes of a long series, but considering what I've heard about the quality of "Anita Blake, Vampire Hunter" after volume 10 or so, it's unlikely to be the one that starts that revolution.