RATING: 5/5; RECOMMENDS: 4.5/5
I have now discovered the pain of having a series I love that absolutely no one else has ever heard of. This and the first book are SO GOOD, I can’t believe I’ve never seen seen anyone on social talk about these books (aside from one Youtuber, which is how I discovered the series). I was so glad this book finally had an audiobook adaptation; I bought it and started listening to it immediately! I hope it won't take too long for the third one to be adapted because unless someone buys me a physical copy, that’ll probably be how I consume it.
Much like the first book, the characters make this story worth it. I actually enjoyed Corlis more this go-around now that he’s learned the value of politeness, occasionally holding his tongue, and is generally far less caustic. This is especially prominent in his relationship with Thessa, for whom he has an adorable softness; even when he snaps at her, it's clear it's a defense mechanism, not how he truly feels. Thessa is also fantastic; she’s lost some of her lingering naivety as she struggles to get used to the working-class lifestyle but still has an endearing touch of wide-eyed wonder. Her struggles with it never sound whiney; in fact, they are very relatable. And her fear of losing control and hurting people makes her incredibly sympathetic.
More importantly, the friendship between Corlis and Thessa is beautifully written. The two constantly look after one another, considering each other’s opinions and advice when making decisions. They always want good things for the other and try to protect the other, even at the expense of their own happiness. They cover each other’s weaknesses and complement each other's strengths, making them an impressive duo in the face of any obstacle. We should all hope to find a friendship like them one day.
That being said, Lorken’s absence is noticeable, and I was surprised he didn’t come up that much.
I enjoy Corlis and Thessa's struggle while surrounded by all this wealth. It's different for each of them: Corlis is entering this world for the first time, having technically been born into it but forced to live in poverty. While, for Thessa, this a return to a world she willingly left but misses the comforts of. Watching them ping-pong between liking this world of luxury and frills (Corlis having the added complication of this being his biological family and wanting to reject it and/or being suspicious of it. Again, it never comes across as whiney, which a lesser writer would have struggled with.
The little town in the majority of the story is set in is fascinating in both its similarities and differences to the grim, grimy, and poverty-stricken New Montres. While it appears calm, sparkling, clean, and privileged, it is just as full of secrets and lies. Even if I missed New Montres, the town serves as a fun place to visit but not to stay.
As for the plot, it is a delightful take on the classic whodunnit -much like the first book was a Steampunk-esc taken on a classic crime mystery. It reminds me of many of the Hercule Poirot novels and, amusingly enough, Knives Out. It was fun seeing how all the classic ‘rich family with dark secrets’ archetypes were adapted -right down to the Drunken Single Aunt. As a lover of these classic mysteries, this was a great treat.