2+
This one had promise and a lot of ideas going on and too little room to develop them. That and Devoti doesn't seem interested in development--character or plot. Her prose and approach are big-picture bold strokes, let's get to the action and not fuss over details. She writes at breakneck speed, and that's not always to the book's/character's credit.
The Norse mythology inclusion, the white witch, packs of hellhounds, witches among us in the mortal realm ... that's a lot. So much so the book got top heavy and lost its balance about midway through.
Given this was a library sale snag, I didn't pay it much attention beyond 'sure I'll give that a try.' Knowing now it's the establishing book in a six-book series explains some of the world-building glut. But that doesn't mean it couldn't have been handled better.
I didn't like the heroine or her sister.
Kara was a flibbertigibbet, until suddenly she wasn't, and it seems what gave her confidence was getting dicked down by a hellhound. I mean, fine -- and why not -- but let her have more than that as character development and finding her powers. She doesn't need to be a fearless super soldier, but she also wasn't given breakthroughs in agency or ability, which is too bad and keeps her rather flat.
Her childhood trauma is upsetting but holds far too much sway over her adult self. And since it's given so much weight, it's another imbalance that suddenly she has powers and the confidence to use them while still being largely clueless about everything, meaning she continues to blunder around ineffectually.
"Hunting for her missing sister" meant she returned to one place and one place only, repeatedly, made the same mistakes there again and again, and only by the intervention and jam-packed exposition of secondary characters did she fulfill her mission. Kind of.
What about her phone or her car and was the inclusion of the dead witch even necessary (no)? Why didn't Kara say, investigate her sister's things or diary or contacts or do some research after she recognized she had power? Or, easiest! keep the hero around longer and grill him for some insights (but why stop for dialogue and interactions when another action scene can be cued up).
Kelly (sister) was brash and, based on the scant history described plus subtext, lied to Kara most of their lives. Not great! And in this book she's the cookie-cutter of a 'badass chick,' which is tiring [I can't see as I'll want to read the book about her].
Why wouldn't Kelly have wanted to explore their likely magic -together- once she discovered hers? It's incredibly strange to paint them as ultra devoted identical twins and then have one be afraid of her own shadow and clueless, and the other go loner warrior Sarah Conner. If they were raised separately? Awesome dynamic. BFFs who live in the same house? Yeah, it doesn't track.
Both are bossy and don't listen and won't trust in ways that made little sense within the moment, both emotionally and practically. And that leeches impact from so many things.
It would have been great for Kara to say to her 'stronger' sister Kelly, look, I know the hero and I trust him, trust and rely on ME for once. And have them both Learn Something from that. But nope, the hero has to make something happen during an action scene, and the would-be emotional payoff for all of them muted because there's so much going on.
The hero Risk is potentially most interesting, but he forces himself to be a blank slate, so we don't get a lot of conflict from him, internal or otherwise. But he did get the biggest 'win' for me emotionally--freedom from the big baddie witch.
And then the book abruptly ends.
That ending was not the least satisfactory for all that came fast & furious before, particularly as the love story style was 'immediate compulsion.' I definitely don't mind a "drawn to you inexplicably but I know it's right" dynamic, but you gotta have more than relief they made it through to the end, a quick quip, and big winks they're gonna go bang to hang your HEA hat on.
Devoti clearly has fun writing action and big ideas, and no patience for the small stuff. That's not a dunk on my part so much as recognizing her style isn't a match to my reading sensibilities. I like action and big ideas, but want details and small stuff in quiet moments, interactions, and plot/character arcs that develop with more nuance and motivation than huge-explosion-to-huge-explosion.
Many times in many scenes I lost spatial sense of everything; it gets more glaring given Devoti is an action-heavy writer, including sex scenes being more physical and less emotional or with much foreplay.
I was annoyed Verge (hero's son) was given important character build and then otherwise had his future dismissed by his own father. And that Risk didn't get more from it than motivation to save all of them from the bad witch's clutches and oh well, good luck son. But!, learning this is the first of six, ahh I see. Verge will have a book all to himself soon.
This is actually an aspect of the unending series / series titles so many authors do that peeve me. Once a secondary or tertiary character is introducted, round them out as much as needed within the establishing book--don't handwave them via the leads, as that so often makes the leads seem unnecessarily callous or shallow.
Peeking at the other six in the series, meh, I'm in no rush to get them. Maybe if they surface at another library sale.