*I was provided with a copy of this book by the publisher, in exchange for my honest opinion.
The synopsis for The Bone Garden sounded so good and the cover was so striking, that I immediately wanted to pick it up and I’m so glad that I did. This was honestly such a great middle grade story, that can be enjoyed by all ages. It had a depth to it that older readers can appreciate, but it was still a story that was not over complicated and was just all in all, an easy read. The writing too, was beautiful and was impactful, but again, was simple, in the best way possible. It had this creepy and haunting atmosphere surrounding it, as if it was a ghost story being told around a fire, and its cover reflects this wonderfully. This had a more subdued and refined type of magic in it, but it was still fascinating and I loved it a lot, especially the label ‘bone dust’ and how the dust itself is used. I really like when a novel just has elements of magic in it, but the characters otherwise live in a non-magical world, it always makes the magic even more mysterious, precious and appealing.
The characters were all extremely well realised, especially Irréelle and Miss Vesper. I loved Irréelle immediately, she was just a pure and endearing soul. She honestly had a heart of gold and so it made me so frustrated, seeing her think so poorly of herself and be treated so badly by Miss Vesper. Irréelle just wanted to feel loved and like she belonged, to the point that she was always trying to find the good in Miss Vesper and was convinced that she wasn’t working hard enough to earn Miss Vesper’s love. I honestly just wanted to give her a big hug and tell her that she’s not the problem. Miss Vesper on the other hand was so brilliant for all the wrong reasons. She was such a menacing character, who was so ambiguous and elusive, yet her presence was always felt towering over Irréelle, whether she was actually present or not. She was extremely manipulative towards Irréelle and it was so sad to see. She really was the perfect example of how you don’t need to be physically intimidating or violent to dominate someone. She really was a real piece of work, and I only hated her so much because she was that well written.
Miss Vesper uses Irréelle to do the menial tasks that are required for her to do her magic and just about everything else. She sends Irréelle to the graveyard to collect the bone dust she needs to make things, like Irréelle, and restore herself from day to day. There are specific instructions to make the tea that restores Miss Vesper, collecting bone dust from different skeletons, from different body parts and of different amounts. Despite relying on Irréelle for this, Miss Vesper is constantly scolding her and cursing her name if she does even the slightest thing to displease her. Irréelle knows that she’s tethered to Miss Vesper in some way, as she’s the one who created her and Miss Vesper uses this to constantly manipulate and threaten Irréelle. She constantly tells her that she isn’t real, that she is misshapen and wrong, a figment of her imagination and therefore she can make her disappear if she wants to. Understandably, Irréelle is terrified that miss Vesper might ‘unmake’ her and so she does everything in her power to be perfect.
Irréelle has a very low opinion of herself as she’s been seriously mistreated, never standing up for herself. However, when she fears that Miss Vesper is going to finally follow through with her threats, she makes a desperate attempt to escape. What she finds in the tunnels on her escape run will change her world for ever, as she comes face to face with a boy for the first time and not just any boy. Irréelle has found the boy that Miss Vesper is constantly asking her if she’s heard on her errands before. Guy was the first of Miss Vesper’s creatures and he and Irréelle strike up a friendship after she helps him. Whilst on the run, they find themselves being saved by one of Miss Vesper’s most recent creations, a girl named Lass. Although they are all made from the same things and suffered Miss Vesper’s cruelty, Lass and Guy are very different to Irréelle. They are both strong characters, self assured and assertive, and see Miss Vesper for what she is, unlike Irréelle. Through her journey with these two, Irréelle experiences huge personal growth and I was so proud of her and it was so lovely to see her finally stick up for herself.
This was such a unique, dark and charming fantasy story and it would be perfect for younger readers who are fans of Tim Burton’s work. The characters and the story itself were so good, that I was constantly engaged, rooting for them and wanting to see what would happen next. It was so melancholy, but also beautiful and hopeful at times as well and I think that the way everything unraveled and panned out in the end was fantastic. This was an enjoyable experience with such an amazing cast of characters, I especially have a soft spot for the hand, which sounds so random, but you’ll see what I mean when you read it, The Bone Garden was just such a weird and wonderfully compelling story and I’d definitely recommend it.