What do you think?
Rate this book
Magic Most Foul #2
The Twisted Tragedy of Miss Natalie Stewart
I'm coming for you. The whispers haunt her dreams and fill her waking hours with dread. Something odd is happening. Something...unnatural. Possession of the living. Resurrection of the dead. And Natalie Stewart is caught right in the middle. Jonathon, the one person she thought she could trust, has become a double agent for the dark side. But he plays the part so well, Natalie has to wonder just how much he's really acting. She can't even see what it is she's fighting. But the cost of losing her heart, her sanity...her soul. Magic Most Foul Darker Still (Book 1) The Twisted Tragedy of Miss Natalie Stewart (Book 2) Praise for Darker Still , an Indie Next "Original, haunting, and romantic." ―YA Bound "This chilling tale will draw you in and keep you guessing until the very last page." ―Seventeen.com
336 pages, Paperback
First published November 1, 2012
30 people are currently reading
2653 people want to read
About the author
Leanna Renee Hieber
66 books1,097 followersAuthor, actress, artist and playwright, Leanna received a BFA in Theatre, a focus in the Victorian Era and a scholarship to study in London. She adapted 19th Century literature for the stage and her one-act plays have been produced around the country. She is a 4 time Prism Award winner for excellence in Futuristic, Fantasy, or Paranormal Romance. Her debut novel, The Strangely Beautiful Tale of Miss Percy Parker, first in the "Strangely Beautiful" saga of Gothic Victorian Fantasy novels (Barnes & Noble Bestseller) won two 2010 Prism Awards (Best Fantasy, Best First Book) has been hailed by Tor Books as a "foundation work of Gaslamp Fantasy" and has been reissued in new, revised editions as STRANGELY BEAUTIFUL. The prequel, PERILOUS PROPHECY and the never before published MISS VIOLET AND THE GREAT WAR finish the quartet (Tor Books). DARKER STILL: A Novel of Magic Most Foul was named an Indie Next title by the American Book Association and a Scholastic book fair "Highly Recommended" title. All books in the Magic Most Foul trilogy are now available as is THE ETERNA FILES trilogy of Gaslamp Fantasy novels (Tor Books). Her new series with Kensington's new Rebel Base imprint, THE SPECTRAL CITY, a Gaslamp Fantasy / Supernatural Suspense became a # 1 Amazon bestseller in Gaslamp Fantasy, Steampunk and Metaphysical Fantasy as well as hitting the top ten across other platforms. The series continues with three novels. Her short fiction has been included in anthologies such as QUEEN VICTORIA'S BOOK OF SPELLS and the MAMMOTH BOOK OF GASLAMP ROMANCE. All her Victorian-set series feature crossover characters. A member of the Science Fiction and Fantasy Writers of America, Mystery Writers of America and the International Thriller Writers, she is a proud co-founder of Lady Jane's Salon Reading Series in New York City. A member of Actors Equity Association and SAG-AFTRA, Leanna works often in film and television on shows like Boardwalk Empire and Mysteries at the Museum, works as a ghost tour guide for Boroughs of the Dead tour company and creates unique neo-Victorian and Steampunk jewelry on Etsy. In 2018 Leanna wrote, developed and now tours a one woman show "By the Light of Tiffany: A Meeting with Clara Driscoll" about the talented 19th century artist. Visit http://leannareneehieber.com for free reads, writers' resources, interviews, videos and more, and follow her on Twitter http://twitter.com/leannarenee and FB http://facebook.com/lrhieber.
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 131 reviews
November 26, 2012
The Twisted Tragedy of Miss Natalie Stewart picks up right where Darker Still leaves off, with Natalie and Denbury on a train out of New York in the aftermath of their confrontation with Denbury’s demon. It takes only a few paragraphs to remind me why Darker Still was such an interesting read, from its fairly unique epistolary form, telling the story through journal entries and newspaper clippings, to its take on gothic horror, almost like there’s a poetic quality to the writing, because luckily this sequel retains almost all of what the first book does right. Even though I have one or two issues with Natalie’s character and parts of the plot, I really think Natalie Stewart does a great job of building on the first book and setting up the third.
Actually, the biggest difference between Natalie Stewart and Darker Still is that this sequel doesn’t as strictly follow the epistolary form as Darker Still did. I really appreciated the found journal storytelling style of Darker Still, the same style as Bram Stoker’s Dracula, because it added to the mystery, reading the found words of this missing girl as part of the investigation into her disappearance , and even though Natalie Stewart, with all its events being told in real time, doesn’t have that same feel, it’s a good choice for this book to put me closer to the action. There’s this hospital scene for example, that’s definitely way spookier with Natalie narrating than if I’d read it from her journal, because with the chill in the air, the spirits all around, a demon on the loose, the danger is just palpable. And the letters, they’re not entirely gone, there are a couple of er interesting ones between Denbury and Natalie scattered throughout.
The plot really impressed me this go around, even if I have some slight issues with it. Darker Still was kind of predictable based on the summary, it’s fairly obvious what Natalie has to do to rescue Denbury, but this book presents a mystery that’s both horrifying and takes its time teasing at the specifics. There’s actually a parallel plot structure with two stories going on simultaneously, one Natalie battling Denbury’s demon who doesn’t seem to have quite been vanquished, and the other Natalie and Denbury getting to the bottom of the mysterious evil organization responsible for summoning the demon in the first place. My only disappointment is that I really felt the two plots would be more interconnected than they turned out to be, turns out, it feels like they best one foe, feel safe for a bit, and then the other strikes out of the blue. With Maggie. Who’s even crazier this time around. And Denbury’s friends Sam and Nate ended up being rather underused as a result. But even so, it’s still great gothic horror the entire way through, unsettling even when nothing bad in particular has happened, and downright creepy when evil’s finally revealed – the scene in the hospital, again, is stellar.
I’m not entirely a fan of Natalie’s character, she’s a bit too much for my liking, especially when she frets about the demon and ends up accusing Denbury or becomes suspicious of Ms. Northe for no apparent reason other than spending too much time with her father, but I’m a little of suspicious of Ms. Northe too. Yeah, I like her, she’s the kind of nice, supportive old lady character every heroine wishes she’d have on her side, but I understand Natalie’s thinking, Northe may be a little too good to be true. But that’s what makes her awesome. And between Natalie’s friend Rachel and Denbury’s pals, there really seems like there’s going to be a real fight between the good guys and that mysterious evil organization, the so called Society.
The last thing I’ll say is that Natalie Stewart really one ups Darker Still in the literary allusion department, and it’s really cool for any fan of classic gothic horror. A close or not too close reading reveals tons of references to Poe’s Fall of the House of Usher, Shelley’s Frankenstein, it’s really a shame Stoker’s Dracula I think is published a few years after these books are set. But it’s clear Hieber knows her gothic horror, and not only included the classic tone and atmosphere of the genre in her books, but even got the ideas in too, take a look at the descriptions of Nate’s play.
It’s no secret I’m a fan of gothic horror, and Darker Still is a pretty cool throwback to the classics. The Twisted Tragedy of Miss Natalie Stewart takes this series one step further, sets up the overarching conflict for what’s to come.
Actually, the biggest difference between Natalie Stewart and Darker Still is that this sequel doesn’t as strictly follow the epistolary form as Darker Still did. I really appreciated the found journal storytelling style of Darker Still, the same style as Bram Stoker’s Dracula, because it added to the mystery, reading the found words of this missing girl as part of the investigation into her disappearance , and even though Natalie Stewart, with all its events being told in real time, doesn’t have that same feel, it’s a good choice for this book to put me closer to the action. There’s this hospital scene for example, that’s definitely way spookier with Natalie narrating than if I’d read it from her journal, because with the chill in the air, the spirits all around, a demon on the loose, the danger is just palpable. And the letters, they’re not entirely gone, there are a couple of er interesting ones between Denbury and Natalie scattered throughout.
The plot really impressed me this go around, even if I have some slight issues with it. Darker Still was kind of predictable based on the summary, it’s fairly obvious what Natalie has to do to rescue Denbury, but this book presents a mystery that’s both horrifying and takes its time teasing at the specifics. There’s actually a parallel plot structure with two stories going on simultaneously, one Natalie battling Denbury’s demon who doesn’t seem to have quite been vanquished, and the other Natalie and Denbury getting to the bottom of the mysterious evil organization responsible for summoning the demon in the first place. My only disappointment is that I really felt the two plots would be more interconnected than they turned out to be, turns out, it feels like they best one foe, feel safe for a bit, and then the other strikes out of the blue. With Maggie. Who’s even crazier this time around. And Denbury’s friends Sam and Nate ended up being rather underused as a result. But even so, it’s still great gothic horror the entire way through, unsettling even when nothing bad in particular has happened, and downright creepy when evil’s finally revealed – the scene in the hospital, again, is stellar.
I’m not entirely a fan of Natalie’s character, she’s a bit too much for my liking, especially when she frets about the demon and ends up accusing Denbury or becomes suspicious of Ms. Northe for no apparent reason other than spending too much time with her father, but I’m a little of suspicious of Ms. Northe too. Yeah, I like her, she’s the kind of nice, supportive old lady character every heroine wishes she’d have on her side, but I understand Natalie’s thinking, Northe may be a little too good to be true. But that’s what makes her awesome. And between Natalie’s friend Rachel and Denbury’s pals, there really seems like there’s going to be a real fight between the good guys and that mysterious evil organization, the so called Society.
The last thing I’ll say is that Natalie Stewart really one ups Darker Still in the literary allusion department, and it’s really cool for any fan of classic gothic horror. A close or not too close reading reveals tons of references to Poe’s Fall of the House of Usher, Shelley’s Frankenstein, it’s really a shame Stoker’s Dracula I think is published a few years after these books are set. But it’s clear Hieber knows her gothic horror, and not only included the classic tone and atmosphere of the genre in her books, but even got the ideas in too, take a look at the descriptions of Nate’s play.
It’s no secret I’m a fan of gothic horror, and Darker Still is a pretty cool throwback to the classics. The Twisted Tragedy of Miss Natalie Stewart takes this series one step further, sets up the overarching conflict for what’s to come.
January 31, 2022
Oh gosh, the final? tentative? made-up title makes me super super nervous. I hope this one is as Denburylicious as the last,
Darker Still
.
December 31, 2013
This review is also available on my blog, Bows & Bullets Reviews
You would think that after all they went through in Darker Still, Natalie Stewart and Jonathan Whitby, Lord Denbury, had earned a reprieve from the dastardly spirits that wish them harm. Unfortunately, that is not the case. Their plan to get away from the negative magic, taking a vacation of sorts with Jonathan's old friends turns out badly when they realize that Samuel, Jonathan's pal, is unwittingly involved in the society that trapped Jonathan in that painting. So now, our dear Lord Denbury is back to London to do some investigating and Natalie is going back home to deal with a very upset father. It's obvious something new is afoot and that the old demon is not yet finished with out lovely couple. Can they finally defeat this foe or will their inevitable doom come sooner rather than later?
Natalie is a feisty heroine determined to save Jonathan (and herself), regardless of the cost. She has finally regained her ability to speak, though her voice does still desert her on occasion, but she's lost a bit of her fire. She's still haven't the clairvoyant dreams, predicting things she hopes never come to pass, and she's terrified they'll never be free of this mess. All she wants is to have a normal(ish) courtship with Jonathan, then marry and have that happily ever after that we all dream about. But the demon that possess Jonathan is still haunting her, along with the new nightmares about resurrection.
Jonathan was just as charming as all the British lords in historical romances normally are. Proper, with a hint of the rake hiding beneath the surface. It's hard to not feel sympathy for him, after being locked in a painting for years and now having to impersonate the monster who trapped him there, it's a miracle he doesn't lose his mind. He's obvious affection for Natalie is so cute. I adore him. He's definitely on my list of swoon-worthy males.
The side characters are all interesting in their own right. Mrs. Northe with her paranormal abilities and saving the day tendencies is a character I'd love to know more about. Her life with her late husband, her youth, and all things past because I feel that would be an intriguing tale. Rachel, who can't speak or hear people, but hears spirits speaking to her, is also fascinating. This poor girl gets tormented in these pages, but they'll sort it out. Then there is Nathaniel Veil. ::swoons:: He's plagued with melancholy. He is an actor and playwright, starring in a play about the sadder things in life, doing versions of Poe and the like. He's so flirty! If Denbury wasn't perfect for Natalie, I'd be throwing myself onto Team Nathaniel straight-away!
What this novel really excels at is the luscious writing. Hieber is a master of this beautiful style of writing that captivates you. Maybe I'm biased because I spent my teenage years devouring historical romance novels, but there is just something magical about this time period and Hieber always manages to do it justice. The novels only real fault is I feel like it was trying to tackle too much in just one short book. We've got the Natalie/Jonathan romance, then Jonathan impersonating a demon, Rachel being used for nefarious purposes, demonic possession, resurrection, and more. I feel like we should have focused a bit more on the resurrection than trying to look at the larger picture just yet. Also, it seemed like this one was just a tad more religious than the previous one. It didn't feel pushy, just Natalie's Christian faith was more prevalent than before.
It does suffer just a bit from middle book syndrome, not quite living up to Darker Still's awesomeness, but it's still completely enjoyable. Jonathan makes it worth it, not to mention meeting Nathaniel. This isn't exactly what I was expecting, but a bit more. It contains that mystical quality that I loved in the first one. It has love, adventure, and a bit of humor, what more can you want?
You would think that after all they went through in Darker Still, Natalie Stewart and Jonathan Whitby, Lord Denbury, had earned a reprieve from the dastardly spirits that wish them harm. Unfortunately, that is not the case. Their plan to get away from the negative magic, taking a vacation of sorts with Jonathan's old friends turns out badly when they realize that Samuel, Jonathan's pal, is unwittingly involved in the society that trapped Jonathan in that painting. So now, our dear Lord Denbury is back to London to do some investigating and Natalie is going back home to deal with a very upset father. It's obvious something new is afoot and that the old demon is not yet finished with out lovely couple. Can they finally defeat this foe or will their inevitable doom come sooner rather than later?
Natalie is a feisty heroine determined to save Jonathan (and herself), regardless of the cost. She has finally regained her ability to speak, though her voice does still desert her on occasion, but she's lost a bit of her fire. She's still haven't the clairvoyant dreams, predicting things she hopes never come to pass, and she's terrified they'll never be free of this mess. All she wants is to have a normal(ish) courtship with Jonathan, then marry and have that happily ever after that we all dream about. But the demon that possess Jonathan is still haunting her, along with the new nightmares about resurrection.
Jonathan was just as charming as all the British lords in historical romances normally are. Proper, with a hint of the rake hiding beneath the surface. It's hard to not feel sympathy for him, after being locked in a painting for years and now having to impersonate the monster who trapped him there, it's a miracle he doesn't lose his mind. He's obvious affection for Natalie is so cute. I adore him. He's definitely on my list of swoon-worthy males.
The side characters are all interesting in their own right. Mrs. Northe with her paranormal abilities and saving the day tendencies is a character I'd love to know more about. Her life with her late husband, her youth, and all things past because I feel that would be an intriguing tale. Rachel, who can't speak or hear people, but hears spirits speaking to her, is also fascinating. This poor girl gets tormented in these pages, but they'll sort it out. Then there is Nathaniel Veil. ::swoons:: He's plagued with melancholy. He is an actor and playwright, starring in a play about the sadder things in life, doing versions of Poe and the like. He's so flirty! If Denbury wasn't perfect for Natalie, I'd be throwing myself onto Team Nathaniel straight-away!
What this novel really excels at is the luscious writing. Hieber is a master of this beautiful style of writing that captivates you. Maybe I'm biased because I spent my teenage years devouring historical romance novels, but there is just something magical about this time period and Hieber always manages to do it justice. The novels only real fault is I feel like it was trying to tackle too much in just one short book. We've got the Natalie/Jonathan romance, then Jonathan impersonating a demon, Rachel being used for nefarious purposes, demonic possession, resurrection, and more. I feel like we should have focused a bit more on the resurrection than trying to look at the larger picture just yet. Also, it seemed like this one was just a tad more religious than the previous one. It didn't feel pushy, just Natalie's Christian faith was more prevalent than before.
It does suffer just a bit from middle book syndrome, not quite living up to Darker Still's awesomeness, but it's still completely enjoyable. Jonathan makes it worth it, not to mention meeting Nathaniel. This isn't exactly what I was expecting, but a bit more. It contains that mystical quality that I loved in the first one. It has love, adventure, and a bit of humor, what more can you want?
April 14, 2015
Book 2 starts off right where book one left off. Natalie and Jonathan are going to his friend Samuel to wait out the connector effects of the dark magic and because Jonathan is wanted for murders he didn’t comment. Then something drives Natalie and Jonathan back to New York. They are about to be thrown back into the society’s web but will they have the strength to beat them back again and for good?
You saw that Natalie and Jonathan had a connection in the last book but in this book you really see them get to know each other and really see how compatible they are. Natalie and Jonathan both grow as characters and in their romantic relationship. Jonathan is still coming to terms with his parent’s death,his imprisonment,and being back in his body. Natalie is still learning to use her voice and dealing with not just her new romance with Jonathan but her father’s romance with Mrs. Northe. So there are a lot of changes these two characters have to get used to. Jonathan plays what I like to call “Good Jonathan” and “Demon Jonathan” in this book. As he is working as a double agent to get information on the “The Society”.
You learn more about “The Society” in this book. Something of their beliefs,goals,and how far they are willing to go. You also meet one of “The Masters”. You also start to see a pattern of who “The Society” is targeting. People who would resist their rule and fight to take them down no matter what. They get sicker and sicker the more you know of them. I loved meeting Jonathan’s friends Samuel and Nathaniel. But I am in love with Nathaniel. He and his melancholy club are my people. I have felt what they felt and have seen the darkness and the light they have. I am really hoping there is more of them in book 3. Natalie’s friend Rachel was a surprise. A deaf mute girl who can hear the dead. She plays a big role in this book. You will see the author’s influences from the Gothic Greats in this book just as much as or more then book 1.
I loved this book more then book 1. I really got more connected to the characters now that Jonathan was back in this own body and got to see the two main characters get to know each other more and Jonathan being able to intact with other characters then Natalie added so much more to the story and their romance. I love paranormal romance and love these books being such a refreshing change to vampires,werewolves,angels,witches,ect… I am a huge believer in the supernatural and love how that element was wove so skillfully into book 2 just as it was in book 1. I highly recommend this series to anyone who loves paranormal romance but wants something unique to change it up or just paranormal romance lovers in general.
Rating: 5 out of 5
Content Rating: PG-13
You saw that Natalie and Jonathan had a connection in the last book but in this book you really see them get to know each other and really see how compatible they are. Natalie and Jonathan both grow as characters and in their romantic relationship. Jonathan is still coming to terms with his parent’s death,his imprisonment,and being back in his body. Natalie is still learning to use her voice and dealing with not just her new romance with Jonathan but her father’s romance with Mrs. Northe. So there are a lot of changes these two characters have to get used to. Jonathan plays what I like to call “Good Jonathan” and “Demon Jonathan” in this book. As he is working as a double agent to get information on the “The Society”.
You learn more about “The Society” in this book. Something of their beliefs,goals,and how far they are willing to go. You also meet one of “The Masters”. You also start to see a pattern of who “The Society” is targeting. People who would resist their rule and fight to take them down no matter what. They get sicker and sicker the more you know of them. I loved meeting Jonathan’s friends Samuel and Nathaniel. But I am in love with Nathaniel. He and his melancholy club are my people. I have felt what they felt and have seen the darkness and the light they have. I am really hoping there is more of them in book 3. Natalie’s friend Rachel was a surprise. A deaf mute girl who can hear the dead. She plays a big role in this book. You will see the author’s influences from the Gothic Greats in this book just as much as or more then book 1.
I loved this book more then book 1. I really got more connected to the characters now that Jonathan was back in this own body and got to see the two main characters get to know each other more and Jonathan being able to intact with other characters then Natalie added so much more to the story and their romance. I love paranormal romance and love these books being such a refreshing change to vampires,werewolves,angels,witches,ect… I am a huge believer in the supernatural and love how that element was wove so skillfully into book 2 just as it was in book 1. I highly recommend this series to anyone who loves paranormal romance but wants something unique to change it up or just paranormal romance lovers in general.
Rating: 5 out of 5
Content Rating: PG-13
April 20, 2020
Leanna's writing is as exquisite as ever, making the nineteenth century come alive in a way few other writers can. Where "Darker Still" was "Picture of Dorian Gray" updated, this book throws in the legend of Frankenstein for good measure. This book expands upon Darker Still, with new characters, and an ever-more menacing and omnipresent Society.
Natalie is a refreshing female protagonist - no damsel in distress, she takes charge and leads the fight against the bad guys. Also, thank god she and Denbury are wholly committed to each other and there's no love triangle. I do wish she wasn't quite so fussed about Denbury acting the double agent - it's called ACTING, he's not going all evil! - but I suppose there had to be some romantic strife.
I felt like the ending dragged on when it should have just stopped, but that's a relatively minor complaint.
Also, for Leanna's long-term fans, there's a delightful Easter egg in the form of a Strangely Beautiful cameo.
Bring on the third book of magic most foul!
ETA 2020: Upon rereading it, I'm happy to report the book holds up! I will add there was one thread that I didn't especially care for: Natalie's suspicion of Mrs. Northe felt sudden and unearned, when most of Darker Still was spent with Natalie rhapsodizing about Mrs. Northe's friendship. But this is a minor quibble amid a very enjoyable book!
Natalie is a refreshing female protagonist - no damsel in distress, she takes charge and leads the fight against the bad guys. Also, thank god she and Denbury are wholly committed to each other and there's no love triangle. I do wish she wasn't quite so fussed about Denbury acting the double agent - it's called ACTING, he's not going all evil! - but I suppose there had to be some romantic strife.
I felt like the ending dragged on when it should have just stopped, but that's a relatively minor complaint.
Also, for Leanna's long-term fans, there's a delightful Easter egg in the form of a Strangely Beautiful cameo.
Bring on the third book of magic most foul!
ETA 2020: Upon rereading it, I'm happy to report the book holds up! I will add there was one thread that I didn't especially care for: Natalie's suspicion of Mrs. Northe felt sudden and unearned, when most of Darker Still was spent with Natalie rhapsodizing about Mrs. Northe's friendship. But this is a minor quibble amid a very enjoyable book!
March 3, 2015
4.5 stars
The Twisted Tragedy of Miss Natalie Stewart starts off exactly where we left Natalie and Denbury in the first book- on the run across the country post the brush with the demon at the Metropolitan Museum. I found this book an extremely well thought-out and gripping follow up to Darker Still (whose conclusion seemed to be a granted from the first page). At the outset, I realised this book is not in form of a collection of diary entries like its prequel- a fact that add immediacy and urgency that the many action scenes demand. Still, Ms. Hieber's whimsical prose is at its poetic best- drawing on the emotions of the readers and absorbing them into her world.
The Twisted Tragedy ... builds past the novelty of Darker Still- as Denbury goes back to England to settle his affairs, and discovers a nefarious society behind all the happenings. He now must pretend to be on the dark side- pretend to be the demon that once took possession of him. At the same time, the demon imprisoned in Denbury's portrait is not quite gone, and they must destroy him before he breaks loose again. I was little let down by the fact that these two threads didn't breathe down their necks into a more gripping seat-of-your-pants narrative; rather it felt more like fighting one foe while the other is waiting backstage, and then once he is down, taking on the other.
We are introduced to the Rachel, Samuel and the wickedly delightful Nathaneil (you know I'll be keeping an eye out for him) And Jonathan! Out-of-the-portrait Jonathan lives up to his potential- at times fiercely protective, at times whimsical and teasing- his love holds steady as they tread long absences and vily opponents. His relationship with Natalie subtly changes from the giddy flush of infatuation to a more mature courtship. There are times when weary of staying strong, they doubt the other's love- but make no mistake, Jonathan and Natalie repeatedly step in front of the knife for the other, and save each other time and time again.
Love in its first bloom, all the poets said, was full of aching and impatience. So then was I. And so then was he.
The various other relationship threads- between Natalie and her deceased mother, Evelyn Northe and Mr. Stewart, and Natalie and her father are explored further. I loved that her father's hesitation over her relationship with 'the English lord' stemmed to his wanting a worthy suitor who could grant her the same level of freedom that he did. And then Denbury went and scored more brownie points from me when he did exactly that!
Since it's going to be a rather long and impatient wait to see what happens next, I leave you with the last haunting lines of the book
Some are born haunted. Some have haunts thrust upon them. We greet the dawn with full understanding of the shadows at our backs. Together, we find solace and kindle the fires that will keep us warm and hold us firmly in the light.
The Twisted Tragedy of Miss Natalie Stewart starts off exactly where we left Natalie and Denbury in the first book- on the run across the country post the brush with the demon at the Metropolitan Museum. I found this book an extremely well thought-out and gripping follow up to Darker Still (whose conclusion seemed to be a granted from the first page). At the outset, I realised this book is not in form of a collection of diary entries like its prequel- a fact that add immediacy and urgency that the many action scenes demand. Still, Ms. Hieber's whimsical prose is at its poetic best- drawing on the emotions of the readers and absorbing them into her world.
The Twisted Tragedy ... builds past the novelty of Darker Still- as Denbury goes back to England to settle his affairs, and discovers a nefarious society behind all the happenings. He now must pretend to be on the dark side- pretend to be the demon that once took possession of him. At the same time, the demon imprisoned in Denbury's portrait is not quite gone, and they must destroy him before he breaks loose again. I was little let down by the fact that these two threads didn't breathe down their necks into a more gripping seat-of-your-pants narrative; rather it felt more like fighting one foe while the other is waiting backstage, and then once he is down, taking on the other.
We are introduced to the Rachel, Samuel and the wickedly delightful Nathaneil (you know I'll be keeping an eye out for him) And Jonathan! Out-of-the-portrait Jonathan lives up to his potential- at times fiercely protective, at times whimsical and teasing- his love holds steady as they tread long absences and vily opponents. His relationship with Natalie subtly changes from the giddy flush of infatuation to a more mature courtship. There are times when weary of staying strong, they doubt the other's love- but make no mistake, Jonathan and Natalie repeatedly step in front of the knife for the other, and save each other time and time again.
Love in its first bloom, all the poets said, was full of aching and impatience. So then was I. And so then was he.
The various other relationship threads- between Natalie and her deceased mother, Evelyn Northe and Mr. Stewart, and Natalie and her father are explored further. I loved that her father's hesitation over her relationship with 'the English lord' stemmed to his wanting a worthy suitor who could grant her the same level of freedom that he did. And then Denbury went and scored more brownie points from me when he did exactly that!
Since it's going to be a rather long and impatient wait to see what happens next, I leave you with the last haunting lines of the book
Some are born haunted. Some have haunts thrust upon them. We greet the dawn with full understanding of the shadows at our backs. Together, we find solace and kindle the fires that will keep us warm and hold us firmly in the light.
December 4, 2012
Let me start by saying that this book is so much better than the first in the series. I enjoyed the first, but I really didn't feel the connection between Natalie and Denbury. In this book however, that connection is vibrant and so much more complex than it ever was in the first book. Leanna is an incredible writer, not only because of the amazing world she has created within the pages but the level of emotions the words that she writes can bring. It's such a gripping story, that I found to be almost poetic in nature.
There are a lot of things you need when it comes to a good story. And you really get to see a lot of them in this second installment to this series. The main characters are more pronounced, as far as when they are talked about together. And even the other characters in this book are much more enjoyable than the ones in the first, even though several do cross over.
It's just a really elegant, dark, exciting and romantic story. I think those words are some of the best to describe it. But it is also surprisingly unique. There is just something about it that gives off this amazing vibe that I found to be quite enjoyable. I wouldn't go as far as to say that this book is a favorite, but there is no doubting the fact that this is an incredibly story written by an author that really knows what she is doing and knows how to really connect you with a story. I'm not really sure if there was much more I would of hoped to see in this second book, simply because it was such a huge improvement compared to the first one.
I'm really hoping this series continues, it feels like things could go on from here especially after the ending. I really, really enjoyed the ending. Leanna did a wonderful job wrapping things together, and the way it was done just felt so unique and I think that is testament to her skill as a writer. By far one of the better endings to a book that I have read.
Book two really helps bring this series together though, especially after my issues with the first. If you're looking to get into the series I would highly suggest it. Even if you have the same problems I did with the first book, hopefully this one will make up for it all like it did for me. And hopefully there will be a third book coming in the series, even though I wasn't really able to find out and information about one.
There are a lot of things you need when it comes to a good story. And you really get to see a lot of them in this second installment to this series. The main characters are more pronounced, as far as when they are talked about together. And even the other characters in this book are much more enjoyable than the ones in the first, even though several do cross over.
It's just a really elegant, dark, exciting and romantic story. I think those words are some of the best to describe it. But it is also surprisingly unique. There is just something about it that gives off this amazing vibe that I found to be quite enjoyable. I wouldn't go as far as to say that this book is a favorite, but there is no doubting the fact that this is an incredibly story written by an author that really knows what she is doing and knows how to really connect you with a story. I'm not really sure if there was much more I would of hoped to see in this second book, simply because it was such a huge improvement compared to the first one.
I'm really hoping this series continues, it feels like things could go on from here especially after the ending. I really, really enjoyed the ending. Leanna did a wonderful job wrapping things together, and the way it was done just felt so unique and I think that is testament to her skill as a writer. By far one of the better endings to a book that I have read.
Book two really helps bring this series together though, especially after my issues with the first. If you're looking to get into the series I would highly suggest it. Even if you have the same problems I did with the first book, hopefully this one will make up for it all like it did for me. And hopefully there will be a third book coming in the series, even though I wasn't really able to find out and information about one.
November 18, 2012
4.5 Stars
'The Twisted Tragedy of Miss Natalie Stewart' is the second book in the Magic Most Foul series - a young adult paranormal series that follows Natalie Stewart as she continues to unravel the mystery behind Lord Denbury and the dark magic surrounding him. Once Denbury is accused of murder, things take an unexpected twist and he must travel to England to stop the demon that has taken his form. Natalie begins to suspect his true motives and must determine what's real and what's dark magic before it's too late for both Denbury and herself.
This is a fantastically unique and absorbing second book in an exciting and mysterious paranormal series. The characters are completely realistic and likable, especially the heroine of Natalie, who is not the usual main character seen in most novels. Denbury proves to be a dashingly handsome and mysterious character and he keeps both Natalie and the reader on their toes trying to figure him out. The setting of the novel is very richly detailed and full of descriptions that easily enable the reader to immerse themselves in the environment. The Victorian era New York and England fit the scene perfectly for the creepy storyline. The plot itself is refreshing and utterly unique - there isn't anything else like it out there. It breathes fresh air and a wonderful new voice into the YA paranormal genre. The narrative is set up as journal entries by Natalie with some newspaper articles and letters mixed in, much like a real journal would contain. I think this way of presenting the story brings the reader deeper into the thoughts and feelings of Natalie and thus gives us an inside view of the events as they unfold. The book is very well written and fast paced, which made this impossible to put down. There is a great mix of genres - paranormal, action, mystery, adventure, and romance - that's sure to keep readers enthralled. Overall, this is an enchanting second book in a refreshingly unique series that readers will simply devour.
Disclosure: I received a copy of the book in exchange for an honest review.
'The Twisted Tragedy of Miss Natalie Stewart' is the second book in the Magic Most Foul series - a young adult paranormal series that follows Natalie Stewart as she continues to unravel the mystery behind Lord Denbury and the dark magic surrounding him. Once Denbury is accused of murder, things take an unexpected twist and he must travel to England to stop the demon that has taken his form. Natalie begins to suspect his true motives and must determine what's real and what's dark magic before it's too late for both Denbury and herself.
This is a fantastically unique and absorbing second book in an exciting and mysterious paranormal series. The characters are completely realistic and likable, especially the heroine of Natalie, who is not the usual main character seen in most novels. Denbury proves to be a dashingly handsome and mysterious character and he keeps both Natalie and the reader on their toes trying to figure him out. The setting of the novel is very richly detailed and full of descriptions that easily enable the reader to immerse themselves in the environment. The Victorian era New York and England fit the scene perfectly for the creepy storyline. The plot itself is refreshing and utterly unique - there isn't anything else like it out there. It breathes fresh air and a wonderful new voice into the YA paranormal genre. The narrative is set up as journal entries by Natalie with some newspaper articles and letters mixed in, much like a real journal would contain. I think this way of presenting the story brings the reader deeper into the thoughts and feelings of Natalie and thus gives us an inside view of the events as they unfold. The book is very well written and fast paced, which made this impossible to put down. There is a great mix of genres - paranormal, action, mystery, adventure, and romance - that's sure to keep readers enthralled. Overall, this is an enchanting second book in a refreshingly unique series that readers will simply devour.
Disclosure: I received a copy of the book in exchange for an honest review.
October 24, 2012
See the full review at:
Read My Mind
It's funny that I happened to read THE TWISTED TALE OF MISS NATALIE STEWART just before I read another gothic tale. Perhaps, after reading this wonderful addition to the DARKER STILL series, I still had a taste for a good gothic mystery. Regardless, this book continued the tale of Natalie Stewart and her love, Jonathan Denbury. having been rescued from the painting that he was trapped in, the two embark on a journey (figuratively and literally, at points) to find and uncover the villain they can't seem to shed. I've already slightly spoiled DARKER STILL, the first book in the series, and to avoid major spoilers for both, I won't speak too much on the plot.
However, Natalie has regained her voice, which makes her part in discovering more about the demon that walked about as Jonathan slightly easier, as now she can talk to her confidantes and help Jonathan don the personality of his demon doppelganger. In DARKER STILL, Natalie is an intelligent young woman, and rather unlike the truth of a majority of Victorian women. She has a freedom that is seldom contained, and a sharp mind that the reader gets to experience more of in THE TWISTED TRAGEDY OF MISS NATALIE STEWART.
What I like about Leanna Renee Hieber's writing is that is has little touches here and there that seem to go beyond one-dimentional research. There is an authenticity employed in the dress, the speech, and the personalities that seem impossible for someone who could never have experienced Victorian or Gaslamp society themselves.
THE TWISTED TRAGEDY OF MISS NATALIE STEWART was all that I could hope for in a follow-up to DARKER STILL. Everything that I liked about the characters from the first book has perfect continuity in this one. Hieber knows how to spin a great tale, where the setting is just as important as the story, and she captured my interest with the unusual tale of Denbury and Natalie. Starting out as a tribute to the Dorian Grey idea, the series has gone beyond what most know about the "picture". Hieber has molded and twisted the idea into her own with great success.
Book Rating:
13/15
4 Stars
A-
GoodReads
Barnes and Noble | Indiebound | Amazon
It's funny that I happened to read THE TWISTED TALE OF MISS NATALIE STEWART just before I read another gothic tale. Perhaps, after reading this wonderful addition to the DARKER STILL series, I still had a taste for a good gothic mystery. Regardless, this book continued the tale of Natalie Stewart and her love, Jonathan Denbury. having been rescued from the painting that he was trapped in, the two embark on a journey (figuratively and literally, at points) to find and uncover the villain they can't seem to shed. I've already slightly spoiled DARKER STILL, the first book in the series, and to avoid major spoilers for both, I won't speak too much on the plot.
However, Natalie has regained her voice, which makes her part in discovering more about the demon that walked about as Jonathan slightly easier, as now she can talk to her confidantes and help Jonathan don the personality of his demon doppelganger. In DARKER STILL, Natalie is an intelligent young woman, and rather unlike the truth of a majority of Victorian women. She has a freedom that is seldom contained, and a sharp mind that the reader gets to experience more of in THE TWISTED TRAGEDY OF MISS NATALIE STEWART.
What I like about Leanna Renee Hieber's writing is that is has little touches here and there that seem to go beyond one-dimentional research. There is an authenticity employed in the dress, the speech, and the personalities that seem impossible for someone who could never have experienced Victorian or Gaslamp society themselves.
THE TWISTED TRAGEDY OF MISS NATALIE STEWART was all that I could hope for in a follow-up to DARKER STILL. Everything that I liked about the characters from the first book has perfect continuity in this one. Hieber knows how to spin a great tale, where the setting is just as important as the story, and she captured my interest with the unusual tale of Denbury and Natalie. Starting out as a tribute to the Dorian Grey idea, the series has gone beyond what most know about the "picture". Hieber has molded and twisted the idea into her own with great success.
Book Rating:
13/15
4 Stars
A-
GoodReads
Barnes and Noble | Indiebound | Amazon
January 24, 2013
This review originally posted at More Than Just Magic
Way back in 2011 I read and reviewed Darker Still, the first book in the Magic Most Foul series by Leanna Renee Hieber. It was dark and dramatic and had this amazing gothic feel to it. And there was Lord Denbury. Yum. It was just an excellent and exciting book.
The Twisted Tragedy of Miss Natalie Stewart, book two in the series promised more of the same. More adventure, more romance, more Lord Denbury. And now Natalie can speak! You get to experience the adventure alongside of her, instead of after the fact through journal entries. Needless to say I was excited to get my hands on a copy of this book. I couldn’t wait to see where the adventure took Natalie and Jonathan next.
But despite all my excitement and my love for Darker Still I couldn’t help but be a little disappointed when I finally sat down to read this book. Right off the bat it didn’t have that same gothic, creepy Dorian Grey feel that Darker Still had. It still had so much great detail and the time period seemed quite authentic. But the tone felt different. Maybe it was the change of writing styles. Everything was so much more straightforward and it didn’t carry that air of mystery that Natalie’s diary entries had. I think by giving us more information it took away some of the suspense – which was one of the elements I loved the most.
Related to the lack of suspense, was the slower pacing. With Natalie’s diary entries we were restricted to just the highlights of the events unfolding. No one spends a ton of time writing down the mundane details in their diary. But in The Twisted Tragedy of Miss Natalie Stewart there is so much time spent worrying and talking about how dangerous everything is and what their plan should be. Some scenes felt like they dragged a little and at times the plot could be difficult to follow.
On the positive side there is this insane hospital scene. It is incredibly creepy and intense and was by far my favourite part of the entire novel. I can’t say too much about it since it’s at the end of the book but I think the entire sluggish journey was worth it to get to the drama and suspense of this scene. It had me on the edge of my seat wondering what was going to happen and if all the characters would make it out alive.
The Twisted Tragedy of Miss Natalie Stewart is an interesting continuation of the Magic Most Foul series. There’s a lot of detail which is both a positive and a negative. It made it feel very vivid but sometimes I got bogged down with all the little facts and pieces. But in the end I was left mostly impressed with the complex tale Leanna Renee Hieber has weaved and are intrigued about what will happen next.
Recommendation: If you enjoyed Darker Still I think it is worth it to continue on with this series. The Twisted Tragedy of Miss Natalie Stewart is not nearly as enjoyable but it does answer some questions and the final few scenes leave you eager to find out what will happen to these characters next.
Way back in 2011 I read and reviewed Darker Still, the first book in the Magic Most Foul series by Leanna Renee Hieber. It was dark and dramatic and had this amazing gothic feel to it. And there was Lord Denbury. Yum. It was just an excellent and exciting book.
The Twisted Tragedy of Miss Natalie Stewart, book two in the series promised more of the same. More adventure, more romance, more Lord Denbury. And now Natalie can speak! You get to experience the adventure alongside of her, instead of after the fact through journal entries. Needless to say I was excited to get my hands on a copy of this book. I couldn’t wait to see where the adventure took Natalie and Jonathan next.
But despite all my excitement and my love for Darker Still I couldn’t help but be a little disappointed when I finally sat down to read this book. Right off the bat it didn’t have that same gothic, creepy Dorian Grey feel that Darker Still had. It still had so much great detail and the time period seemed quite authentic. But the tone felt different. Maybe it was the change of writing styles. Everything was so much more straightforward and it didn’t carry that air of mystery that Natalie’s diary entries had. I think by giving us more information it took away some of the suspense – which was one of the elements I loved the most.
Related to the lack of suspense, was the slower pacing. With Natalie’s diary entries we were restricted to just the highlights of the events unfolding. No one spends a ton of time writing down the mundane details in their diary. But in The Twisted Tragedy of Miss Natalie Stewart there is so much time spent worrying and talking about how dangerous everything is and what their plan should be. Some scenes felt like they dragged a little and at times the plot could be difficult to follow.
On the positive side there is this insane hospital scene. It is incredibly creepy and intense and was by far my favourite part of the entire novel. I can’t say too much about it since it’s at the end of the book but I think the entire sluggish journey was worth it to get to the drama and suspense of this scene. It had me on the edge of my seat wondering what was going to happen and if all the characters would make it out alive.
The Twisted Tragedy of Miss Natalie Stewart is an interesting continuation of the Magic Most Foul series. There’s a lot of detail which is both a positive and a negative. It made it feel very vivid but sometimes I got bogged down with all the little facts and pieces. But in the end I was left mostly impressed with the complex tale Leanna Renee Hieber has weaved and are intrigued about what will happen next.
Recommendation: If you enjoyed Darker Still I think it is worth it to continue on with this series. The Twisted Tragedy of Miss Natalie Stewart is not nearly as enjoyable but it does answer some questions and the final few scenes leave you eager to find out what will happen to these characters next.
November 5, 2012
This review also appears on my blog at http://www.thegoldenruleof666.blogspo...
Excellent, delightfully creepy, and darkly romantic! I loved this book!
I have to say, I was immensely worried when I saw the title to this book. "Twisted Tragedy" doesn't sound like a book where the main character gets to be happy with her incredibly hot true love. But, after reading it, I understand why the title is as it is. Natalie's life has become a twisted life and it seems like a tragedy to her. The complex network of those who work in the Society, those who might join, and those who fight against it is truly twisted and everything that Natalie has to go through definitely seems like a tragedy. But, worry not, Natalie and Johnathan still have their sweet romance, despite a few hiccups along the way.
Natalie has changed from book one to book two. She's both stronger and more vulnerable. She handles everything the Society throws at her and does her best to overcome it. But confusion of the complexity of her situation leaves her at loss a few times. However, she still handled it admirably and grew as a character.
We get to know Johnathan much more throughout this book. We see his strength, his determination to protect everyone that he can and help as many people as he can. And as we see him working as a double agent, he shows himself to be clever and devious when he needs to be. Add to that we see him act as a proper gentleman and you have a recipe to make me adore him all the more. I adored Johnathan even more by the end of this book. And Natalie and Johnathan's relationship deepens. They come to know one another better and their fledgling love becomes more real. I really felt that depth of emotion between them. And I thought it was so sweet how the two of them saved each other constantly and were always stronger when they were together. Their relationship just made me smile.
The plot of book two is as thrilling as book one. Never a dull moment and constant surprises in store, The Twisted Tragedy of Miss Natalie Stewart will keep you hooked all the way through. The ending left us with a sweet note as Natalie and Johnathan determine to have one normal day of courting in between all the madness. And there is a nice lead in to book three that has me itching to find out what happens next.
The Twisted Tragedy of Miss Natalie Stewart is just magnificent. I adored it!
5/5
Excellent, delightfully creepy, and darkly romantic! I loved this book!
I have to say, I was immensely worried when I saw the title to this book. "Twisted Tragedy" doesn't sound like a book where the main character gets to be happy with her incredibly hot true love. But, after reading it, I understand why the title is as it is. Natalie's life has become a twisted life and it seems like a tragedy to her. The complex network of those who work in the Society, those who might join, and those who fight against it is truly twisted and everything that Natalie has to go through definitely seems like a tragedy. But, worry not, Natalie and Johnathan still have their sweet romance, despite a few hiccups along the way.
Natalie has changed from book one to book two. She's both stronger and more vulnerable. She handles everything the Society throws at her and does her best to overcome it. But confusion of the complexity of her situation leaves her at loss a few times. However, she still handled it admirably and grew as a character.
We get to know Johnathan much more throughout this book. We see his strength, his determination to protect everyone that he can and help as many people as he can. And as we see him working as a double agent, he shows himself to be clever and devious when he needs to be. Add to that we see him act as a proper gentleman and you have a recipe to make me adore him all the more. I adored Johnathan even more by the end of this book. And Natalie and Johnathan's relationship deepens. They come to know one another better and their fledgling love becomes more real. I really felt that depth of emotion between them. And I thought it was so sweet how the two of them saved each other constantly and were always stronger when they were together. Their relationship just made me smile.
The plot of book two is as thrilling as book one. Never a dull moment and constant surprises in store, The Twisted Tragedy of Miss Natalie Stewart will keep you hooked all the way through. The ending left us with a sweet note as Natalie and Johnathan determine to have one normal day of courting in between all the madness. And there is a nice lead in to book three that has me itching to find out what happens next.
The Twisted Tragedy of Miss Natalie Stewart is just magnificent. I adored it!
5/5
September 24, 2012
I am so thankful that I was able to read this ARC from Around The World ARC Tours. I have to say that this book was a long awaited and anticipated book for me. When I read Darker Still I was so drawn into the world of Jonathan and Natalie that it was hard for me to put it down.
In the continuation of Jonathan and Natalie's story they are on the run and are trying to figure who is killing all the girls in New York. Mrs Northe is helping them and vows to find out what is really going on but Natalie starts to think that something is not right. There is definitely something going on with Jonathan and as they are on their way to England to find the truth a man recognizes Jonathan and makes a scene on the train. But Natalie and Jonathan assure the train conductor that he is an English man on his way to England for vacation.
Once they get to England Jonathan starts to act weirder but Natalie is determined to find out what is going on and why he is being framed for all those murders.While she is there she meets someone and he begins to put doubts in her heart about Jonathan. As Natalie struggles to find the truth out with Mrs Northe she will have to face the facts that their is something out there that wants Jonathan and her. When all the secrets are revealed and the dust settles Natalie will have to trust her instincts in order to survive. What will Natalie uncover? Will Jonathan's name be cleared? Is Jonathan hiding something from Natalie and Mrs Northe? Come along for the greatest ride of a lifetime and enjoy this story as it unfolds! Leanna you have created such a great world and I look forward to reading more from you.
In the continuation of Jonathan and Natalie's story they are on the run and are trying to figure who is killing all the girls in New York. Mrs Northe is helping them and vows to find out what is really going on but Natalie starts to think that something is not right. There is definitely something going on with Jonathan and as they are on their way to England to find the truth a man recognizes Jonathan and makes a scene on the train. But Natalie and Jonathan assure the train conductor that he is an English man on his way to England for vacation.
Once they get to England Jonathan starts to act weirder but Natalie is determined to find out what is going on and why he is being framed for all those murders.While she is there she meets someone and he begins to put doubts in her heart about Jonathan. As Natalie struggles to find the truth out with Mrs Northe she will have to face the facts that their is something out there that wants Jonathan and her. When all the secrets are revealed and the dust settles Natalie will have to trust her instincts in order to survive. What will Natalie uncover? Will Jonathan's name be cleared? Is Jonathan hiding something from Natalie and Mrs Northe? Come along for the greatest ride of a lifetime and enjoy this story as it unfolds! Leanna you have created such a great world and I look forward to reading more from you.
December 5, 2012
Natalie Stewart was hoping that she would be able to lead a somewhat normal life, now that her beloved Jonathan Whitby, Lord Denbury is freed from his prison. But they soon realize that Jonathan is wanted for murder and he must return to his native England to try and figure out what happened to his parents and exactly why he was imprisioned. But the Majesty Society is spreading and Jonathan is forced to play the double agent while trying to determine exactly what it is they plan to do.
I didn't read the first book in this series (Darker Still), but it didn't matter as I found myself instantly pulled into a wonderfully crafted world where paranormal elements mixed with historical turn of the century America (or close to it). Even more, I loved that an eighteen year old girl (mute for most of her life) was given such a strong character to not only save her Prince Charming once before, but to delve into the world of magic and demons to prevent worse things from happening.
And while there was all sorts of bad and weird things happening around Jonathan and Natalie, they managed to keep each other grounded and knew when levity needed to be added to the situation. They didn't have much time for romance or wooing, but when they did get those moments, it was clear that these two were meant for each other.
I look forward to more in this series (which includes reading the first book). I must know who is after Natalie and what's in store next from the Majesty.
I didn't read the first book in this series (Darker Still), but it didn't matter as I found myself instantly pulled into a wonderfully crafted world where paranormal elements mixed with historical turn of the century America (or close to it). Even more, I loved that an eighteen year old girl (mute for most of her life) was given such a strong character to not only save her Prince Charming once before, but to delve into the world of magic and demons to prevent worse things from happening.
And while there was all sorts of bad and weird things happening around Jonathan and Natalie, they managed to keep each other grounded and knew when levity needed to be added to the situation. They didn't have much time for romance or wooing, but when they did get those moments, it was clear that these two were meant for each other.
I look forward to more in this series (which includes reading the first book). I must know who is after Natalie and what's in store next from the Majesty.
September 8, 2014
Natalie Stewart is dealing with a lot of issues, not least of which is Jonathan, they have some clues about the secretive group that put Jonathan in the painting and they're trying to find out more, but this requires that Jonathan plays the part of the other who invaded his life, which makes Natalie suspicious. Add in a jealous friend and another friend who is troubled by what she is being asked to do and you get a melange of issues and stories and a bridging novel.
It just didn't seem to take long enough for things to develop and the father's reaction seemed a little off, they would have been married off much earlier than that after the (rail)road trip and she probably would have been ostracised from society if not. Marriage wasn't always because of love in the period and they could have kept the illusion of him being evil going and it would have helped them with their mission. Add to this the fact that it wouldn't have been strange for her to keep living at her father's house until Jonathan had them "settled" and you get something that jarred a little.
It's a somewhat minor thing but it is how the society of the time worked and while they might rail against it, it would have been how it would have been rescued, also there would have been pressure put to bear from not only her father but also some friends.
Not a bad read, just doesn't feel like early 20th century period.
It just didn't seem to take long enough for things to develop and the father's reaction seemed a little off, they would have been married off much earlier than that after the (rail)road trip and she probably would have been ostracised from society if not. Marriage wasn't always because of love in the period and they could have kept the illusion of him being evil going and it would have helped them with their mission. Add to this the fact that it wouldn't have been strange for her to keep living at her father's house until Jonathan had them "settled" and you get something that jarred a little.
It's a somewhat minor thing but it is how the society of the time worked and while they might rail against it, it would have been how it would have been rescued, also there would have been pressure put to bear from not only her father but also some friends.
Not a bad read, just doesn't feel like early 20th century period.
December 3, 2016
It has been a couple years since I read Darker Still, so my memory of the details was a bit faded. Luckily there were plenty of clues and revisits of the important parts to keep the story coherent. I absolutely love the writing style of this book. I felt like every scene was perfectly described, but not by being overly wordy, rather providing a perfect canvas for the imagination to fill in the gaps. I thoroughly enjoyed Nathaniel's literary theatrical performance and could imagine myself being one of his melancholy followers all dressed in black. The low-lit corridor that Natalie often dreams of, is also a reoccurring dream of mine, and it surprised me that it could be so similar. As for the story, I was three-quarters and wondered how everything could possibly be wrapped up in such a short amount of time. The question remains, will Jonathon and Natalie's fate remain haunted and tragic or will they become soldiers in the battle against evil and win their happily ever after?
March 30, 2014
This was quite a reprieve from the second book syndrome I've seen in other trilogies. Filled with suspense, this book gave us answers while piling up questions at the same time.
I loved Natalie and Jonathon. Their relationship has many facets and they struggle to deal with them all. One of my favorite scenes was when Jonathon met Natalie's father. To see them deal with such a normal situation amidst such abnormal circumstances was fun.
Of course the ending was a bit of a cliffhanger. I can't wait to get my greedy hands on the last book.
I loved Natalie and Jonathon. Their relationship has many facets and they struggle to deal with them all. One of my favorite scenes was when Jonathon met Natalie's father. To see them deal with such a normal situation amidst such abnormal circumstances was fun.
Of course the ending was a bit of a cliffhanger. I can't wait to get my greedy hands on the last book.
December 6, 2012
I still had the feeling of can't-put-it-down I-want-to-finish-it-now. Unfortunately, most of the action happens in the last 30-50 pages so there are a lot more scenes of Natalie writing, avoiding thinking about Jonathan, etc. The writing was still decent, I just wish the action/adventure was more spread out through the book to make it move more smoothly. That said, the action was very intense and the imagery was particularly gruesome (in a good way). I'm assuming there will be another book in the series and I'll most likely pick it up, just more hesitantly this time.
November 24, 2012
A fantastic go by Hieber who I already consider to be the master of the Victorian supernatural yarn. A fun, adventurous, and romantic story that even manages to make its few flaws charming. Interesting characters, interesting view of history. This is the YA I love to see, intelligent and full of heart.
November 16, 2012
more later
Back. And I don't really have anything to add here. A good Gothic story, plenty of atmosphere.
Also: We're onto you Leanna Hieber. Only a blind reader wouldn't notice that you cast Tom Hiddleston as Nate. Well played, madame. Well played.
Back. And I don't really have anything to add here. A good Gothic story, plenty of atmosphere.
Also: We're onto you Leanna Hieber. Only a blind reader wouldn't notice that you cast Tom Hiddleston as Nate. Well played, madame. Well played.
March 6, 2017
Loved to reread this book, and my hopes came true, now to read 3rd book now, yeah!
*First read Feburary 3rd 2013*
Great book, great to see these characters again, I'm hoping for a 3rd book!
*First read Feburary 3rd 2013*
Great book, great to see these characters again, I'm hoping for a 3rd book!
December 9, 2012
Quickly-paced, full of engaging characters, and well-researched -- Hieber's latest is a pleasure to read. Nice cameo from a couple of favorite characters from her Strangely Beautiful universe.
May 27, 2025
I DNF this one, I couldn't get into it
November 11, 2012
DENBURYLICIOUS <3
October 4, 2021
Ok, I want to preface this by saying that it's been nearly 10 years since I read the first book in this series. I know that wasn't a great move, but it is what it is.
So with this book, the distance between reading the first book and the second clearly impacted my enjoyment. I didn't connect with the characters. I didn't connect with the plot. I actually did remember some things from the first one despite the time, but it didn't help with the connections.
Natalie is supposed to be this brave, but shy, leader who is learning to believe in herself. But most of the time, she ends up coming off mousy and accidentally keeps stumbling into answers or problems. And Jonathon, for all the book jacket tries to build him up as a potential villain, just never comes off that way. I have no idea what the plot was trying to do with that.
Nothing about this book excited me. I thought going up against demons would be more interesting than it turned out to be. Even when there was an air of danger to a scene, it never ended up coming across as having too many stakes. I don't know if that's a writing issue, a 2010s writing trend, or if it was just my own interpretation. Whatever it was, I was never really hooked.
That said, the book was a pretty quick read. There are some quirky or just strange minor characters who, while usually not vitally important to the story, were enough to liven up the scene when the leads weren't enough. The story overall may not have been the most interesting thing, but I was mildly interested in certain aspects of the story. But it really was something I should have passed on after all this time.
So with this book, the distance between reading the first book and the second clearly impacted my enjoyment. I didn't connect with the characters. I didn't connect with the plot. I actually did remember some things from the first one despite the time, but it didn't help with the connections.
Natalie is supposed to be this brave, but shy, leader who is learning to believe in herself. But most of the time, she ends up coming off mousy and accidentally keeps stumbling into answers or problems. And Jonathon, for all the book jacket tries to build him up as a potential villain, just never comes off that way. I have no idea what the plot was trying to do with that.
Nothing about this book excited me. I thought going up against demons would be more interesting than it turned out to be. Even when there was an air of danger to a scene, it never ended up coming across as having too many stakes. I don't know if that's a writing issue, a 2010s writing trend, or if it was just my own interpretation. Whatever it was, I was never really hooked.
That said, the book was a pretty quick read. There are some quirky or just strange minor characters who, while usually not vitally important to the story, were enough to liven up the scene when the leads weren't enough. The story overall may not have been the most interesting thing, but I was mildly interested in certain aspects of the story. But it really was something I should have passed on after all this time.
May 3, 2018
The Twisted Tragedy of Miss Natalie Stewart picks up right where the first book left off. Young Miss Natalie has just freed the dashing Lord Denbury from the magical portrait in which his soul was imprisoned and regained her powers of speech, but now the two of them must dodge the dark forces that will surely seek revenge. They try to flee West, but discover that these forces of evil have a broader reach and bigger goals than they realized. A mysterious group known as the Society has been recruiting scientists and psychics for some nefarious purpose. When the young couple returns to New York to investigate further, they find that hunting demons and communing with ghosts is almost as difficult as navigating the complexities of Victorian courtship!
See my full review on TheGothicLibrary.com.
See my full review on TheGothicLibrary.com.
July 4, 2018
The second book wasn't as good as the first but still worth the read. I'll continue the story but I didn't fly through it as quick as I did Darker Still. I feel the ending was slightly anticlimactic but interested to see where it goes. I love the romance between Jonathon and Natalie, excited to see how that goes.
March 10, 2019
A bit predictable and convenient for the most part. You know, the heroine has access to a rich heiress blah, blah, blah. The hero is a bit standoffish etc., etc., etc.. Thus leaks in the typical YA tripe of doubt yadda, yadda, yadda. I had high hopes due to the premise but oh woe is me! Let's see if it kicks up a notch with the finale.
June 4, 2021
I swear, this one was even better than the first! This book was filled with action, romance, and adventure. I’m typically not a fan of the love at first sight trope, but this book explored their love a bit more and wasn’t always rainbows and sunshine. This was a bingeable read and I’m looking forward to the finale.
January 12, 2023
3.75 stars! While the first book was written diary-style, this one is in 3rd person, and it took me a while to adjust to the big change. Once I did, I enjoyed the beginning, got very bogged down in the middle (had to put it down for a WHILE), and then ended up flying through the end. Can’t wait to see what’s in store for the final volume!
June 19, 2024
Upon reading I quickly realized this was book in a series because I felt thrown into the story with no context for these characters who already shared a history. So the caveat of this review is solely based on my opinion of this book as a stand alone title. While I found the qualities of the protagonist Natalie Stewart refreshing I thought some of the secondary characters uninteresting.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 131 reviews