I listened to the Graphic Audio version of this, my first time experiencing a Marvel novel. The sound effects and music really gave a cinematic feel to this story. While the voice acting was engaging, some of it did take some getting use to. Spider-Man's voice sounds like what I'd expect from the character, but when he's just Peter Parker, his voice is not quite what I'd expect. It sounds more confident and authoritative. Not quite as natural of a fit to my ears as the live-action versions or the 2D animated versions. Then again, Jake Johnson's Peter Parker voice in Into the Spider-Verse took some getting used to, and I came to accept it. J. Jonah Jameson also sounds different from what I'm used to, and I can't quite put my finger on which actor his voice reminds me of.
I haven't really had much experience watching or reading about an older, married Peter Parker. So having this set in that period of his life was interesting. He teaches at school, though it feels unrealistic having him ask during a lecture whether any of his students are diabetics, and then having a couple of them raise their hands. I'd think that this would be a touchy thing that some people would be hesitant to reveal, but I digress. I'm especially glad that Aunt May, the voice of reason, is in the loop in regards to her nephew's double-life. Mary Jane is very present and has believable interactions with Peter. They have an intense argument at one point that bothered me a bit, but it makes sense given the full context provided by the end.
J. Jonah Jameson is also provided with a lot of depth. We get to delve into his mind and find out that he doesn't trust Spider-Man because he sees a version of himself who, if he could hide behind a mask, would do whatever he wants. And Peter eventually comes to the realization of what Jameson's reasoning for his distrust reminds him of, which feels very full circle. There's even a moment between them that feels reminiscent of a moment from The Killing Joke. And when JJ's being unreasonable, I love how Robbie Robertson is willing to call him out on his BS. There's also a funny line about how "Journalism" is Jameson's first name. In various adaptations of the Spider-Man comics, I never really got a sense of the general public getting behind Jameson's viewpoint of Spider-Man. But I get a sense of that here, especially during a tragic moment that really impacts Spider-Man.
Regardless of whether you're happy with how the villainous plot against Spider-Man is explained, I think that this was a really good character study of Spider-Man and J. Jonah Jameson. It may not be a perfect story, but I thoroughly enjoyed it and am glad that I bought it.