What do you think?
Rate this book
Golgotham #2
Left Hand Magic
Located on Manhattan's Lower East Side, Golgotham has been the city's supernatural neighborhood for centuries. Populated by countless creatures from myth and legend, the neighborhood's most prominent citizens are the Kymera, a race of witches who maintain an uneasy truce with New York City's humans... Tate Eresby has accepted the unusual sights and sounds of Golgotham and made it her home. Unfortunately, a magazine has alerted trendsetting hipsters to its existence and they've descended upon the community-along with an anti-Kymera faction known as The Sons of Adam. The sudden influx of tourists escalates racial tensions to a boiling point when two Kymerans are murdered and rioting fills the streets.
293 pages, Mass Market Paperback
First published December 6, 2011
17 people are currently reading
444 people want to read
About the author
Nancy A. Collins
337 books672 followersNancy A. Collins (born 10 September 1959) is a United States horror fiction writer best known for her series of vampire novels featuring her character Sonja Blue. Collins has also written for comic books, including the Swamp Thing series, Jason Vs. Leatherface, Predator: Hell Come A Walkin and her own one-shot Dhampire: Stillborn.
Collins was born in McGehee, Arkansas, United States. She lived in New Orleans, Louisiana in the 1980s; after time in New York City and Atlanta, Georgia she settled in Wilmington, North Carolina in the late 2000s.
Collins has written twenty novels since 1989, many of which refer to and directly include races of creatures the author calls Pretenders, monsters from myth and legend passing as human to better hunt their prey.
Collins has also written a number of highly acclaimed Southern Gothic short stories and novellas, most of which are set in Seven Devils, Arkansas, a highly fictionalized version of her hometown.
Most recently, she has focused her attention onto the Golgotham urban fantasy series,published by Penguin. Golgotham is the 'supernatural' ghetto of New York City, where creatures from myth and folklore--including witches,shapeshifters,leprechauns and centaurs--live and work in uneasy alliance with mankind.
Collins was born in McGehee, Arkansas, United States. She lived in New Orleans, Louisiana in the 1980s; after time in New York City and Atlanta, Georgia she settled in Wilmington, North Carolina in the late 2000s.
Collins has written twenty novels since 1989, many of which refer to and directly include races of creatures the author calls Pretenders, monsters from myth and legend passing as human to better hunt their prey.
Collins has also written a number of highly acclaimed Southern Gothic short stories and novellas, most of which are set in Seven Devils, Arkansas, a highly fictionalized version of her hometown.
Most recently, she has focused her attention onto the Golgotham urban fantasy series,published by Penguin. Golgotham is the 'supernatural' ghetto of New York City, where creatures from myth and folklore--including witches,shapeshifters,leprechauns and centaurs--live and work in uneasy alliance with mankind.
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 61 reviews
January 13, 2012
In Left Hand Magic, Nancy A. Collins delivers a satisfying follow-up to last year’s Right Hand Magic. Tate Eresby, a trust-fund baby turned avant-garde sculptor, is still living in the rich setting of Golgotham with her Kymeran lover, Hexe. But new troubles are brewing in Golgotham. A magazine spread has made Golgotham a hip hot spot for human tourists, and racial tensions are growing between these tourists and Golgotham’s magical natives.
The racism that Collins depicts is, sadly, all too realistic and plausible. It threatens to tear apart the relationship between Tate and Hexe, as both are seen as race traitors. But it’s far worse than that too: bullying, then rioting, then murder take their toll on the neighborhood. Some of the victims are characters we’ve already met and liked, making their fates hit harder.
A mystery lies behind all this. Are the crimes random, or is the racial hatred being manipulated by another party for personal gain? And how does all this tie in with the strange favor Tate was obliged to fulfill for a friend?
Tate is more of a major player this time around. Her special skills play a large role in the novel’s events, even more so than last time (though the back cover blurb reveals too much about that). She makes great strides with regard to her intimidating family. And though she’s not a combat character at heart, she gets to kick some butt this time.
There’s still a little clunkiness in the dialogue, especially when Golgotham’s history is recounted (though the topic itself is fascinating) or when the villain’s henchman conveniently rants about the whole dastardly plot while Tate is eavesdropping.
Overall, though, Left Hand Magic is a fun read. I read it in one day and greatly enjoyed it. And with the greater amount of agency given to Tate here, it’s superior to the first installment. Readers who like their urban fantasy worlds intricately built and fleshed out in rich detail will enjoy the GOLGOTHAM series.
The racism that Collins depicts is, sadly, all too realistic and plausible. It threatens to tear apart the relationship between Tate and Hexe, as both are seen as race traitors. But it’s far worse than that too: bullying, then rioting, then murder take their toll on the neighborhood. Some of the victims are characters we’ve already met and liked, making their fates hit harder.
A mystery lies behind all this. Are the crimes random, or is the racial hatred being manipulated by another party for personal gain? And how does all this tie in with the strange favor Tate was obliged to fulfill for a friend?
Tate is more of a major player this time around. Her special skills play a large role in the novel’s events, even more so than last time (though the back cover blurb reveals too much about that). She makes great strides with regard to her intimidating family. And though she’s not a combat character at heart, she gets to kick some butt this time.
There’s still a little clunkiness in the dialogue, especially when Golgotham’s history is recounted (though the topic itself is fascinating) or when the villain’s henchman conveniently rants about the whole dastardly plot while Tate is eavesdropping.
Overall, though, Left Hand Magic is a fun read. I read it in one day and greatly enjoyed it. And with the greater amount of agency given to Tate here, it’s superior to the first installment. Readers who like their urban fantasy worlds intricately built and fleshed out in rich detail will enjoy the GOLGOTHAM series.
October 24, 2018
This is fun and fast-paced follow-up to Right Hand Magic. Golgotham is an alternate-world fantasy borough of New York City. All of the characters from the first book are here and we meet some new ones, including the families of our romantically entwined interspecies protagonists. There's a bit more light-hearted humor and romance than one would expect from the author of the Sonja Blue stories, but it's an enjoyable fantasy romp. I'm ready to start the third volume.
May 19, 2015
When I saw this book on a shelf at the library I remembered that I didn't have a good response to the first book in the series but I couldn't remember why. This sounded intriguing so I thought I'd bring it home and see what I'd said about the first book. I definitely had a lot of issues with the first book, the heroine was too stupid to live, the plot was really weak and very badly paced and I didn't feel like the problems were excusable for an author this experienced. But...I really needed something to read and was in the mood for urban fantasy so I gave this a try anyway. And it was going well until about half way through. The pacing issues from the first book weren't an issue, she got right into the story instead of just touring us around the city like she did the first time. She still does that thing where she tells me what three things everyone smells like, which is really weird since the character she has announcing it is a human, how can she tell what someone smells like as soon as she opens the door for them or know it so well as to be able to distinguish three distinct notes? This one smells like sea spray, kelp and a touch of driftwood, this one smells like chalk and paper, that one I can believe smells like jasmine and roses, ok, sure, that's believable, but when she opened the door and discovered the woman who smelled faintly of menthol and pencil shavings standing on the front stoop it was just too much. Ah ha - after 160 pages into the second book the author finally explained that the personal scents of Kymerans provides biochemical signals of their basic personalities. Nice people have nice scents. Which still made little sense considering that what they consider nice is so different than what humans consider nice, look at what they like to eat. Why don't any of the characters smell like crickets? And why do they all smell so strong that Tate can identify it from so far away? And why is she so good at identifying each separate scent? Do you know what sea spray or driftwood smell like? Because I don't. I can imaging a lady smelling like the ocean to me, but the individual scents, nope, no way. It was just a really annoying idea in large doses during both books.
But not as annoying as Tate being consistently too stupid to live. Very nearly literally. Around half way through the book Tate lost what was left of her good sense and decided to sneak into a Kymeran protest rally, as though a temporary hair dye job could keep her safe from the mobs that have already been so violent in the last few days. She said she'd just shove her five-fingered hands in her pockets and hopefully no one would notice she didn't have six digits. As long as no one shoved her in the crowd and she didn't put out a hand to get her balance. That was the "what if" I thought of that would have prevented me from doing something so dumb. But not our girl. Too stupid to live. And really bad writing. I should have just put the book down then. The rest of it was just too predictable. She almost died, refused to accept how stupid she was, people told her they couldn't decide if she was brave or dumb (dumb!), she continued to insist that she knew what she was doing even though she was clearly being an idiot, etc. It was never as bad as that scene in the stupidity department, but the pacing got really off after that again, I don't know what it is with Collins and her plotting. It's all wind-up, then suddenly wrap-ups at the end, it happened with both books in this series. Her bio says she's won or been nominated for tons of awards but I don't get it from these books. They have a lot of potential, I like the concepts a lot and some of the characters are intriguing. I really liked Hexe's mother, and of course the puppy, though he's hardly a character. It's a vibrant world, I just don't love the execution. It's frustrating to have it be so close to good but then miss the mark again. It was better than the first book though.
But not as annoying as Tate being consistently too stupid to live. Very nearly literally. Around half way through the book Tate lost what was left of her good sense and decided to sneak into a Kymeran protest rally, as though a temporary hair dye job could keep her safe from the mobs that have already been so violent in the last few days. She said she'd just shove her five-fingered hands in her pockets and hopefully no one would notice she didn't have six digits. As long as no one shoved her in the crowd and she didn't put out a hand to get her balance. That was the "what if" I thought of that would have prevented me from doing something so dumb. But not our girl. Too stupid to live. And really bad writing. I should have just put the book down then. The rest of it was just too predictable. She almost died, refused to accept how stupid she was, people told her they couldn't decide if she was brave or dumb (dumb!), she continued to insist that she knew what she was doing even though she was clearly being an idiot, etc. It was never as bad as that scene in the stupidity department, but the pacing got really off after that again, I don't know what it is with Collins and her plotting. It's all wind-up, then suddenly wrap-ups at the end, it happened with both books in this series. Her bio says she's won or been nominated for tons of awards but I don't get it from these books. They have a lot of potential, I like the concepts a lot and some of the characters are intriguing. I really liked Hexe's mother, and of course the puppy, though he's hardly a character. It's a vibrant world, I just don't love the execution. It's frustrating to have it be so close to good but then miss the mark again. It was better than the first book though.
December 21, 2011
Originally posted at http://www.smexybooks.com/2011/12/rev...
Favorite Quote: “You’d think by this point in my life I could no longer be shocked or embarrassed by what comes slithering out of her mouth, but somehow my mother always manages to top herself.“
Left Hand Magic picks up about 3 weeks after Right Hand Magic ended. Trust-fund baby Tate Eresby has made herself at home in Golgotham and in the arms of a sexy royal Kymeran prince. Tate had originally come to Golgotham, New York’s premiere paranormal underworld, because she needed a larger space to create her large metal sculptures. At the end of Right Hand Magic, we find out that Tate’s sculptures are “special” and a reporter’s article about that has resulted in Golgotham becoming a human tourist attraction. Not everyone is thrilled with this though. Humans, also called numps by the residents of Golgotham, don’t understand the residents or magic of Golgotham and tensions rise as prejudice and racism permeate the air.
Hexe does what he can to protect Tate and tries to convince her to head back to New York where she will be safe but she refuses to leave Golgotham or him. When Hexe’s evil uncle Easu begins a steady campaign to rid Golgotham of all humans, Tate gets caught in the middle and finds herself fighting for her love and her life.
Nancy Collins’ Left Hand Magic continues to build strength with its elaborate world building. We, along with Tate, learn more about this richly fascinating magical city that borders New York. Traditions, cultures, and history is further explored as Tate tries to fit in to her lover’s world. We see the problems that occurs when two worlds clash and two opposing police factions-The PTU (Paranormal Tactical Unit) and the NY police department-have to deal with it and each other. The story blends better this time around with the world building and the characters. A more emotional approach is taken in here and it reflects well on the story.
While I am still ambiguous to Hexe and Tate, I did feel that the secondary characters were better developed in this installment; adding more realism and a sense of anticipation to the story lines. More depth and personality is shown both in action and dialogue. Not to say I don’t like our protagonists because I do. It’s just there isn’t any real conflict or angst between them. They get along well and any problems are solved fast and amicably. Their romance is still giving me a YA feeling. It’s apparent that Ms. Collins chooses to highlight the world and the fantasy over the romance.
I loved seeing more of Hexe’s familiar, Scratch. A hairless sarcastic cat/demon who acts as though he would be very happy if Tate left and never came back. He adds some snarky humor to the story. We get more back story on Hexe’s mother, his father, and the reasons his uncle hates humans so much. We also see more of Tate’s parents who’s ties to Golgotham were a surprise. Tate does show some growth in here. She is more aware of her human limitations and acts wiser this go around.
The plot and sub plots are well paced and plenty of action keeps you on your toes. I found that we didn’t have the dead scenes or repetitiveness in here as was a problem in the first one. We are still getting some sub stories with random character introduction that doesn’t really add or deflect from the story but makes you wonder why they were added. The villain is known early on but I enjoyed watching how Ms. Collins weaves it all together for a climatic and interesting ending. Though this could be read as a stand alone, there is a continuing arc that might be confusing if your not starting at the beginning.
I enjoyed this foray back into Ms. Collin’s world and see that with each installment, the series is continuing to improve. I look forward to the next in the series.
Overall Rating: C+
Favorite Quote: “You’d think by this point in my life I could no longer be shocked or embarrassed by what comes slithering out of her mouth, but somehow my mother always manages to top herself.“
Left Hand Magic picks up about 3 weeks after Right Hand Magic ended. Trust-fund baby Tate Eresby has made herself at home in Golgotham and in the arms of a sexy royal Kymeran prince. Tate had originally come to Golgotham, New York’s premiere paranormal underworld, because she needed a larger space to create her large metal sculptures. At the end of Right Hand Magic, we find out that Tate’s sculptures are “special” and a reporter’s article about that has resulted in Golgotham becoming a human tourist attraction. Not everyone is thrilled with this though. Humans, also called numps by the residents of Golgotham, don’t understand the residents or magic of Golgotham and tensions rise as prejudice and racism permeate the air.
Hexe does what he can to protect Tate and tries to convince her to head back to New York where she will be safe but she refuses to leave Golgotham or him. When Hexe’s evil uncle Easu begins a steady campaign to rid Golgotham of all humans, Tate gets caught in the middle and finds herself fighting for her love and her life.
Nancy Collins’ Left Hand Magic continues to build strength with its elaborate world building. We, along with Tate, learn more about this richly fascinating magical city that borders New York. Traditions, cultures, and history is further explored as Tate tries to fit in to her lover’s world. We see the problems that occurs when two worlds clash and two opposing police factions-The PTU (Paranormal Tactical Unit) and the NY police department-have to deal with it and each other. The story blends better this time around with the world building and the characters. A more emotional approach is taken in here and it reflects well on the story.
While I am still ambiguous to Hexe and Tate, I did feel that the secondary characters were better developed in this installment; adding more realism and a sense of anticipation to the story lines. More depth and personality is shown both in action and dialogue. Not to say I don’t like our protagonists because I do. It’s just there isn’t any real conflict or angst between them. They get along well and any problems are solved fast and amicably. Their romance is still giving me a YA feeling. It’s apparent that Ms. Collins chooses to highlight the world and the fantasy over the romance.
I loved seeing more of Hexe’s familiar, Scratch. A hairless sarcastic cat/demon who acts as though he would be very happy if Tate left and never came back. He adds some snarky humor to the story. We get more back story on Hexe’s mother, his father, and the reasons his uncle hates humans so much. We also see more of Tate’s parents who’s ties to Golgotham were a surprise. Tate does show some growth in here. She is more aware of her human limitations and acts wiser this go around.
The plot and sub plots are well paced and plenty of action keeps you on your toes. I found that we didn’t have the dead scenes or repetitiveness in here as was a problem in the first one. We are still getting some sub stories with random character introduction that doesn’t really add or deflect from the story but makes you wonder why they were added. The villain is known early on but I enjoyed watching how Ms. Collins weaves it all together for a climatic and interesting ending. Though this could be read as a stand alone, there is a continuing arc that might be confusing if your not starting at the beginning.
I enjoyed this foray back into Ms. Collin’s world and see that with each installment, the series is continuing to improve. I look forward to the next in the series.
Overall Rating: C+
January 20, 2012
A sweet Roman Holiday with a paranormal bent, LEFT HAND MAGIC delivers both magic and social justice with a hefty dose of youthful enthusiasm. Hexe and Tate, charming products of very privileged upbringings, are a bit more starry eyed than I can relate to. Despite that, I found them both love-able (if a bit silly) as they stand up against injustice, their families, and the expectations of the world at large.
Though the world building and magic didn’t blow me away (the mechanics of a magical New York neighborhood that *hadn't* been invaded by hipsters seemed a bit shaky), I found the politics of Golgotham fascinating. Collins paints a vivid picture of prejudice and fear spinning out of control. The story was made all the more effective by a fun supporting cast. The fanny-pack wearing centaur, the demonic familiar and love-lorn maenad were each irresistible. Even Tate and Hexe were their own brands of exotic creatures: young and idealistic and privileged. I found them equal parts frustrating and fun. The introduction of Tate’s Boston terrier Beanie just about sums up the couple: Tate gives lip service to the “life altering responsibility” of owning a pet but within seconds is in rapturous love with the surprise puppy (and occupied with accessorizing and status-updating her new arrival). This split second decision in no way negatively impacts the household, just like every other quick-on-the-draw decision Tate makes. I did find Tate to be a little shallow (outside of her social justice crusade), and Hexe’s beta hero persona never particularly charmed me either. He’s at best the harmless, generous boyfriend that makes Tate’s “rebellion” possible.
Don’t let my harsh characterization of Tate and Hexe’s relationship fool you, however, they in no way dragged the story down. The politics of Golgotham clashing with “normal” New York had me at the edge of my seat all the way through. Though this was my first taste of the Golgotham series, I had no trouble falling I to the story. I don’t think Tate and Hexe interest me enough to go back and read book one, but I am invested enough in the fate of the city to pick up book three when it appears.
Sexual Content: Attempted rape and references to sex.
Though the world building and magic didn’t blow me away (the mechanics of a magical New York neighborhood that *hadn't* been invaded by hipsters seemed a bit shaky), I found the politics of Golgotham fascinating. Collins paints a vivid picture of prejudice and fear spinning out of control. The story was made all the more effective by a fun supporting cast. The fanny-pack wearing centaur, the demonic familiar and love-lorn maenad were each irresistible. Even Tate and Hexe were their own brands of exotic creatures: young and idealistic and privileged. I found them equal parts frustrating and fun. The introduction of Tate’s Boston terrier Beanie just about sums up the couple: Tate gives lip service to the “life altering responsibility” of owning a pet but within seconds is in rapturous love with the surprise puppy (and occupied with accessorizing and status-updating her new arrival). This split second decision in no way negatively impacts the household, just like every other quick-on-the-draw decision Tate makes. I did find Tate to be a little shallow (outside of her social justice crusade), and Hexe’s beta hero persona never particularly charmed me either. He’s at best the harmless, generous boyfriend that makes Tate’s “rebellion” possible.
Don’t let my harsh characterization of Tate and Hexe’s relationship fool you, however, they in no way dragged the story down. The politics of Golgotham clashing with “normal” New York had me at the edge of my seat all the way through. Though this was my first taste of the Golgotham series, I had no trouble falling I to the story. I don’t think Tate and Hexe interest me enough to go back and read book one, but I am invested enough in the fate of the city to pick up book three when it appears.
Sexual Content: Attempted rape and references to sex.
January 17, 2012
I have to confess that Sonja Blue is one of my Top 20 favorite urban fantasy/horror characters. She was the original "hipster, stone cold killer" vamp long before they ever got sparkly.
Collins has created a new series with an interesting premise of alt-history. Left Hand Magic is the second of the series. I'm normally leery of jumping into a series without checking the initial book first, but had to make an exception in this case.
Writing is top notch, the background "world building" is concise, extraordinary and done with a very deft hand. She takes minor liberties with American History to explain, in a very rational fashion, just how a designated portion of Manhattan is (technically) its own country, complete with its own law, morals, and denizens.
I found the book to be a quick read, but a very entertaining one. If you enjoyed the Sonja Blue series or works by Patricia Briggs, Kim Harrison or (possibly) Charlaine Harris there's a good chance you'll dig this book. Plus the fact it is a trade paperback, not hardcover makes it an easy "impulse buy."
Collins has created a new series with an interesting premise of alt-history. Left Hand Magic is the second of the series. I'm normally leery of jumping into a series without checking the initial book first, but had to make an exception in this case.
Writing is top notch, the background "world building" is concise, extraordinary and done with a very deft hand. She takes minor liberties with American History to explain, in a very rational fashion, just how a designated portion of Manhattan is (technically) its own country, complete with its own law, morals, and denizens.
I found the book to be a quick read, but a very entertaining one. If you enjoyed the Sonja Blue series or works by Patricia Briggs, Kim Harrison or (possibly) Charlaine Harris there's a good chance you'll dig this book. Plus the fact it is a trade paperback, not hardcover makes it an easy "impulse buy."
September 4, 2020
Not really a full three stars, but nearer three than two.
Set a few weeks or months after the first book, human artist Tate has settled quite nicely into her new home in Golgotham. Her career as a metal sculptor may have stalled somewhat since her last show, when the sculptures became animated and marched out, but her relationship with her landlord/boyfriend Hexe is bubbling over nicely, despite some hostility from some of the non-humans who think a Kymeran (sort of a fey wizard) like Hexe shouldn't be 'polluting' himself with a human like her.
When a photo article about Golgotham draws a lot of trendy human hipsters to Golgotham and troubles breaks out, the fight leaves victims on both sides and the racial tensions boil over. Hexe's uncle Esau starts forming an anti-human league to take on the Sons of Adam, a human terrorist group, who want to drive the fey out of the city for good.
This book wasn't a bad read, but it wasn't a particularly good one either. The premise of a racial war might seem like an interesting (if rather depressing given the current state of the world) read, but it just wasn't. It was handled stupidly easily, and the real victim of the piece was obvious virtually from the get-go - it was about as complicated as an episode of Scooby-Doo!
The relationship between Tate and Hexe also become more important and while I'm not especially bothered by that per se, it meant that more time was devoted to that and thus less was devoted to the half-baked plot, which was kind of annoying.
One the plus side, Collins writes action scenes well, and Scratch, the snarky hairless cat/demonspawn familiar is a pleasure to read.
If you like UF that flirts with PNR and has a fairly light plot with an obvious end, you may like this book. If you like harder, crueler books that flirt with horror rather than romance, you may find it too light and dull for you.
Set a few weeks or months after the first book, human artist Tate has settled quite nicely into her new home in Golgotham. Her career as a metal sculptor may have stalled somewhat since her last show, when the sculptures became animated and marched out, but her relationship with her landlord/boyfriend Hexe is bubbling over nicely, despite some hostility from some of the non-humans who think a Kymeran (sort of a fey wizard) like Hexe shouldn't be 'polluting' himself with a human like her.
When a photo article about Golgotham draws a lot of trendy human hipsters to Golgotham and troubles breaks out, the fight leaves victims on both sides and the racial tensions boil over. Hexe's uncle Esau starts forming an anti-human league to take on the Sons of Adam, a human terrorist group, who want to drive the fey out of the city for good.
This book wasn't a bad read, but it wasn't a particularly good one either. The premise of a racial war might seem like an interesting (if rather depressing given the current state of the world) read, but it just wasn't. It was handled stupidly easily, and the real victim of the piece was obvious virtually from the get-go - it was about as complicated as an episode of Scooby-Doo!
The relationship between Tate and Hexe also become more important and while I'm not especially bothered by that per se, it meant that more time was devoted to that and thus less was devoted to the half-baked plot, which was kind of annoying.
One the plus side, Collins writes action scenes well, and Scratch, the snarky hairless cat/demonspawn familiar is a pleasure to read.
If you like UF that flirts with PNR and has a fairly light plot with an obvious end, you may like this book. If you like harder, crueler books that flirt with horror rather than romance, you may find it too light and dull for you.
January 21, 2012
2.5 Stars
Tate and boyfriend wizard, Hexe are living together in Golgotham. Golgotham is a city inside of New York that is teaming with mythological and fairy tale creatures that call themselves Kymerans. Golgotham has had a lot of press lately, and has turned into a tourist spot for humans. Very soon tensions between the Humans and Kymerans heat up causing problems for Tate and Hexe.
This is the second book in the series, and it took me around eighty pages to establish myself in the city of Golgotham. The book could be alternate reality since Golgotham’s establishment dates very far back, and it is very interesting to see some of the mythological creatures just wondering around the street, or hanging out in the bar getting drunk. The city itself was my favorite part of the story.
Tate and Hexe didn’t do it for me. Their relationship is well established but felt stiff. Their dialog felt off, and although they were perfect to one another, it was hard to get into their relationship. They seem to lack faults, and every little thing that goes wrong is shrugged off between them.
The problem in Golgotham is a racial issue. Humans keep coming and mucking things up, to top it off Hexe’s uncle gets involved. It is hard to be the mixed couple when the city is full of hate for humans. So what does Tate do? She goes to an anti-human rally. This was another problem I had. I don’t understand what possessed her, even after finishing the book. She is an artist, who instead of diving head first inside of her work, and letting her feelings about what is going on shine through. She dives into the fray. Soon people are coming after her, including the Sons of Adam (SOA), a group of humans who want to kill Kymerans.
Of course once Tate becomes involved Hexe dives in to save her. It doesn’t help that he is the Witch Queen’s son, and next in line, so he is a public figure. Tate is also the daughter of a rich influential couple, so both human and Kymeran eyes are glued to them. Hexe dives into save Tate more than I would like.
Golgotham is a cool place to read about, but the characters fell off for me. I had a hard time getting into them, not because it is a heavy read, but because of how they react to one another. As the story unfolded it felt predictable, but easy to follow.
-Beth (Guest Reviewer)
Tate and boyfriend wizard, Hexe are living together in Golgotham. Golgotham is a city inside of New York that is teaming with mythological and fairy tale creatures that call themselves Kymerans. Golgotham has had a lot of press lately, and has turned into a tourist spot for humans. Very soon tensions between the Humans and Kymerans heat up causing problems for Tate and Hexe.
This is the second book in the series, and it took me around eighty pages to establish myself in the city of Golgotham. The book could be alternate reality since Golgotham’s establishment dates very far back, and it is very interesting to see some of the mythological creatures just wondering around the street, or hanging out in the bar getting drunk. The city itself was my favorite part of the story.
Tate and Hexe didn’t do it for me. Their relationship is well established but felt stiff. Their dialog felt off, and although they were perfect to one another, it was hard to get into their relationship. They seem to lack faults, and every little thing that goes wrong is shrugged off between them.
The problem in Golgotham is a racial issue. Humans keep coming and mucking things up, to top it off Hexe’s uncle gets involved. It is hard to be the mixed couple when the city is full of hate for humans. So what does Tate do? She goes to an anti-human rally. This was another problem I had. I don’t understand what possessed her, even after finishing the book. She is an artist, who instead of diving head first inside of her work, and letting her feelings about what is going on shine through. She dives into the fray. Soon people are coming after her, including the Sons of Adam (SOA), a group of humans who want to kill Kymerans.
Of course once Tate becomes involved Hexe dives in to save her. It doesn’t help that he is the Witch Queen’s son, and next in line, so he is a public figure. Tate is also the daughter of a rich influential couple, so both human and Kymeran eyes are glued to them. Hexe dives into save Tate more than I would like.
Golgotham is a cool place to read about, but the characters fell off for me. I had a hard time getting into them, not because it is a heavy read, but because of how they react to one another. As the story unfolded it felt predictable, but easy to follow.
-Beth (Guest Reviewer)
November 17, 2011
Left Hand Magic is the second book in the Golgotham series by Nancy A Collins and a ROC Fantasy.
Book Blurb:
Located on Manhattan’s Lower East Side, Golgotham has been the city’s supernatural ghetto for centuries. Populated by countless creatures from myth and legend, its most prominent citizens are the Kymera, a race of witches who maintain an uneasy truce with New York City’s humans...
Tate Eresby has accepted the unusual sights and sounds of Golgotham and has made it her home. Unfortunately, trend-setting hipsters have descended upon the community - along with an anti-Kymera faction known as the Sons of Adam. The sudden influx of tourists escalates racial tensions to a boiling point when two Kymerans are attacked, another is murdered, and rioting fills the streets.
Tate’s relationship with Hexe, the current heir to the Kymeran throne, is also full of tension. Hexe’s uncle Esau is an anti-human activist who’s ready to declare war on the Sons of Adam - and who believes Tate is a spy. But is it possible that Tate’s time in Golgotham has left her more than human?
My thoughts:
Tate has settled into the rhythm of Golgotham and for the first time in a long time, she is content.
Her relationship with Hexe is easy and she is excited to see where it will go.
When a night out on the town shows just how far supernatural and human relations in Golgotham have fallen - Tate and Hexe become worried.
A confrontation between NYPD and the PTU have things going from bad to worse. Now those normally accepting Kymerans are looking at Tate and Hexe’s relationship as a disgrace. Even Hexe’s mother is cautioning them against such a public display of affection.
The humans are making a racket as well - in the form of the Sons of Adam. A couple are beaten, a centaur is murdered - no one is safe.
And Tate is having dreams...
If she and Hexe can’t figure out who is behind the murders - Tate may be next on the list.
Left Hand Magic is an enjoyable read. Golgotham is an extraordinary place full of diverse beings. I can’t wait for more.
I give Left Hand Magic 4 out of 5 stars.
Product Details
Paperback: 304 pages
Publisher: Roc (December 6, 2011)
Language: English
ISBN-10: 0451464303
ISBN-13: 978-0451464309
Book Blurb:
Located on Manhattan’s Lower East Side, Golgotham has been the city’s supernatural ghetto for centuries. Populated by countless creatures from myth and legend, its most prominent citizens are the Kymera, a race of witches who maintain an uneasy truce with New York City’s humans...
Tate Eresby has accepted the unusual sights and sounds of Golgotham and has made it her home. Unfortunately, trend-setting hipsters have descended upon the community - along with an anti-Kymera faction known as the Sons of Adam. The sudden influx of tourists escalates racial tensions to a boiling point when two Kymerans are attacked, another is murdered, and rioting fills the streets.
Tate’s relationship with Hexe, the current heir to the Kymeran throne, is also full of tension. Hexe’s uncle Esau is an anti-human activist who’s ready to declare war on the Sons of Adam - and who believes Tate is a spy. But is it possible that Tate’s time in Golgotham has left her more than human?
My thoughts:
Tate has settled into the rhythm of Golgotham and for the first time in a long time, she is content.
Her relationship with Hexe is easy and she is excited to see where it will go.
When a night out on the town shows just how far supernatural and human relations in Golgotham have fallen - Tate and Hexe become worried.
A confrontation between NYPD and the PTU have things going from bad to worse. Now those normally accepting Kymerans are looking at Tate and Hexe’s relationship as a disgrace. Even Hexe’s mother is cautioning them against such a public display of affection.
The humans are making a racket as well - in the form of the Sons of Adam. A couple are beaten, a centaur is murdered - no one is safe.
And Tate is having dreams...
If she and Hexe can’t figure out who is behind the murders - Tate may be next on the list.
Left Hand Magic is an enjoyable read. Golgotham is an extraordinary place full of diverse beings. I can’t wait for more.
I give Left Hand Magic 4 out of 5 stars.
Product Details
Paperback: 304 pages
Publisher: Roc (December 6, 2011)
Language: English
ISBN-10: 0451464303
ISBN-13: 978-0451464309
December 17, 2011
I absolutely love the world that Nancy has created. Golgotham is a place where New York's Paranormal folks live and the detail and creativity written between the pages of this series never stop amazing me. LEFT HAND MAGIC is the second book in the series and I would 100% recommend you read book one before jumping into it. There are things in book 1 that you will not want to go without knowing.
After a big incident at the The Two-Headed Calf Golgotham is not a friendly place for humans and that includes Tate. LEFT HAND MAGIC is filled with danger, action, suspense and drama. At every turn Tate seems to be pulled into a situation that puts her in danger. Tate and Hexe are comfortable with each other and their relationship. They have just about everyone in their lives trying to break them up but they only hold onto their relationship tighter. I really want them to get married and have babies (ok I know that is jumping the timeline but I'm very interested in knowing how the child will turn out with some of the new details we learn about Hexe's family lines and how his family members get to be heir to the Kymeran throne) read the book you will want them to have babies too. Scratch continues to be fabulous. He is the perfect little side kick familiar and he cracks me up at every turn. No matter how much he tries to hide it and how much crap he gives her you can tell that Tate is growing on him. We get a few visits from Tate's parents and wow her mother is a piece of work. Just when I think she is done being a witch we find out a shocking detail that links her to Hexe's mom. I cant wait to see how this little slice of information comes out in the future. As the description of the book states, Tate's time in Golgotham has left her less human then she was coming in. I wont tell you what that means but Im excited what will happen next for her now that we know a little bit of what she can do. I know teasers teasers. Go grab yourself book 1 RIGHT HAND MAGIC if you have not started this series.
After a big incident at the The Two-Headed Calf Golgotham is not a friendly place for humans and that includes Tate. LEFT HAND MAGIC is filled with danger, action, suspense and drama. At every turn Tate seems to be pulled into a situation that puts her in danger. Tate and Hexe are comfortable with each other and their relationship. They have just about everyone in their lives trying to break them up but they only hold onto their relationship tighter. I really want them to get married and have babies (ok I know that is jumping the timeline but I'm very interested in knowing how the child will turn out with some of the new details we learn about Hexe's family lines and how his family members get to be heir to the Kymeran throne) read the book you will want them to have babies too. Scratch continues to be fabulous. He is the perfect little side kick familiar and he cracks me up at every turn. No matter how much he tries to hide it and how much crap he gives her you can tell that Tate is growing on him. We get a few visits from Tate's parents and wow her mother is a piece of work. Just when I think she is done being a witch we find out a shocking detail that links her to Hexe's mom. I cant wait to see how this little slice of information comes out in the future. As the description of the book states, Tate's time in Golgotham has left her less human then she was coming in. I wont tell you what that means but Im excited what will happen next for her now that we know a little bit of what she can do. I know teasers teasers. Go grab yourself book 1 RIGHT HAND MAGIC if you have not started this series.
April 26, 2012
4 1/2 stars.
“Left Hand Magic” by Nancy A. Collins is the next in her series about Golgotham, the neighborhood of New York that houses exotic inhabitants such as centaurs, satyrs, leprechauns, witches, warlocks, ipotanes and the like. Heiress Tate Eresby has settled in with her lover Hexe, but she has had to make adjustments to loving a warlock, living with his familiar, and being one of the few humans in the neighborhood. Her unconventional work as a metal sculptor causes friction with her very conventional parents but their disapproval pales in comparison to the hostilities that erupt between the Golgothamites and humans that they disparage with the term numps. An escalation in violence results in the deaths of friends and acquaintances and complications arise from Hexe’s status as Heir Apparent (not to mention his having a human girlfriend) and his own divided family. Tate’s inescapable loyalty to her new neighborhood puts her right in the middle of the conflict between the humans and non-humans. Complying with the repayment of a debt by utilizing her skills at working metal may have more repercussions than she could ever imagine and the increase in her immediate family changes the household dynamics. Hexe and Tate must find a way to survive the upheavals around them, keep their neighborhood intact and deal with parental disapproval but Golgotham may never recover from the pressures being exerted upon it.
A great sequel to “Right Hand Magic”, revisiting the fantastical neighborhood with its remarkable denizens. The centaurs are prevalent in their roles as transportation experts, the Paranormal Threat Unit (PTU) is kept busy, testimony is via scrying crystal, a sketch artist accesses one’s third eye and other imaginative elements keep the story fresh and entertaining in this enjoyable read.
© Night Owl Reviews
“Left Hand Magic” by Nancy A. Collins is the next in her series about Golgotham, the neighborhood of New York that houses exotic inhabitants such as centaurs, satyrs, leprechauns, witches, warlocks, ipotanes and the like. Heiress Tate Eresby has settled in with her lover Hexe, but she has had to make adjustments to loving a warlock, living with his familiar, and being one of the few humans in the neighborhood. Her unconventional work as a metal sculptor causes friction with her very conventional parents but their disapproval pales in comparison to the hostilities that erupt between the Golgothamites and humans that they disparage with the term numps. An escalation in violence results in the deaths of friends and acquaintances and complications arise from Hexe’s status as Heir Apparent (not to mention his having a human girlfriend) and his own divided family. Tate’s inescapable loyalty to her new neighborhood puts her right in the middle of the conflict between the humans and non-humans. Complying with the repayment of a debt by utilizing her skills at working metal may have more repercussions than she could ever imagine and the increase in her immediate family changes the household dynamics. Hexe and Tate must find a way to survive the upheavals around them, keep their neighborhood intact and deal with parental disapproval but Golgotham may never recover from the pressures being exerted upon it.
A great sequel to “Right Hand Magic”, revisiting the fantastical neighborhood with its remarkable denizens. The centaurs are prevalent in their roles as transportation experts, the Paranormal Threat Unit (PTU) is kept busy, testimony is via scrying crystal, a sketch artist accesses one’s third eye and other imaginative elements keep the story fresh and entertaining in this enjoyable read.
© Night Owl Reviews
January 3, 2012
I thought the first book in this series was a little slow to start, but this one didn't have that problem for me. I think a lot of that is because the world has been set up and we know how things work and what to expect.
Tate and Hexe are happy with the changes in their lives and being a couple, but the rest of people not so much. So much of this book is about discrimination, humans versus those living in Golgotham and the hate isn't one way, but both ways. So with Tate and Hexe being a mixed race couple they see a lot of hate rained down on them.
I found it interesting just who was doing the hating and who stood up to those that did the hating. I did seem like there was a bigger conspiracy at the bottom of things and when it was revealed you could hardly believe how everyone was manipulated.
Even among the strife there were some great parts, the new addition to Hexe and Tate's house, one who managed to charm everyone he came in contact with. Tate makes a couple of big discoveries about herself and her family, that will bring about some big changes to her future. Hexe also learns some things about his family that has always been hidden, it will be interesting what this knew knowledge brings to his life.
I look forward to the next one!
Tate and Hexe are happy with the changes in their lives and being a couple, but the rest of people not so much. So much of this book is about discrimination, humans versus those living in Golgotham and the hate isn't one way, but both ways. So with Tate and Hexe being a mixed race couple they see a lot of hate rained down on them.
I found it interesting just who was doing the hating and who stood up to those that did the hating. I did seem like there was a bigger conspiracy at the bottom of things and when it was revealed you could hardly believe how everyone was manipulated.
Even among the strife there were some great parts, the new addition to Hexe and Tate's house, one who managed to charm everyone he came in contact with. Tate makes a couple of big discoveries about herself and her family, that will bring about some big changes to her future. Hexe also learns some things about his family that has always been hidden, it will be interesting what this knew knowledge brings to his life.
I look forward to the next one!
December 28, 2015
The story carries on closely to the events in Right Hand Magic - (no spoilers) but you do see a lot on continuity - I am not saying you have to read all the books in order, but it does help as the recaps and explanations are a little thin on the ground (come on whats a little encouragement). Even so I would suggest you read them in order.
Why well for once I have found a heroine who is both a great orator and fun character to follow. I do at times get tried of the female stereotype (although reading a lot of "classic" science fiction it is hard at times to avoid) - but Nancy Collins has a knack of creating characters you can both relate to and admire and as a result it makes following their adventures all the more thrilling. I learnt this some time ago reading Sonja Blue (go on read it you wont be disappointed). So which ever gender you are there are both heroes and villains you can root for.
But back to the story, it is fast paced with multiple stories and threads running through it - something that caught my eye and interest from the first page. you can see why the stories have been optioned. The district of Golgotham is a rich and vibrant location full of new adventures waiting to happen at every turn.
Why well for once I have found a heroine who is both a great orator and fun character to follow. I do at times get tried of the female stereotype (although reading a lot of "classic" science fiction it is hard at times to avoid) - but Nancy Collins has a knack of creating characters you can both relate to and admire and as a result it makes following their adventures all the more thrilling. I learnt this some time ago reading Sonja Blue (go on read it you wont be disappointed). So which ever gender you are there are both heroes and villains you can root for.
But back to the story, it is fast paced with multiple stories and threads running through it - something that caught my eye and interest from the first page. you can see why the stories have been optioned. The district of Golgotham is a rich and vibrant location full of new adventures waiting to happen at every turn.
December 11, 2011
This book should be at the bottom of my TBR mountain but I couldn't resist when it arrived last week. The second book in the series developed the main characters well in amongst tensions between the human residents of New York and the paranormal ones of Golgotham.
The addition of a new pet (loved Beanie the Boston Terrier) and the introduction of magical powers for Tate added well to the story.
Not the darkest or most angst driven urban fantasy but a good read and recommended.
The addition of a new pet (loved Beanie the Boston Terrier) and the introduction of magical powers for Tate added well to the story.
Not the darkest or most angst driven urban fantasy but a good read and recommended.
May 26, 2022
The conflict between Golgothamites and Humans grows worse; all it takes is a couple of drunk frat boys toying around with a leprechaun, and said leprechaun cursing the lead frat boy into a pig, to start open combat. Soon, Hexe's sinister' uncle Esau is calling for getting humans out of Golgatham, and a group of anti-Kymeran humans (who call themselves the Sons of Adam) vowing to kill all the unnaturals especially those involved or in conflict with humans. Can Tate and Hexe survive, their relationship intact, through all this chaos?
July 28, 2018
Surprisingly, I enjoyed this 2nd Golgotham book more than the first which rarely happens in a series for me. I felt like the time Nancy Collins had spent building her world in Right Hand Magic paid off perfectly. This was a fast-paced Urban Fantasy which broke away from the Vampire/Werewolf tropes and did it well. I will definitely be reading book three.
59 Fandom's Reading Challenge - a book that involves an inter-species friendship/romance.
59 Fandom's Reading Challenge - a book that involves an inter-species friendship/romance.
July 16, 2022
2022 bk 197. A look at prejudice through the eyes of one science fiction author and as it is expressed in a large city in the future. This is a book of politics and political action, thinly disguised as a SF/Fantasy title. Interesting look at one possible future.
December 4, 2022
Well. You can tell it is a book 2, not much of a plot, lots of descriptions of the world and people. I am going to try book 3 and we shall see.
October 8, 2013
Left Hand Magic really ratchets up the tension in Golgatham, particularly the tensions between humans and the creatures of Golgotham. They start with (relatively) minor confrontations in the Two-Headed Calf and escalated into a full on riot. And that's just in the first quarter of the book. I think Collins did a really good job of portraying the prejudice and racial (or would that be species, possibly both) tensions that arise simply because they don't understand each other. It's a major cultural clash, and no side handles it particularly well - all it takes is one little spark and the whole thing went up in a blaze of flames (this is actually literal too). I enjoyed the pacing (except towards the end where things wrapped up rather quickly) and the action going on.
Truthfully I'm enamored of the world more than the characters (with the exception of perhaps Scratch and Beanie). I like Tate and Hexe, don't get me wrong - its just between everything that's going on - all those pesky attempts to drive Tate away (and the murder attempts) don't give us a lot of chance to get to know them as a couple. I do get why Hexe is determined to keep on a Right Hand path, and I can respect that. We also get more of their personal histories and more personality but still not quite enough, not enough development I should say - especially when compared to the detail and effort gone into the world building. I did enjoy getting to know more about Hexe's family - it certainly explains somethings. Tate's family, well - I could be happy to never see them again (with the exception of her father, maybe). I think the funniest part of the story was when Scratch told Tate's mom off! I love that familiar - his reaction to Beanie was also amusing.
Would I like it better if I connected more with Tate and Hexe (and their relationship), yes. Do I like it anyway, Yes. I'm not precisely sure what it is…maybe it's that their relationship is a little too perfect - they seem to have no problems whatsoever with the other. The conflict about the stupid thing Tate does to trying to get her to leave were more half-hearted than anything. And that's another thing - why would Tate who has no way of defending herself go to an anti-human rally, alone without even telling anyone? She explains herself but it doesn't make sense - well at least not to me but maybe I have more common sense then her. I mean what did she expect to find/see/hear that she wouldn't be able to guess at without having gone to an ANTI-HUMAN rally? And the fight, which lasted a few sentences was really kind of meh. A part of me wants them to have a blow up so we can see what their made of and another part of me says it's more mature of them not to (I hate these conflicts of my own feelings). Not a big deal - only a bit baffling.
The only other issue/non-issue (yes it's one of those things I'm conflicted on) was Tate's gaining powers. Is it simply a result of living in Golgotham awakening a latent trait? Is it a result of her relationship with Hexe? Something else entirely? A combination of elements? Could it have something to do with how Tate's mom knows Syra (long-shot here, since it sounds like Syra may have simply sold her mom a love potion)? I look forward to seeing what this means, but I'll also miss Tate being just plain old human Tate. I know I complain about her not being strong enough or able to defend herself - but now she'll be a 'special' human in Golgotham like the other 'special' humans. I know I'm contrary and I drive me insane too. This doesn't bother me overly much - besides it's a really neat ability - being able to bring anything she creates out of metal to life. I also had that same feeling toward the end we were going to find out who Hexe's father was - and it was who I thought it was! I look forward to seeing that developed in future books. I also enjoyed Esau getting taken down, by the very demon he summoned! Talk about getting his just desserts, though I imagine it's possible for him to pop up again in the future.
Overall, I like this series quite a bit, certainly enough to keep following it for the moment. 4 stars.
Truthfully I'm enamored of the world more than the characters (with the exception of perhaps Scratch and Beanie). I like Tate and Hexe, don't get me wrong - its just between everything that's going on - all those pesky attempts to drive Tate away (and the murder attempts) don't give us a lot of chance to get to know them as a couple. I do get why Hexe is determined to keep on a Right Hand path, and I can respect that. We also get more of their personal histories and more personality but still not quite enough, not enough development I should say - especially when compared to the detail and effort gone into the world building. I did enjoy getting to know more about Hexe's family - it certainly explains somethings. Tate's family, well - I could be happy to never see them again (with the exception of her father, maybe). I think the funniest part of the story was when Scratch told Tate's mom off! I love that familiar - his reaction to Beanie was also amusing.
Would I like it better if I connected more with Tate and Hexe (and their relationship), yes. Do I like it anyway, Yes. I'm not precisely sure what it is…maybe it's that their relationship is a little too perfect - they seem to have no problems whatsoever with the other. The conflict about the stupid thing Tate does to trying to get her to leave were more half-hearted than anything. And that's another thing - why would Tate who has no way of defending herself go to an anti-human rally, alone without even telling anyone? She explains herself but it doesn't make sense - well at least not to me but maybe I have more common sense then her. I mean what did she expect to find/see/hear that she wouldn't be able to guess at without having gone to an ANTI-HUMAN rally? And the fight, which lasted a few sentences was really kind of meh. A part of me wants them to have a blow up so we can see what their made of and another part of me says it's more mature of them not to (I hate these conflicts of my own feelings). Not a big deal - only a bit baffling.
The only other issue/non-issue (yes it's one of those things I'm conflicted on) was Tate's gaining powers. Is it simply a result of living in Golgotham awakening a latent trait? Is it a result of her relationship with Hexe? Something else entirely? A combination of elements? Could it have something to do with how Tate's mom knows Syra (long-shot here, since it sounds like Syra may have simply sold her mom a love potion)? I look forward to seeing what this means, but I'll also miss Tate being just plain old human Tate. I know I complain about her not being strong enough or able to defend herself - but now she'll be a 'special' human in Golgotham like the other 'special' humans. I know I'm contrary and I drive me insane too. This doesn't bother me overly much - besides it's a really neat ability - being able to bring anything she creates out of metal to life. I also had that same feeling toward the end we were going to find out who Hexe's father was - and it was who I thought it was! I look forward to seeing that developed in future books. I also enjoyed Esau getting taken down, by the very demon he summoned! Talk about getting his just desserts, though I imagine it's possible for him to pop up again in the future.
Overall, I like this series quite a bit, certainly enough to keep following it for the moment. 4 stars.
June 18, 2014
Mon avis en Français
My English review
I read the first volume when it was released and I knew that I needed to immerse myself in the second novel. Finally with some time off, I took the opportunity to continue the Tate and Hexe’s adventures, two unusual characters.
It’s always quite funny because every time I read the name « Golgotham », I immediately think of the Batman’s city, « Gotham City », well it’s maybe only me but the resemblance is disturbing.
I thought I may finally understand the story about the hammer on the cover after my read. I must say that it was quite a strange object… Well then, I’m still thinking about its presence because I don’t have a clue. This is perhaps a little too subtle for me, but I’m already starting to scald assumptions. (Hey it’s true!) Maybe just to recall the Tate’s work? To show the revolt of this small town (yes I know I went that far, but hey, it’s a starting point, right?). But it is always a pleasure to discover more elements about this world. The idea of a separate district is not unique but it is with pleasure that we interact with all these creatures and we can assist to the the clash of two completely different cultures.
As I said at the beginning, we found our dear Tate spinning the perfect love with Hexe (yes she is a lucky girl!). But nothing can stay quiet that long, isn’t it? It is impossible of course. Everything starts to change when many tourists come in Golgotham, this part of the town that everyone avoids. But nothing goes well between humans and these creatures. And when riots broke out and that some murders are committed, nothing goes well. But now, even more than that, the Tate’s life is threatened. I was really surprised by the speed at which the chaos is settled, everything is quickly deteriorated and our two heroes are trying to understand what is happenning while trying to protect their own. Well I must say it is rather Hexe who will do the protection, because Tate is very good at getting into catastrophic situations. It was touching to see them together, evolving together; to see them facing discrimination as if nothing had happened, for the right to live together.
I was both surprised and at the same time we suspect about the culprit behind all these events. I must say that everything is really strange but it is quite complicated to assemble the pieces to really understand the final words. I was so happy at the end of the novel to know the reasons for all this. I also enjoyed to have the chance to discover more information about the Hexe’s family because his life is actually quite mysterious. We still have much to discover but it is still a good starting point.
This volume announces big changes in the Tate’s live, whenever it’s about her personal or professional life. All this announces once again big events whom we are curious to learn more about.
My English review
I read the first volume when it was released and I knew that I needed to immerse myself in the second novel. Finally with some time off, I took the opportunity to continue the Tate and Hexe’s adventures, two unusual characters.
It’s always quite funny because every time I read the name « Golgotham », I immediately think of the Batman’s city, « Gotham City », well it’s maybe only me but the resemblance is disturbing.
I thought I may finally understand the story about the hammer on the cover after my read. I must say that it was quite a strange object… Well then, I’m still thinking about its presence because I don’t have a clue. This is perhaps a little too subtle for me, but I’m already starting to scald assumptions. (Hey it’s true!) Maybe just to recall the Tate’s work? To show the revolt of this small town (yes I know I went that far, but hey, it’s a starting point, right?). But it is always a pleasure to discover more elements about this world. The idea of a separate district is not unique but it is with pleasure that we interact with all these creatures and we can assist to the the clash of two completely different cultures.
As I said at the beginning, we found our dear Tate spinning the perfect love with Hexe (yes she is a lucky girl!). But nothing can stay quiet that long, isn’t it? It is impossible of course. Everything starts to change when many tourists come in Golgotham, this part of the town that everyone avoids. But nothing goes well between humans and these creatures. And when riots broke out and that some murders are committed, nothing goes well. But now, even more than that, the Tate’s life is threatened. I was really surprised by the speed at which the chaos is settled, everything is quickly deteriorated and our two heroes are trying to understand what is happenning while trying to protect their own. Well I must say it is rather Hexe who will do the protection, because Tate is very good at getting into catastrophic situations. It was touching to see them together, evolving together; to see them facing discrimination as if nothing had happened, for the right to live together.
I was both surprised and at the same time we suspect about the culprit behind all these events. I must say that everything is really strange but it is quite complicated to assemble the pieces to really understand the final words. I was so happy at the end of the novel to know the reasons for all this. I also enjoyed to have the chance to discover more information about the Hexe’s family because his life is actually quite mysterious. We still have much to discover but it is still a good starting point.
This volume announces big changes in the Tate’s live, whenever it’s about her personal or professional life. All this announces once again big events whom we are curious to learn more about.
March 15, 2012
This series was one of my “finds” last year when I stumbled upon Right Hand Magic, the first book in this series. Ms. Collons was a new voice with fresh look at the urban fantasy genre that I had yet to be seen done before. The world of Golgotham was a living, breathing, tangible essence that nearly jumped off the pages. It was because of this experience that I was so eager to read the next book set in Golgotham, Left Hand Magic. And while the experience had a few misses, overall I was impressed with my second journey into Golgotham. So, come along with me to the gate of skulls and let us peek into NCY’s strangest neighborhood.
In Left Hand Magic we pick up pretty much where we left off with the beguiling Tate still finding her place as a human among the magical residents of Golgotham and Hexe using his right hand magic to heal and lift curses while trying to downplay his status as the heir apparent for the Kymeran throne—as ceremonial—for the most part—as that title may be. Uncle Esau takes the forefront as the villain in this book, and both black or left-hand magic and racial warmongering ensue.
I like this story a lot; I was fun and lighthearted while still keeping the tension to stop it from devolving into plain silliness. The plot in this book moved along already foreshadowed avenues, but in such a way as to avoid the often trite-feeling of being lead. My biggest problem with this book lay in the characterization; I even took over a month break from reading it when one too many times the main character made a stupid choice, even with the foresight to know that it was not-so-bright. That kind of decision making tends to irk me, and about two-thirds of the way through this story it managed to so to the point that I put the book down and walked away. Since finishing it, I can concede that the author did seem to have a purpose for sending her heroine into trouble, but even still it annoyed me. I hope that in future installments of this pretty fabulous series we see better choices in our main characters and a depth of characterization to match the stunning breadth of the world building.
http://masquerader.harshmage.com/cate...
In Left Hand Magic we pick up pretty much where we left off with the beguiling Tate still finding her place as a human among the magical residents of Golgotham and Hexe using his right hand magic to heal and lift curses while trying to downplay his status as the heir apparent for the Kymeran throne—as ceremonial—for the most part—as that title may be. Uncle Esau takes the forefront as the villain in this book, and both black or left-hand magic and racial warmongering ensue.
I like this story a lot; I was fun and lighthearted while still keeping the tension to stop it from devolving into plain silliness. The plot in this book moved along already foreshadowed avenues, but in such a way as to avoid the often trite-feeling of being lead. My biggest problem with this book lay in the characterization; I even took over a month break from reading it when one too many times the main character made a stupid choice, even with the foresight to know that it was not-so-bright. That kind of decision making tends to irk me, and about two-thirds of the way through this story it managed to so to the point that I put the book down and walked away. Since finishing it, I can concede that the author did seem to have a purpose for sending her heroine into trouble, but even still it annoyed me. I hope that in future installments of this pretty fabulous series we see better choices in our main characters and a depth of characterization to match the stunning breadth of the world building.
http://masquerader.harshmage.com/cate...
October 22, 2012
Tate and Hexe’s relationship has moved forward and she’s happier than ever in Golgotham, even if her parents don’t approve of her choice of boyfriends or address. Resident photog Bartho has had his pictures of Golgotham printed in a big-named magazine and it has brought more tourists and looky-loos to Golgotham. This doesn’t sit well with everyone and when a fight breaks out, the Golgothamites will get the short end of the stick. Now Golgothamites are being attacked and some killed by a ‘pro-human’ group called The Sons of Adam and the residents of Golgotham are planning to rise up and take back their streets. Will Tate and Hexe be able to find out the truth behind the two factions before more people are maimed or murdered?
‘Left Hand Magic’ is a great follow-up novel to ‘Right Hand Magic’, the first novel of Golgotham. Ms. Collins brings the ills of racism (or any other –ism) to the forefront as the Golgothamites and humans are pitted against one another. It’s a sad fact events like those in ‘Left Hand Magic’ still happen in our world. Zealotry and bigotry threaten to tear Tate and Hexe apart before they can discover who is behind this brewing maelstrom. The story flowed well and I was please by how Tate and Hexe were able to weather the pressures against them to maintain their relationship and who they are as individuals. While theirs is an unconventional relationship, it works. I still love Hexe’s familiar and the additional of Beanie, Tate’s new dog. ‘Left Hand Magic’ is an excellent novel and a wonderful addition to Ms. Collins’ bibliography.
Golgotham series: Right Hand Magic (1), Left Hand Magic (2), Magic and Loss (3)
‘Left Hand Magic’ is a great follow-up novel to ‘Right Hand Magic’, the first novel of Golgotham. Ms. Collins brings the ills of racism (or any other –ism) to the forefront as the Golgothamites and humans are pitted against one another. It’s a sad fact events like those in ‘Left Hand Magic’ still happen in our world. Zealotry and bigotry threaten to tear Tate and Hexe apart before they can discover who is behind this brewing maelstrom. The story flowed well and I was please by how Tate and Hexe were able to weather the pressures against them to maintain their relationship and who they are as individuals. While theirs is an unconventional relationship, it works. I still love Hexe’s familiar and the additional of Beanie, Tate’s new dog. ‘Left Hand Magic’ is an excellent novel and a wonderful addition to Ms. Collins’ bibliography.
Golgotham series: Right Hand Magic (1), Left Hand Magic (2), Magic and Loss (3)
June 6, 2014
This was a hard book to read with all the racial tension, prejudice, and hate shouted liberally in every direction. (Each magic series has its own word for average human and in this series the term was "nump" and honestly, in this book I got irritated with the word fast). From the prejudice of the Kymerians over the Sufference when witches were burned at the stake that still lingers with them through to the modern age, to the hostility of the humans who don't like having such odd neighbors camping in the middle of their city, to the skin-head group The Sons of Adam who start inflicting brutal beatings and murders every chance they get. But I still dearly love Hexe. He's a very well-crafted character with his purple hair, six fingers on each hand, love of wearing dragon pattered robes in the morning and T-shirts and ratted jeans in the day, and truly odd diet. And Tate is a wonderful viewpoint to follow. She has bravery (though some times stupidity for running head-long into situations), and she's willing to use what's around her (like her welding equipment) to defend herself regardless if she's magically out-classed, not to mention she looks beyond the differences in the magical creatures surrounding her and just sees them as people. Not to mention that this series is chock full of magic, magical creatures, and something surprising around every corner, while still being rooted in New York City. The series is quite a bit like Jim Butcher's Harry Dresden series, but without the hard-boiled detective aspect.
January 14, 2012
As sweet as a Roman holiday with a paranormal bent, LEFT-HAND MAGIC delivers two charming, sheltered scions with the gumption and potential to live up to their ideals. Both Hexe and Tate are a bit more starry eyed than I can claim, but I found them both relatable and loveable in this as they stand up against injustice, their parents, and the expectations of the world at large.
Though the mechanics of a magical New York neighborhood that *hadn't* been invaded by hipsters seemed a bit shaky, I found the inhabitants of Golgotham fascinating. With a zest that reminded me of reading my first Harry Potter, I found the fanny-pack wearing centaurs and love lorn maenads irresistible. Even Tate and Hexe were their own brands of exotic creatures, young and idealistic and the products of a wealthy upbringing.
Though this was my first taste of Golgotham, I had no trouble falling I to the story. I think skipping book one made me roll my eyes a bit when Tate and Hexe were declaring their devotion (c'mmon, you just moved in with this guy after a few weeks, we're really using the 'L' word?), but ultimately that just left me curious enough to want to head back to book one and read for myself where the magic began.
Sexual content: references to sex.
Though the mechanics of a magical New York neighborhood that *hadn't* been invaded by hipsters seemed a bit shaky, I found the inhabitants of Golgotham fascinating. With a zest that reminded me of reading my first Harry Potter, I found the fanny-pack wearing centaurs and love lorn maenads irresistible. Even Tate and Hexe were their own brands of exotic creatures, young and idealistic and the products of a wealthy upbringing.
Though this was my first taste of Golgotham, I had no trouble falling I to the story. I think skipping book one made me roll my eyes a bit when Tate and Hexe were declaring their devotion (c'mmon, you just moved in with this guy after a few weeks, we're really using the 'L' word?), but ultimately that just left me curious enough to want to head back to book one and read for myself where the magic began.
Sexual content: references to sex.
August 13, 2016
Fun, relatively light* and fast-moving read that might especially appeal to those readers looking for an urban fantasy novel-series that's a shade darker and more mature than a YA novel (this is not meant in a demeaning way - there's hints of sex, but nothing even remotely explicit and the magic and violence of the first two books is PG-13 at worst).
There's a 'mystery' - hidden villains and secret associations - element to the book, but, as in Right Hand Magic , they're easy - intentionally so - to suss out.
I enjoyed this a lot, found it difficult to set down; in fact, I read it in a couple of hours. Left Hand Magic is worth your money and time, if the above-paragraph description sounds like that something that would grab you.
Followed by Magic and Loss.
[*compared to Collins' dark, ultra-violent Sonja Blue series]
(This review originally appeared on the Reading & Writing By Pub Light site.)
There's a 'mystery' - hidden villains and secret associations - element to the book, but, as in Right Hand Magic , they're easy - intentionally so - to suss out.
I enjoyed this a lot, found it difficult to set down; in fact, I read it in a couple of hours. Left Hand Magic is worth your money and time, if the above-paragraph description sounds like that something that would grab you.
Followed by Magic and Loss.
[*compared to Collins' dark, ultra-violent Sonja Blue series]
(This review originally appeared on the Reading & Writing By Pub Light site.)
August 11, 2016
Tate and Hexe are trying to create a happily ever in Golgotham but life is not easy for the human and Kymeran. First there are racial riots and tension in Golgotham between human tourists and the native Golgotham’s, then everyone thinks the couple should break up because it is not good for the royal family nor is it good for the heiress.
I admit I absolutely loved this story. Ms. Collins has created a highly plausible world where tension probably would be high between humans and magical people. The situation was further complicated when the result of these actions had some real consequences people are taken advantage of and they are hurt. I really enjoyed the relationship between Tate and Hexe, while at times they are very corny they are also still two people who are fighting to be with each other. It was also interesting to see how this story is revolving around Tate and understanding her motives and choices.
The only reason why I am not rating this one a five is because the end was a bit rushed and there were these really interesting story lines that were summed up but it did not feel complete.
Even still great book!
I admit I absolutely loved this story. Ms. Collins has created a highly plausible world where tension probably would be high between humans and magical people. The situation was further complicated when the result of these actions had some real consequences people are taken advantage of and they are hurt. I really enjoyed the relationship between Tate and Hexe, while at times they are very corny they are also still two people who are fighting to be with each other. It was also interesting to see how this story is revolving around Tate and understanding her motives and choices.
The only reason why I am not rating this one a five is because the end was a bit rushed and there were these really interesting story lines that were summed up but it did not feel complete.
Even still great book!
December 15, 2012
While I still enjoyed this as a really fun read, all of the characters come across as really naive, gullible, unsubtle, take your pick. I figured out the 'twists' within the first chapter or two so there wasn't much suspense involved. The main characters barely if ever questioned anything around them. They accepted what they were told or experienced without much reflection over the larger implications or even a comment to themselves that something was odd. That's a little weird.
I will definitely be reading the next book as it comes out but I hope the author will have learned to bury the lead a little to make it harder for the reader to figure out what is going on. I don't expect a big mystery style novel but a little surprise now and then would be fun. Between the prophesy in the first novel and the lack of subterfuge by any of the characters, this is a straightforward albeit fun read.
I will definitely be reading the next book as it comes out but I hope the author will have learned to bury the lead a little to make it harder for the reader to figure out what is going on. I don't expect a big mystery style novel but a little surprise now and then would be fun. Between the prophesy in the first novel and the lack of subterfuge by any of the characters, this is a straightforward albeit fun read.
January 31, 2012
Left Hand Magic was such a great read.
I absolutely love this pair of characters and the New York quadrant they live in. Nancy Collins has created an amazing Urban Fantasy team in Tate and Hexe and Left Hand Magic picks up right where Right Hand left off.
The tides are turning in Golgotham as Esau is brewing up a rebellion. As the magic flows and the humans and preternaturals collide Tate is caught in the middle and has to choose her place in her world by not only standing up for herself, but also standing up for her new Family in Golgotham. With a fast paced story, Left Hand Magic is unforgettable. With a change in the air and in the feelings of the crowds of humans and otherworlders change is coming and for many it will cost not only their lives, but their livelihoods.
Nancy Collins has created a great up and coming series that grabs readers and keeps them hungering for more.
I absolutely love this pair of characters and the New York quadrant they live in. Nancy Collins has created an amazing Urban Fantasy team in Tate and Hexe and Left Hand Magic picks up right where Right Hand left off.
The tides are turning in Golgotham as Esau is brewing up a rebellion. As the magic flows and the humans and preternaturals collide Tate is caught in the middle and has to choose her place in her world by not only standing up for herself, but also standing up for her new Family in Golgotham. With a fast paced story, Left Hand Magic is unforgettable. With a change in the air and in the feelings of the crowds of humans and otherworlders change is coming and for many it will cost not only their lives, but their livelihoods.
Nancy Collins has created a great up and coming series that grabs readers and keeps them hungering for more.
July 29, 2012
I'm really liking this series. It's very different from the other series' that I read. Although, something that happened in the end of the second book might change a bit of that dynamic.
I'm really glad that Nancy Collins is writing books that I want to read again. I loved her Sonja Blue series years ago and although this is nothing like it, I still love her writing and her different take on things. She wrote the comic Swamp Thing for a time and I liked it. Then, it seemed as if she dropped out of writing for awhile and I ran across the first of her Golgotham series in a local bookstore last year and was so excited to find a new book of hers. I looked her up and discovered she had been writing, but had been writing some Young Adult books. I tried reading them, but it just wasn't my thing. Anyway, glad to see her writing again. :)
I'm really glad that Nancy Collins is writing books that I want to read again. I loved her Sonja Blue series years ago and although this is nothing like it, I still love her writing and her different take on things. She wrote the comic Swamp Thing for a time and I liked it. Then, it seemed as if she dropped out of writing for awhile and I ran across the first of her Golgotham series in a local bookstore last year and was so excited to find a new book of hers. I looked her up and discovered she had been writing, but had been writing some Young Adult books. I tried reading them, but it just wasn't my thing. Anyway, glad to see her writing again. :)
March 14, 2013
A series that got even better with book 2, I do love when that happens.
In this one things are heating up between humans and, well non-humans. Tate is in the middle of it all as she lives in Golgatham. Yes Tate, I do like her cos she is not kick-ass, neither is she a damsel in distress. She is just your average kind of human who loves to make things in her studio. She has a warlock boyfriend and she is very curious. Yes that puts her in trouble too. I do love kick-ass heroines, but it's a nice change to have someone like Tate. She also puts all her faith in love, because when things got tricky in Golgatham, well I would have left. It was scary there for a long moment of the book.
Oh look I made this short :D
A great series, that I do recommend.
In this one things are heating up between humans and, well non-humans. Tate is in the middle of it all as she lives in Golgatham. Yes Tate, I do like her cos she is not kick-ass, neither is she a damsel in distress. She is just your average kind of human who loves to make things in her studio. She has a warlock boyfriend and she is very curious. Yes that puts her in trouble too. I do love kick-ass heroines, but it's a nice change to have someone like Tate. She also puts all her faith in love, because when things got tricky in Golgatham, well I would have left. It was scary there for a long moment of the book.
Oh look I made this short :D
A great series, that I do recommend.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 61 reviews