"Slaughter vividly conveys the reality of combat during World War II in his book with sweeping passages that literally place his reader on the battlefield beside him." Belvoir Eagle
Before D-Day, regular army soldiers called the National Guardsmen of Virginia's 116th Infantry Regiment "Home Nannies" and "Weekend Warriors" and worse. On June 6, 1944, on Omaha Beach, however, these proud Virginians who carried the legacy of the famed Stonewall Brigade showed the regular army and the world what true valor really was. In this moving World War II memoir, the author captures the life of GI Joe from pre-Pearl Harbor days through training, deployment overseas, and more training. All leads up to D-Day and Normandy on June 6, 1944, when Sergeant Bob Slaughter came across Omaha Beach with Company D of the 116th Infantry and the Bedford Boys.
Excellent autobiography of Sgt. John Slaughter, of the 29th Infantry Division, who hit Omaha Beach on 6 June 1944 and (with a brief time out recovering from wounds) made it to the Elbe River. After enlisting at age 16, Slaughter was the first of the 29th to be rotated back to the States at war’s end—he had more points than anyone else by a huge margin.
Coming home, he describes his difficulty in adapting to civilian life, then his dedication to creating a National D-Day Memorial in Bedford, Virginia (near his home): the town that lost more men per capita then any other on the longest day.
Slaughter’s memoirs are written in a plain, but punchy style. He transmits the horror of starting in a Division of about 1,000 men (many of which he knew), losing about half the first day, and ending the war with no more than 150. There were three 29th Divisions, he says: one on the battlefield, a second made up of replacements with six weeks of training, and a third in graveyards.
This is a different tale than “Band of Brothers.” There are no brothers here. There are few heroes. Only a terrible war, a man with a job to do, who did it well, and also was lucky. And, for the most part, he never learned the names of replacements—KIA or WIA too fast to remember 60 years later. That speaks volumes.
I enjoy war memoirs. This one was written and edited well, so naturally I liked it.
Slaughter joined the National Guard at age 15. When it was federalized for a year, he thought it would be a good chance to get three square meals a day and a little spending money. He didn't expect to go to war. But Pearl Harbor changed a lot of things.
This book covers his training in the states and in England, then his time in combat. Slaughter landed on Omaha beach on D-Day. He fought in the Norman hedgerows, spent time in a hospital in England, and then rejoined his unit for the push into Germany. It covers the funny and the gruesome, the brave and the not-so-brave, bureaucratic SNAFUs and combat brotherhood. Slaughter also describes his efforts to ensure D-day wasn't forgotten, including his work the help establish the National D-Day Memorial in Bedford, VA.
The book's appendix includes several other first-hand accounts of D-day. I often skip appendixes, but this book's are worth reading.
Overall, a good read about one man's WWII experience.
Omaha Beach through the Eyes of Teenage Boy ..., August 8, 2011
Of the scores of books covering the dramatic D-Day invasion in 1944, there are relatively few first-hand accounts from those who survived the initial assault on Omaha Beach, let alone live long enough to write about it 65 years later. Thankfully, Sgt. Bob Slaughter is still alive to serve as one, if not the last, voice of a generation of (very) young men that accomplished the deadly and daring task of storming the beaches of Normandy against overwhelming odds. Slaughter's book OMAHA BEACH AND BEYOND serves as a shining example of the type of individual that carried out the D-Day operation ... the typical all-American boy.
I was familiar with Sgt. Slaughter prior to the release of his book mainly due to his home-town (Roanoke, VA) hero status as a D-Day veteran and his prominent role in bringing the National D-Day Memorial to nearby Bedford, Virginia (the chosen location because it had the greatest per capita loss of life during the invasion of any town in the United States). Slaughter's post-war career with the Roanoke Times newspaper is probably key to the paper graciously providing readers in our region with an annual dose of D-Day anniversary coverage and his presence alongside US Presidents at annual D-Day commemorative events are indicative of his national significance as a surviving Omaha Beach veteran. I found Slaughter's "Ernie Pyle-esque" writing style of his wartime experience as surprisingly fresh, honest and open. OMAHA BEACH AND BEYOND is not a rehash of the operations history, but a very personal and unique view of the events of June 6 (and beyond) through the eyes of a teenage boy.
What really stands out in Slaughter's book is that it is easy to assimilate his voice representing the millions of men who quietly and patriotically answered their country's call to duty, completed their task and quietly merged back into the "normal" world of civilian life once the war was over. Slaughter was only 16 years old when he enlisted in the US Army through the National Guard ... a mere kid. The optimistic, youthful exuberance of his early days in the Army are told in a manner that could easily parallel a man recalling his youth in the Boy Scouts. Although there was a serious global war being fought and Slaughter knew he and his buddies would be participating in it soon enough; his recollection of events leading up to that moment still read more like kids preparing for a grand adventure than an uncertain future ... young, energetic, mischievous and naïve. Slaughter introduces the reader to the rest of the "boys" in Company D, as well as their leaders (who would still be considered boys by today's standard) in a manner that reminds me of Ernie Pyle's BRAVE MEN. The tone gets serious when the training becomes more specialized and it is evident that the men are preparing for a monumental operation. As the Normandy operation unfolds, Slaughter's recollections are vivid, matter-of-fact and serious; the reader braces his or herself alongside Slaughter as his landing craft approaches the Normandy coast. Moment-by-moment we experience a sense of anxiety as the craft is enveloped in sea-spray and hot lead as the enemy beings targeting the boats approaching the shore ... we even feel a sense of urgency to get out of the boat. The detail of events from the moment Slaughter departs from his landing craft to the eventual securing of the beachhead will probably remind readers of that visceral opening scene in "Saving Private Ryan" ... the deafening cacophony of hell breaking loose and people getting killed everywhere. The "storming of the beach moment" is both exhilarating and scary; the pace of the book is somewhat frenetic. There is an appreciated sense of catching one's breath when Slaughter finally has the opportunity to rest from the morning's events, look back at the beach and reflect on what he'd just been through. I'm sure many readers will wonder, as I did, how the 6'5" Slaughter lived to write about the experience in first place.
While D-Day comprises the bulk of Slaughter's combat action, plenty more subsequent combat occurs such as the capture of St. Lo (which officially secured the beachhead), the vicious hedgerow fighting, the Battle of the Bulge and fighting in Germany. There is a notable difference in the tone of the book following D-Day ... the stories are no longer being told through the eyes of a boy, but from the point-of-view of grizzled veteran. The maturation process that was surviving Omaha Beach is clearly evident. A Sergeant before the age of twenty, Slaughter's numbness to the rigors of combat become evident and the reader can sense the sudden loss of innocence that many of these young men must have experienced during the war.
I found OMAHA BEACH AND BEYOND to be a fascinating read and a fresh view of an event that has become somewhat media-saturated in that the same stories are constantly being retold. The appendices at the end of the book are a bonus as they include several other colorful first-person Omaha Beach accounts, D-Company casualties and a section explaining the nature of Normandy's tides as it related to the landings. OMAHA BEACH AND BEYOND is a most-welcomed addition to my World War II library.
Folks, let me tell you. I read a multitude of books each year and maybe, just maybe there are a handful that makes it to my hands that will forever stay on my shelf. This is one of those books. Don’t get me wrong, I have read some good ones and have enjoyed many of them. However, I am talking about a step above the betters.
What really drew me into this book was the personal and genuine way that this story was told. I actually felt that I was sitting and talking, just Bob and myself. A story that I would imagine that is told to children and grand children to remember who he was and he wanted to pass it along. It may sound strange but I did feel a part of the family.
The book covers so much more than the war itself. From Bob’s childhood, family and friends to the makings of a soldier who did not know what he was getting himself in to and to his life now. The amazement of travel and the candid pranks and trouble he got into. It’s all there for you, just pull up a chair and sit a while.
The war years express a deep feeling for his friends he fought with and knew and the horrors of events that we all hope will never be seen again. Omaha Beach and Beyond: The Long March of Sergeant Bob Slaughter should, and I hope later on it will be in audio form as well. You will not be disappointed in the read I promise.
I know I did not go into detail chronicling the book itself and there is a reason for it. It is like trying to explain the most adrenaline filled moment you have ever had and then turn the page and experience the lowest you have ever been. That may sound like a negative but I assure you it’s not. It is a genuine, heartfelt and personal experience that was a pleasure not only to read but also to be a part of the legacy. Thanks Mr. Bob.
Craig Anderson Our History Project ourhistoryproject.com
Solid account of not only Omaha Beach but of the federalization of the 29th Infantry Division and later journey all the way to Warendorf, Germany.
This will be an excellent account for present and future historians.
The book reads a lot like Charles MacDonald's "Company Commander" in that is focuses a lot on the individual and the unit. In this case, D-Company of the 116th regiment.
I found it interesting how very little was placed on the camaraderie. By that I mean there were no best friends singled out. Rather, the author clearly choose to focus on all the men in the regiment and respecting them all.
There were two accounts of the author encountering German soldiers. I felt that both these accounts are important when studying this time. One cannot narrow the lens on just Germany's leader(s). The book conveys that the WWII German soldier can be human.
It is stunning to think that this 6 foot 5 inch individual made it through the ETO with a shrapnel wound and a bullet grazing his forehead. To say he was lucky would be an understatement. Especially after stepping through a dead mine trap.
The book had many great tidbits. One critical to understanding Omaha Beach was how much equipment the soldiers were given. Instead of being loaded like rabbits they were loaded like pack mules; this book highlights this fact.
Other great stories were his training and how fascinating that was. Much of the novel early days focus on his volunteering for the Rangers and training with British Commandos. There was also the time he was invited over to the German house at the conclusion of the war and deterred the Russians from entering and ransacking the house.
This is a great candidate for a re-read years later.
This was the book I needed to read to fully understand what my father experienced in the Normandy Invasion...he was in the second wave but this was not something he wanted to talk about or remember...he did say that he relived it every night in his dreams...I realize that he had PTSD and didn't tolerate stress or controversy well...the horrors that he and other young men faced and lived through were truly life changing.
This memoir was very well written and provided great detail of a foot soldiers experience...I thank them all for their dedication against all odds and for our freedom....I hope to visit the memorial in Virginia soon.
I cried at the end of the book...I finally understood my father
The book devotes a lot of pages to pre-invasion training, which is understandable since most of the author’s service was spent in training.
The descriptions of the actual landing on Omaha beach were quite interesting. The end of the book has several stories by others who participated in the first wave of the landings as well. This is the strength of the book.
The “beyond” part falls short. The author was very fortunate to have survived to the end of the war but chose not to reveal much about the actual combat that he participated in. Their is no mention, for example, of his ever firing his weapon.
To me, those who survived, and those who died on the beaches that day, are all heroes.
Loved this book. Great forward by Alex. Makes you question whether you truly are grateful for our WW2 vets. The author had a butter smooth narrative that was pleasing to read. I could probably read everything he ever wrote just to relax. There’s nothing relaxing about the content however. Detailed and gory at times. Wish there were more details at the end of “his war”. That’s the reason for 4 stars. I wanted more. It’s well worth your money and man...what a dramatic experience Omaha must have been
This book is an important contribution to the first-person accounts of the Second World War. Sergeant Slaughter was one of the few who survived the slaughterhouse (no pun intended) of Omaha Beach on D-Day. As a member of the 116th Infantry Regiment (a direct descendent of Stonewall Jackson’s Second Brigade, nicknamed “The Stonewallers”), of the 29th Infantry Division, he experienced some of the War’s most brutal fighting and heartfelt disappointments.
The “Blue and Gray” division was one of the first American divisions sent to England. While there, a special formation of U.S. Army Rangers was forming up and took its volunteers from the 29th Division. They were trained hard in the moors of Scotland by the tough British Commandos and achieved a high state of physical fitness and combat readiness. Then surprisingly, after almost a year, the 29th Rangers (Provisional) were disbanded and the soldiers returned to their original units. The men were devastated and never received an explanation. Not much had been previously written about this episode.
The 29th was in the first wave at Omaha Beach. The naval gunfire failed to hit targets on the bluffs. The air forces missed those targets as well and failed to provide any craters on the beach that might have served as protected firing points for the infantry. The special tanks (DD Tanks) outfitted with flotation collars designed to allow them to swim ashore were swamped by the fast-running tides and sunk. Thus, the first wave had to face the relentless German gunfire without any of the support designed to assist them and they paid the price in blood. That any survived was a miracle but the few accounts of the few who survived remain an important contribution to history.
There were some scholarship issues in this book. The First Marine Division, that practiced beach landings with the 29th Infantry Division, did not go on to invade the Philippines but rather they landed on Guadalcanal on the Solomon Island chain in August, 1942 (Page 41). Germany and Italy did not declare war on the United States the day after Pearl Harbor (December 8, 1941). They declared war on the U.S. on December 11 (Page 39). However, I fault the military editor for these mishaps and not the author.
The maps in this book are very good and the photographs are interesting but the insight and perspective of one who lived through it make this book a “must read” for anyone interested in World War II. It was an invaluable source for my own historical novel.
This was a phenomenal account by someone who was there - a veteran of D-Day who fought all the way to the Elbe River. Bob Slaughter's stories are vivid and engaging. There are only two minor flaws. The first is that, at times, the narrative jumps forward and back a few days; a description on the 29th's activity on a Wednesday might precede a description of action on a Tuesday, and then might jump ahead to a Thursday. The second minor flaw is that there are occasions where the author misstates a statement of fact; stating that the Ninth Air Force included medium bombers like the B-26 and B-24 (when it should be B-26 and B-25 - the B-24 was a heavy bomber), or that a destroyer supported an attack with 8-inch guns (destroyers carried 5-inch guns).
These minor flaws in no way mar the value or enjoyment of this book.
I spent some time thinking about how I would rate this book. In terms of importance, this book rates easily at 5-stars, namely because a book like this needs to be written so as to not forget what happened. This is especially the case because this book was written by someone who was there. However, I found the actual book, namely the battle descriptions, hard to wrap my mind around, although I certainly did enjoy reading this book. Lets just hope more people are able to share their experiences during this monumental time.
I liked this book, but it wasn't one of the better WW2 biographies that I have read. It was told in such a way that entire battles lasted no more than a page and there wasn't much detail to it. I understand that the writer may not have wanted to dwell on certain things and aspects of his stories, but if that's the case then why write the story?
For an avid reader and someone who wants to expand upon WW2 this is something that I'd add to my reading list, but if you were to read one WW2 novel in your life, this would not be the one that I would recommend.
This is a book that I could not put down. While reading it, I commented that it would be hard from now on to complain about anything in my own life. The endurance of the soldiers who lived through these battles is amazing, and the fact that so many were cut down in youth is so sad. The heroes of World War II should never be forgotten, and this book is a fascinating look at war told from a heroic soldier's perspective. I highly recommend it!