New York to Dallas is the 33rd book in J.D. Robb’s immensely popular futuristic series that shows what happens after the HEA ends with the main couple who end up married. Eve Dallas and Roarke is one of my all favorite romantic couples. Roarke is my favorite hero hands down, regardless of him being way too perfect for words. After so many books with these two, I feel as if they’re old friends I can turn to for comfort. Also I love how the series takes place in New York City and forty years in a future I can see coming to pass. I can’t wait for the day when I can have my own flying car and auto chef.
New York to Dallas should be a milestone in this series. I knew something big was going to go down when for the first time, the title didn’t have the two words- In Death. I had an inkling what this shocking reveal might be that happens in this story, and I was correct. Unfortunately the way this was divulged was less than satisfactory. It was very lacking and just thrown in there, as if Robb knew what her readers wanted and she had to give them something to make them happy. Lately, I’ve become fatigued with this series. After 33 books, what more can you do? I love seeing the tender side of Roarke and Eve and how they’re still trying to figure each other out. These two are such opposites, and for all purposes, shouldn’t be able to sustain a relationship together. But they do, and even though the toughest of times, they work out their issues and always go to bed together, waking up the next morning in each other’s arms. Most of the time Eve is a snarling cranky wench the next day, while Roarke just sits there placating her with his swarmy sexiness.
New York to Dallas is set up like most of the past books. A horrible crime has been committed and Eve must solve it, always with Roarke lending more than a helping hand. But this latest case hits close to home for Eve. A pedophile killer has broken out of jail, which coincidentally is the first case Eve ever solved. The pedophile, Issac McQueen was the first criminal Eve brought down when she was still green and just starting out as a police officer. Now that Issac is on the loose, he’s up to his old tricks and has targeted Eve. Also, Issac may be hiding out in Dallas, Texas. Eve once lived there as a child and was left by her mother who in turn was horribly abuse by her father, who she killed in self-defense as he tried to rape her again. Eve has to confront her past again, while remaining strong as she tries to figure out where Issac is, who’s helping him and stop him from kidnapping, raping and killing young girls.
The McQueen case hits Eve hard because she once was a victim just like the girls McQueen targets. Whenever young girls are involved and brutalized by some monster, Eve takes it personally because she was once in their shoes. But the McQueen case takes on a whole new meaning because someone working with McQueen may have ties to Eve’s past and her parents.
I was so hoping New York to Dallas would hit one out of the park for me. It didn’t. I did find the case and the non-stop action from Eve and her crew to be on the edge of your seat material, but it feels as if it has that been there, done that feeling to it already. The way Eve and Roarke interact has become routine, even down to the minimal love scenes they share together. At a certain point I felt as if these two were tired about everything and they need to get away to regroup.
The big twist that should shock failed for me. The way it was revealed was poorly executed and comes out of the blue, more like a throwaway. It didn’t really fit, and even when Eve has that light bulb moment, I had to re-read because it was confusing. I felt as if I missed something, as if Robb left out a few important pieces that should have been introduced earlier on. This spoiler really closes up so many loose ends for Eve and her past, and I wonder if perhaps Robb perhaps is decided to finally end this series. There’s not much more she can do with the characters. They can’t really grow anymore and they have become static. Even if a new uber type villain is introduced to shake things up, it really wouldn’t breathe life back into this series.
All parties have to end and with the In Death books and the case of Eve and Roarke, I really think it’s time to say goodbye and say thanks for the good times. New York to Dallas was more ho hum reading with a few zingers here and there, but not enough to keep me reading this series indefinitely.
I was hoping for so much more with this book, but in the end it just didn’t deliver.