Walter Model i strid - andra världskriget

Command #15

by Robert Forczyk

Swedish / Svenska

Genres: Biography, World War II, Military History, Nonfiction

1 pages, Hardcover

First published January 1, 2011

About the author

Robert Forczyk has a PhD in International Relations and National Security from the University of Maryland and a strong background in European and Asian military history.

Reviews

[Creighton · Rating 5 out of 5]

Walter Model: an interesting man, with an interesting background. There has been a mixture of feelings towards him by various historians, but honestly, he was a soldier, a general, and in all honesty, from the standpoint of a historian, he fought and defeated his enemies with skill. Model was one of the few who defeated Zhukov, Bradley, and Montgomery in the field of battle, and it was because of his skill that Germany was not crushed much earlier in the war. There were no written memoirs left by Model, so any books written on him are worth reading, however one must always think critically about these figures
From history .


In this book, the author talks about models life, his achievements, why he is such a skilled general in terms of the German Wehrmacht, and how he used defensive tactics, that wore down and defeated allied armies. The author wants the reader to think critically about Models relationship with Hitler and his henchmen, presenting shifting views on the general by his peers and historians. Despite this, it is a great book, and I learned more about Model and his achievements than I had before.

[Naing Lin · Rating 4 out of 5]

It could be a page-turner for historians but really enjoyable read for me. It illustrates how much hardships Model would struggle in both fronts, and his constant defensive welfare delaying third Reich from imminent defeat. I personally find him as one of the most underrated commanders in Wehrmacht. Contrary to German commanders who are succubus to Blitzkrieg doctrine, he spends most of his time from hardening the lines, keeping zone defense and saving his troops from pockets. To quote it from the book,

"Model is remembered as a fine tactician and stubborn defensive commander, but his detractors - of whom there were many - tend to define him as sycophantic if not servile to Hitler, lacking the operational brilliance of Manstein or charisma of Rommel."

[Robert · Rating 4 out of 5]

Short book in the Osprey Commanders series. History and achievements of “Hitler’s Fireman”

[Thomas Schandolph · Rating 4 out of 5]

Fascinating read. Model truly is one of the greatest military minds of history, though I'd much rather have him on defense than offense. My only complaint is that this book isn't longer!

[Sean Chick · Rating 3 out of 5]

I usually like Forczyk's work, although his heavy German bias is evident here. Model is depicted as a tough defensive fighter with a lot of varied experience, leading to an attention to detail that few commanders possessed. All of this is true enough. Where Forczyk fails is in ignoring Model's severe moral failings and in disparaging Allied commanders, particularly Bradley. Not a bad book as an introduction, but be aware this is written by a fan, and that Model was notorious for his acquiescence to Nazism even if he was not a true believer like Walther von Reichenau, Ernst Busch, and to a lesser degree Heinz Guderian.