The dreamer of the day
When I asked my brother, who is a connoisseur of T.E. Lawrence biographies, which one would be a good one to start with he suggested Michael Korda’s ‘Hero’. For one thing, it’s the most recent full-scale biography. Yes, it’s long but there are much longer tomes out there. He told me don’t start with Lawrence’s dense thicket of prose, ‘Seven Pillars of Wisdom’. Get the basic facts down first, then dive into Lawrence’s own assessment of what he did.
‘Hero’ begins in the middle of the action, as Lawrence leads a coalition of Arab forces upon an assault on the valuable port city of Aqaba after having crossed several hundred miles of treacherous desert. For those familiar with the classic film ‘Lawrence of Arabia’, this is the center of the film, the major victory that not only spurred the Arab tribes into active rebellion against Turkish domination but got the attention of Lawrence’s superior British officers. This sprang from a strategy that Lawrence devised, unauthorized by British command headquarters, who had to acknowledge the successful the results that this lower ranking officer, in their eyes merely a Middle East authority and advisor, could get from unlikely soldiers. The desert crossing itself was a major accomplishment, where Lawrence proved his mettle to the Arabs by enduring every hardship that they were capable of dealing with. At one point, a man turned up lost. Lawrence went back alone for several miles to locate the man, who had drifted off and fallen from his camel, carrying him back on his own camel, and catching up with the rest of the Arabs. Later during the same journey, arising from a dispute between a man from one tribe and a man from another, one man killed the other man. As a neutral arbiter and to prevent a blood feud, Lawrence carried out the justice that would not offend either tribe by executing the perpetrator himself. This was one of the first of many difficult decisions to kill that weighed on Lawrence’s conscience. Lawrence taught guerilla warfare to the Arabs as well as the use of explosives, which he employed toward blowing up railroads upon which the Turks transported supplies. He didn’t want to completely destroy the railroads but to keep blowing up portions to keep the Turks in a constant state of needing to repair them while debilitating their strength.
After the extremely readable, action-packed first two chapters, Korda goes back in time to chronicle the backgrounds of each of Lawrence’s parents. Lawrence’s father, an Irishman named Thomas Chapman, who had four daughters from a still-extant but unhappy marriage and fell in love with his daughters’ governess, Sarah Lawrence. His wife refused to give him a divorce and so he left with Sarah and moved to Wales, where they presented themselves as Mr. and Mrs. Lawrence and later moved to Oxford. They had five sons, of which Thomas Edward was the second. Ned was always a rebellious son and he repeatedly clashed with his pious mother. Even before he confirmed it, he knew he was illegitimate but did not at first realize that he and his brothers were all born out of wedlock. From an early age, he was a loner and a scholar who developed interests with archaeology, languages, and mapmaking. He also envisioned a heroic destiny:
“[He] aspired to be both a leader of men and a hero. He claimed that when he was a boy his ambition had been “to be a general and knighted by the time he was thirty,” and both goals would come close to being within his grasp at that age, had he still wanted them.”
After embarking on archaeological digs for ancient artifacts in Carchemish in the years before World War I broke out, he enlisted in the army and, based on his knowledge of the area, was assigned to the Arab Bureau in Cairo. He had prepared himself well for the role he eventually played, learning about the history as well as studying military tactics. When he embedded himself in the Arab forces, he quickly adopted to their customs and grew sympathetic to their desire for independence and to form their own nation state. This put him in an awkward position for someone who was supposed to represent British interests. He later wrote:
“A man who gives himself to the possessions of aliens leads a Yahoo life…He is not one of them…In my case my effort for these years to live in the dress of Arabs, and to imitate their mental foundation, quitted me of my English self, and let me look at the West and its conventions with new eyes, and destroyed it all for me. At the same time I could not sincerely take on the Arab skin: it was an affectation only.”
Lawrence presented the British cause to the Arabs as a gift of independence for them to rule themselves. However, he was fully aware of the Sikes-Picot agreement between Britain and France, which arbitrarily divided the borders of the Arab territory between British and French rule, without respect to tribal differences or long-held hostilities between the Arabs and the Jews. All the careful tactics he planned to help them win the war against the Turks would be in vain. After a reconnaissance mission into the Turkish stronghold in Daraa led to his capture, torture, and rape Lawrence was a broken man. According to Korda, Lawrence’s reaction to his mother’s religious upbringing led him to an aversion to all sexuality or touching of any sort which the Turkish assault on his body confirmed. The total breaking of his will by the Turks increased his post-traumatic stress combined with his intense guilt. At this point, he simply wanted to get out of this untenable position with respect to Arab independence. At one point, he told Gilbert Clayton, the Arab Bureau chief:
“I've decided to go off alone to Damascus, hoping to get killed on the way: for all sakes try and clear this show up before it goes further. We are calling them to fight for us on a lie, and I can't stand it.”
He begged Allenby, the commander of the British campaign, to relieve him of his command and reassign him to the Royal Air Force as a low-ranking soldier under a new name. He wanted to get away from the legend of his fame that had been spread largely by American correspondent Lowell Thomas. He wanted anonymity. Based on his reputation and Allenby’s respect and understanding of Lawrence’s temperament, he was able to get a command in which he could serve for as long as he pleased and opt to get out of the service when he wished. He resisted following orders and his identity and fame blew his cover. He served both in the Royal Tank Corps as well as returning to the Royal Air Force before retiring in March of 1935. Two months later, he was killed in a motorcycle crash.
‘Hero’ is the first biography that I have read of Lawrence so I can’t really judge it in relation to others that have been written. What I gather is that Korda assimilates information that has already been presented in previous biographies, evaluating other analyses of Lawrence’s motivation and character and presenting the story in a very well-written, evenhanded account. The most engaging portion is the story of the Arab Revolt of 1917-18. After the Paris peace treaties that concluded World War I, Lawrence’s life perhaps became less overtly dramatic. While this portion of the book is interesting and filled in several blanks, such as how Lawrence became friendly with a wide range of prominent figures including Winston Churchill, Thomas Hardy, George Bernard Shaw, and Noel Coward, it is not quite as engaging as the most dramatic years of his life.
Korda also delineates the posthumous fame that has been rekindled regularly over the decades since his death, including the account of attempts by his uncle, famed director Alexander Korda, to make a film of Lawrence’s life, originally proposed while Lawrence was still living. First because of a pledge not to make a film until after Lawrence’s death, then through geopolitical tensions that could still be stirred by such a cinematic account, the rights were sold and the film wasn’t released until 1962.
Korda expresses unabashed admiration for what Lawrence achieved. He says that it is very difficult to understate the significance of his accomplishments and points out that Lawrence underplayed his own role in major events such as the Arab campaign against the Turks. Lawrence is the most famous hero from World War I that is still known by almost everyone, even those without detailed understanding of what he did. He was one of the first media celebrities. Korda compares Lawrence’s fame to what Princess Diana later experienced. He also played a pivotal role in the diplomatic establishment of Middle Eastern borders that perpetuated the border disputes that continue into the present day. Korda repeatedly illustrates Lowell Thomas’s famous quotation that he “had a genius for backing into the limelight.” It is largely due to Thomas’s efforts that over eighty years after his death, Lawrence still resides there.