Jump to ratings and reviews
Rate this book

Ways of Lying: Dissimulation, Persecution and Conformity in Early Modern Europe

Rate this book
The religious persecution and intellectual intolerance of the sixteenth and seventeenth centuries compelled many heterodox groups and thinkers to resort to misdirection, hidden meaning, secrecy, and deceit. In this highly unusual interpretation, Perez Zagorin traces the theory and practice of religious leaders, philosophers, intellectuals, and men of letters who used deception to cloak dissident beliefs.

Zagorin surveys some of the chief sources of early modern doctrines of dissimulation in the Bible and the works of theologians from Jerome andAugustine to Erasmus, Luther, and Calvin. Subjects covered include Nicodemism, the name given by Calvin to secret Protestants who concealed their faith behind a facade of conformity to Catholic worship; crypto-Judaism in Spain; and the hidden beliefs of English Catholics. Other topics include the Catholic doctrine of mental reservation; the place of dissimulation in English Protestant casuistry; occultism; and dissimulation of religious unbelief among philosophers and men of letters. In charting the widespread phenomenon of lying and deceit and by exploring its evolutions, Perez Zagorin has made an important contribution to the historiography of an intellectually roiling and perilous time. He adds a vital dimension to our understanding of the religious, intellectual, and cultural history of the epoch before the modern. Lacey Baldwin Smith finds this hook “an impressive and scholarly work of cultural synthesis that coins a fresh label for the sixteenth and seventeenth the age of dissimulation. Zagorin’s efforts to compare and contrast Catholic and Protestant styles of dissimulation and Nicodemism are important, casting a new perspective and focus on the religious and intellectual dissent of the era.”

337 pages, Hardcover

First published September 25, 1990

Loading...
Loading...

About the author

Perez Zagorin

25 books7 followers
Perez Zagorin was an American historian who specialized in 16th- and 17th-century English and British history and political thought, early modern European history, and related areas in literature and philosophy. From 1965 to 1990, he taught at the University of Rochester, New York, retiring as the Joseph C. Wilson Professor of History Emeritus.

Ratings & Reviews

What do you think?
Rate this book

Friends & Following

Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!

Community Reviews

5 stars
1 (14%)
4 stars
3 (42%)
3 stars
2 (28%)
2 stars
1 (14%)
1 star
0 (0%)
Displaying 1 - 1 of 1 review
240 reviews
July 17, 2022
Humans have been lying since as long as there was speech, but in the early modern period, lying and dissimulating about one's identity became a significant feature of western life.

As Perez Zagorin traces the concept, Renaissance notions of the courtier and "courtesy" established the beginning of the notion that it's polite to lie in order to honor authorities and peers. Taken further, in the era of Reformation and religious wars, many Europeans maintained faiths clandestinely while openly professing other ones. This began with marranos and other sorts of Jewish conversos in Inquisition lands, and especially took form with Protestants who lived in Catholic lands and dissimulated aspects of their Protestant identities to not run afoul of the law. Catholics did the same in Protestant places. Oaths and vows were particular points of issue. Moving into the eighteenth century, rationalists and atheists resided in intellectual closets as well.

Zagorin's book makes useful points, but the writing focuses on materials that I find esoteric. It focuses on doctrines and many Christian legal texts, with much concerns about the casuistry and arguments about dissimulation, and less focus on the lived experiences of people living identity lies.

The book is published in 1990, and therefore does not draw connections between its notions of "lying" and "dissimulating" with more contemporary terminologies like "the closet" as it is often used today to refer to people who dissimulate about sexual orientation, or even religious or political views. Even though some of these topics were not mainstream or well-known in 1990 for Zagorin to bring in for comparison, the work is nonetheless wanting in more analysis and contextualization of what all the body chapters' detailed content really tells us about the meaning of truth and honesty in identity in the age of modernity.

Why is this topic important? I suspect that it is...but Zagorin doesn't make a clear enough case.
Displaying 1 - 1 of 1 review