A satisfactory comprehensive history of the social and economic development of pre-modern China, the largest country in the world in terms of population, and with a documentary record covering three millennia, is still far from possible. The present work is only an attempt to disengage the major themes that seem to be of relevance to our understanding of China today. In particular, this volume studies three questions. Why did the Chinese Empire stay together when the Roman Empire, and every other empire of antiquity of the middle ages, ultimately collapsed? What were the causes of the medieval revolution which made the Chinese economy after about 1100 the most advanced in the world? And why did China after about 1350 fail to maintain her earlier pace of technological advance while still, in many respects, advancing economically? The three sections of the book deal with these problems in turn but the division of a subject matter is to some extent only one of convenience. These topics are so interrelated that, in the last analysis, none of them can be considered in isolation from the others.
Still the best overarching narrative of Chinese history. Elvin takes technology seriously, is perhaps a bit simplistic in his understanding of changing social trends post Song (from the present perspective). The high-level equilibrium trap is still a somewhat persuasive analytical framework.
This book took me a while to read, but it was very good. I bought it after reading Mark Elvin's obituary and some drafts in "New Left Review," mostly because I was very interested in what he had to say about the high-level equilibrium trap. Unfortunately for me, that part came at the very end. Still though, the rest of the book was pretty interesting, even if I couldn't get myself to focus as much as I would have liked. The primary sources in here were often fascinating, and Elvin's ability to analyze China across various fields makes for dense but manageable reading.
This book is a classic of Chinese economic history and the work that other China or Great Divergence historians respond to in the future. The book isn't long but it covers a lot of ground.
The first part explains why the Chinese empire never permanently fragmented like the Roman Empire did. It starts with a general framework about how big pre-modern empires could be. There are 2 counteracting forces: empires expand because they have an overall advantage over their neighbors and they fragment when the administrative burden of administering the empire becomes too large. Elvin then applies this theory to the Chinese dynasties up until the Qing and explains what advantage they had that caused them to expand and what constraint they hit that caused them to fragment. This cycle broke down with the Ming and Qing where the advances and investment of the previous centuries allowed them to administer large empires cheaply and led to 700 years of unified rule.
The second part talks about the economic and technological revolution during Northern and Southern Sung times and how that led to China in that time frame being the most prosperous, technologically advanced society on earth. This part is deeply researched drawing from primary sources (regional gazettes, memorials, first hand accounts, poems) to an impressive degree.
The final part talks about how the economy continued to grow from the Yuan on but how unlike in the Sung this wasn't accompanied by technological advances at the same rate which allowed Europe to surpass China. This section is similar to part 2 in drawing heavily from primary sources to describe the structure of the Chinese economy. It's only in the last chapter where Elvin posits on why this happened. His argument is that China entered a high equilibrium trap where their given their current technology, their agriculture and industry couldn't grow any further without modern science and China couldn't get modern science and industrialization because they lacked inputs and their labor costs were too low to make the investments into machinery worth it.
This book is over 50 years old and not all of it is academic consensus anymore. Pomeranz and the California School have successfully argued the most dynamic parts of China were on par with the most dynamic parts of Europe until 1700, not the 1400 Elvin states, but the high equilibrium trap theory is still considered correct. All in all a great book that still holds up to this day. I wish more historians would write readable books based on deeply researched primary text for a lay audience!
Why is it that medieval China of the Song era showed many signs of industrial revolution and declined in later eras without reaching the explosive growth known from Britain of 19th century? For such a short book, Elvin makes an erudite and persuasive argument regarding his resolution of this riddle, which even after 50 years must be taken seriously. But, it cannot be your first encounter with Chinese history. Basic familiarity with this enormous subject is a prerequisite. One must also approach the topic with the understanding that it may not allow of a simple answer.
I haven't re-read this in many years, but it was certainly a highly influential text when I encountered it in university and helped to shape my understanding of the flow of Chinese history.
The stagnation theory of Chinese history is an interesting one. But in light of China's tremendous changes in the last 30 years, the stagnation theory of China is probably not in fashion.