Review of a diabetic character by a type 1 diabetic reader.
The T1D rep isn’t bad, but it does fall into the common “sick lit” tropes: Melanie…
•hides her diabetes
•loses her insulin in the mountains
•is forced to reveal her diabetes against her will and is then demeaned for keeping her personal medical information private instead of addressing her well-founded fears of WHY she hides it from people
•and winds up in the hospital.
I hate all of these chronic illness tropes for several reasons, which I’ll get into at a later point. Possibly.
Aside from personal pet peeves, the diabetes rep really isn’t bad. It is outdated, even considering the book’s ten years old. I’ve had diabetes since I was seven, just like Melanie: I know! (That’s been a lot longer than ten years, btw.)
I’m not sure when exactly the book is supposed to take place, but there’s phones and computers and other modern technology, just in a rural setting, so I assumed it was supposed to be modern day. In which case the diabetes treatment is *very* outdated.
Melanie’s on injections, which is still very much a thing so I’m not complaining about that, but she doesn’t seem to give nearly enough of them. She also checks her blood glucose very rarely (I think twice a day? And sometimes at meals?), and this is treated as taking exceptional care of herself. She certainly thinks about t1d a lot, but her thoughts don’t necessarily translate into actions.
There’s no mentions whatsoever of pumps, CGM, or really anything beyond the bare bones of her diabetes treatment. I understand the focus of this novel is the romance, but the lack of further details is extremely noticeable, especially given Melanie’s family is rich (and can thus afford everything without thinking about it, and oh how nice that must be) and also very controlling.
Controlling to the point of abuse, by the way. Melanie even calls it that.
Also, for as controlling and obsessive about her t1d as her parents are, where was her endo? I would think Melanie’s first attempt to deal with her dad would be to get her endocrinologist’s opinion, not a general physician’s, illegal bribes aside.
It’s also an excellent situation for her to know, and possibly resent but hey, other people with t1d. We don’t live in bubbles, especially with diabetes camps around and the invention of the internet. It makes total sense to me for Melanie’s dad to be funding an entire camp and try to use that against her, too.
I really do feel like this just wasn’t for me; if you like the tropes, you’ll likely enjoy the book. Keep in mind the rep isn’t perfect but it is continually present throughout the entire story.