Hmmm this book was hard to review, for several reasons. First, just so you know who this review is coming from, here’s a quick bio: I’ve been a guitarist for the last 20 years or so, and have been getting more into the production/mixing side of things the last ten years. So, I’m no stranger to the subject. I have three other books similar to this, which I’ll be comparing this to.
Ok, one of the difficulties in reviewing this book is based on the title. I’ve learned, after buying many books with similar titles, that it is usually a marketing gimic. However, it’s also subjective. If you’re brand new to the mixing side of things, then indeed this whole book could contain hundreds of secrets. But if you’re already fairly versed, not so much.
My other issue with the title is that the implication is that his target audience is people with not as much experience, who might not know some of the info he is assuming we know. So, he skips over a lot of things I feel could’ve been addressed. When he starts talking about things like phase response, comb filtering, etc. with the assumption we already know about that, he’ll lose a lot of people right there.
So, I decided to review the book based primarily on his “mission statement” if you will, in the introduction. He says this book will teach you to create “release quality mixes” on a budget. In that respect, the book definitely falls short. So, here we go:
First off, he proudly states in the beginning that this book is based on his research into the studios of over a 100 engineers. Yet, we only get occasional quotes from one or two of them on any given topic. As a huge fan of older Bryan Adams records, I’d kill to know, for example how R.J. Lange or Bob Clearmountain approach a mix. How do they handle guitars? Vocals? None of that is in here. If you’re looking for more meaty info specifically on how different producers handle these subjects, the book “The Mixing Engineers Handbook” has huge amounts of that. Full interviews with engineers/producers on these subjects.
Secondly, although he states the book is a “step by step primer” some information is so conspicuously absent, I was shocked. For example, when I get a book like this, I almost always go straight to the chapters on EQ and compression, since those are arguably THE most important things, and the things that will trip most people up. Although there definitely is some very good info on those subjects in this book, he gives you absolutely NO idea how to apply those effects to any individual instrument. None. There is a short section on “Compressing Lead Vocals” but I think that was it. So, how are we supposed to get a release quality mix done, if we don’t even know where to start with the two most important effects? What frequencies are we concerned with, as far as the kick drum? Electric guitars? We are left completely floundering in that respect. Here, “The Mixing Engineers Handbook” shines again. It has detailed frequency information on individual instruments, for things like “fullness” “attack” “presence” etc.
What if we just want to know how the pro’s might set up a lead vocal? Or how we might treat electric guitars in the mix? Again, really none of that, that I recall. The previously mentioned book, as well as “Mix Smart” and “Using Your Portable Studio” all have that kind of info in them.
The chapter on compression was quite good in a lot of ways. He really explains all the different controls and parameters of compression, but then gives you no real idea how to use it on individual instruments, aside from generalities.
He mentions some specific plugins, both free and paid, which is always welcome. There is a lot of good info in this book, but was completely taken aback by the overwhelmingly high reviews it got. Some people even said this is the only book you’d ever need on the subject. COMPLETELY disagree. As far as my other books, “Mix Smart” is one of the best and most comprehensive I’ve ever seen. I’m constantly going back and referencing it. It has it’s faults, too, like not having any audio material as examples. The Mixing Engineers Handbook is also quite good, but has it’s faults, too. But if I were to get only one book, it would be one of those others.
Lastly, this book has a companion website with audio material, which I’ll be checking out soon, so that could really add a lot of value to the book, in which case I’ll happily amend my review. Also, the chapter on reverb was one of the highlights of the book. He really covers the different uses of that effect, and the five different aspects of it you’ll looking at with the effect. However, there is an apparent contradiction on the subject of “pre-delay.” I’ve read it several times, and maybe I’m missing something, but he seems to say one thing, contradict himself, then contradict himself again? He says the less pre-delay you use, the more it will push the sound away from the listener. Then he says to add 10 to 20 ms of pre-delay to start, “aiming on the shorter side for a more intimate sounding space, and on the longer side for a more spacious virtual acoustic...” then turns around and says you can always add a second reverb with more pre-delay to further distance the sound from the listener? Maybe it’s just me, but I’m confused.
At any rate. I hope this review helps. I will say the reviews that give this only one or two stars are flatly unfair. I’d give this 3.5 stars.