I have to say, I really enjoyed the spin that Jenkins put on the old myth of the sirens in this book. It starts out kind of slow, but once it picks up pace, you're on the edge of your seat, wondering what's going to happen next. I really had fun with this book, and it's a great summer read.
The idea of Sirens guiding the sea-drowned dead is something I hadn't even considered (and I think a lot on mythology, especially recently), and Jenkins completely surprised me with this idea of having to make up for their sin of luring men to their deaths with their voices, and the guilt that they carried around because of it. I loved this, and it drew me in immediately.
I also liked the new origin myth about the Sirens (at least, I think it's new, because not only can I not remember there being anything related to Persephone, but I can't find it on wikipedia or other somewhat scholarly sources saying so) - it gave even more gravity to the guilt of the Sirens, and their new mission to guide the dead.
The only things that I'm not sure were needed was the romance element - if anything, the romance between Wyatt and Charlotte felt more than a little forced, and I think that the novel would have done fine without it. Had she just had her own family to look after/save from the hunter, I think it would have been just fine. Hence, one less star. But I do like the way that Jenkins handled the romance, since it was there - after the relationship started, it did start to feel more natural and slowed down a bit, and I felt a bit more at ease in that world.
Jenkins is definitely talented in the sensory language arena - whenever Charlotte was underwater, I felt as if I were underwater too. It was as if I were right by her side, and that's difficult to really properly do in any novel, much less a YA paranormal novel. So I applaud her on that one, and I really look forward to more of it in book 2, which is supposed to be out sometime soon.
Bottom line? I love me some mermaid/siren myths, and this one is a wonderful new addition to the YA canon. So if you want a new spin on an old tale, I urge you to try out "Lure". You won't be disappointed.
(posted to librarything, goodreads, shelfari, and witchoftheatregoing.wordpress.com)