I have to be honest with this review. I am struggling with the number of stars to assign. I first wanted to give 2 stars, but to be fair, I settled on 3 because of the quality of writing and the merits of what is contained in this book, but honestly, 3 is a stretch for me. I had some issues with this book, which I'll attempt to explain, and give more details on why I didn't give a higher rating below.
One thing which concerned me, was that there is very little scripture contained in this book. Most devotionals I've read, will list a scripture for every page. In my honest opinion, I think there's very little scripture in it, because there's not many to back up some of the statements/opinions the author makes here. There seem to be several half-truths in this devotional also; 'gray' areas if you will.
To be fair and give the author some credit, "The Nature of God: 50 Christian Devotions about God's Love and Acceptance", is a very sweet undertaking, with daily devotions which are short enough that they can be conveniently read in a few minutes. The author, Mona Hanna gives the view of a loving, patient God who waits for us with open arms.
For someone who is depressed, discouraged or needs to be uplifted, this would be a good book, but only temporarily. Why do I say that? Let me try to explain.
This is taken from the back cover of the book, the 2nd paragraph:
"These devotions break down the notion that God judges us, and has strict requirements for how we should think, feel and behave. Mona’s stance is that God loves us like a parent loves their child, with the same intimacy and compassion that a loving parent would have. Immerse yourself in heart-warming declarations of God’s love, and remind yourself of the true nature of God."
This book seemed awfully one-sided and out of balance to me, and biblically my heart grieved in parts. Yes! I believe God treats His children as a loving parent does. However, even the most loving parent sets boundaries, disciplines their child, judges their child's actions, and works towards teaching their child personal responsibility.
(I had a hard time seeing any of that displayed in this devotional; if anything, I saw the complete opposite).
I don't believe this is intentional on Ms. Hanna's part; I believe her 'spiritual menu' written here to be off though. For example, if a loving parent continually feeds their child a diet of food that consists of only the food the child loves, such as cookies, candy, ice cream, cake, etc., the child will grow to have only a singular view of what a proper diet is. This is where my concern lies.
Allow me to share a sampling of excerpts from the book in the author's own words to give you a taste. (It's possible I misunderstood, however I went through this book twice trying to be fair). The brackets are my comments.
Excerpts:
pg 6: "He (God) isn't trying to teach me certain lessons because I should go through them, and he's demanding them. He just wants me to be happy."
[Jesus taught us. He taught us lessons through parables. A loving parent teaches their child certain lessons.]
pg 56: "...We truly need to do very little in our relationship with God. We need to stay with him, and try; but Jesus does almost everything.... It's not entirely up to us to heal our relationship with God. Jesus will do that.
...Jesus doesn't hold us accountable, the way we hold ourselves accountable. His love is pure, and real, and strong. He doesn't blame us..."
[God, nor Jesus, can condone or ignore sin. Yes, we are still accepted and loved by God when we sin, but there must be repentance by us. We must be accountable for our sins, in order to confess them to God.]
pg 60; 61: "As Christians, we're often told we need to be separate from everyone else....
...We don't need to be separate from the world. We just need to be."
[The bible tells us to be separate from the world. 2 Corinthians 6:17].
pg 62; 63: "God told me it wasn't my fault - my guilt, my isolation, the other ways I turned out. He said I've done what I could with what I had...
[The phrases, "its not my fault. I've done what I could with what I had", is repeated at least 3 more times in the last devotional].
"...God looks at me and says: however I'm coping, however I'm feeling, however I'm doing, it's okay. ...Right now I'm doing what I can.... I'm doing what I can, because however I'm doing is okay. I'm okay, no matter how I'm doing, because I'm okay as I am....
...We're doing what we can. God doesn't ask any more of us. He loves us, as we are..."
Let me reiterate; I don't think Ms. Hanna intentionally meant to write blended truths (or the 'gray' areas); I believe she has been so touched, blessed, excited and overjoyed with her revelation of God's love and comfort that she wants to share it with all. However, in our excitement sometimes, we can add our own flesh and thoughts to God's word instead of letting the bible speak for itself.
However, I can't in good conscience recommend this book, unless it's to more spiritually mature Christians who have studied the bible and are grounded in their faith. To be honest, these are "whipped topping" devotions; no substance or "meat". I don't mean to speak for all Christians, however, I don't think more learned/mature Christians will find much here.
* Disclosure of Material Connection: I received this book free through Goodreads. (Thank you Mona Hanna for the opportunity to read this book). I was not required to write a positive review. The opinions I have expressed are my own. I am disclosing this in accordance with the Federal Trade Commission’s 16 CFR, Part 255: “Guides Concerning the Use of Endorsements and Testimonials in Advertising.” *