5+ stars (6/10 hearts). This story was even more exiting than book 1! I didn’t love it quite as much as Une bouteille à la mer because of how intense it was, but I think upon reread I’ll enjoy it more.
I was thrilled that Uncle Calvin, Laura, and Tariq were perfectly themselves and still had excellent relationships. As for the new characters—no one could love Rita & Bob but Jimmy grew on you despite everything, poor kid; and I liked the Canadian fellow (!!!) and the former Special Ops. And the new villains were much worse than the first ones—downright terrifying.
The plot, as I mentioned, was a lot more fast-paced than book 1. Of course I enjoyed the cruise part a lot (I have ALWAYS wanted a cruise). I was not quite such a fan of the fugitive portion of the book… it’s scary and I hate all the lies and half-truths the kids have to recourse to… plus it feels a teeny bit unrealistic. However, it was certainly gripping, the kids did have good reasons for what they did, and they did own up quickly and honestly when they could. Also, I liked how everything fit together and the marine preservation was worked in, also the deep themes of courage and friendship and self-confidence.
I had to read this very fast to return it to the library, plus I found it rather heavy on the emotions/exhausting the first time I read it, so expect a better review upon reread.
// 2025 REREAD //
As I predicted, I enjoyed more than the first time around because I wasn't so anxious!