The Caribbean “market woman” is ingrained in the popular imagination as the archetype of black womanhood in countries throughout the region. Challenging this stereotype and other outdated images of black women, Downtown Ladies offers a more complex picture by documenting the history of independent international traders—known as informal commercial importers, or ICIs—who travel abroad to import and export a vast array of consumer goods sold in the public markets of Kingston, Jamaica.
Both by-products of and participants in globalization, ICIs operate on multiple levels and, since their emergence in the 1970s, have made significant contributions to the regional, national, and global economies. Gina Ulysse carefully explores how ICIs, determined to be self-employed, struggle with government regulation and other social tensions to negotiate their autonomy. Informing this story of self-fashioning with reflections on her own experience as a young Haitian anthropologist, Ulysse combines the study of political economy with the study of individual and collective identity to reveal the uneven consequences of disrupting traditional class, color, and gender codes in individual societies and around the world.
Downtown Ladies takes the reader into the realm of Informal Commercial Importers (ICIs) in Kingston, Jamaica as they maneuver through various gender, class, and color expectations as well as increasingly complex, political state regulations. The author accomplishes this task while maintaining a strong auto-ethnographical dialogue, allowing the reader to read between the lines. The book is separated into chapters and sections and includes drawn maps, outlines, and profiles of her subjects of research. Ulysse starts with a detailed history of gender, class, and color as it impacts ICIs and uses this to lead the reader through some of the daily struggles and interpretive meanings of the primarily black, female commercial importers. Her auto-ethnographical approach allows her to further elaborate on these issues and to explore them more personally. The book is ordered by topic, but holds some chronological sequencing. Downtown Ladies largely deals with lower class (initially), visible ICIs. Through her daily interactions with these women, she discovers the various social codes by which they live. In the process, she finds herself feeling quite a bit of angst and even discovers toughness within herself. This kind of integration that the author has with the community gives the reader a unique perspective. Although Faye Harrison contributed to the understanding of the area, Gina Ulysse has added much more to the topic through her different color position. Harrison stated in Anthropology as Liberation that her work “necessitated a continual negotiation of role expectations based on [her] light pigmentation.” Since color determines social standing in the region, it is important that the author was of darker skin. For example, the author would have never known how the public treats a black woman, as opposed to a brown woman, on the streets of downtown had she not blended in to the point of confusion. She also would not have been able to incorporate her unique experience in the arcade, her encounter with “tuffness,” or her thick description on her trip to Miami as one of a “native” perspective. I put native in parenthesis because Ulysse refutes some of the assumptions behind this idea in the book. One criticism I have is that the author does not engage invisible ICIs enough in order to get their full perspective. It would have been helpful to have analyzed more fully the similarities and differences in treatment that the visible and invisible ICIs receive through customs as it was left ambiguous whether there really is a difference when it comes to identifying them (beyond the difference in luggage and which line to stand in). One could point out that the author herself discovered that she could not tell the difference when a visible ICI cross dressed across class in order to appear as though she was a traveling middle class woman. It would have been interesting also if the author dug further and asked the customs officials what they looked for when identifying invisible ICIs so as to expose the profiling that goes on in the airport. Another criticism is the author’s exclusion of the CIA’s involvement in the transfer of power away from the PNP socialist movement. This is mentioned in Harrison’s Ethnography as Politics. The topic would have been an interesting contribution to the book if she were to have tied it to ICIs’ general distrust of researchers, assuming the general public knows about what happened. On the positive side, the book was very well organized and easy to read. It covers an array of social issues without difficulty and will leave readers with a sense of understanding and critical thought. The afterward or “brawta,” as the author calls it, includes an update on the ICIs that were mentioned throughout the book. This adds a sense of closure, but concurrently brings up some questions for the reader to ponder over their future. With all the work that was done in anthropology concerning Jamaica in the 1970’s becoming out of date, this book is a refreshing addition to the field and to anyone interested in the ongoing struggles of those living in the confines of gender, color, and class codes in Jamaica.
The premise of this book rests on an excellent ethnographic study Ulysse conducted in Jamaica for her postgraduate degree. I literally happened across this book as I sought to find out more information on the politics of identity in Jamaica for my research on the subject matter.
That being said, in this book, Ulysse captures so well the experiences or lived realities of this particular "class" of women in Jamaica who seek to sustain themselves and their families through their "informal" commercial activities. What stood out for me was the way Ulysse was able to flesh out, for her readers, the nature of the identity politics that characterize Jamaican society - particularly as it relates to race, gender and class.
Kudos for making me feel as though I was with you in the field, Ulysse.