Well, this one was pretty good! The twist at the end was actually great. So if you go and read my review of the Fear Street book New Year's Party (Super Chiller), you will see it's similar to this one. It takes place in two time periods, and this one does too. Beach House takes place in 1956 and "this summer," which meant 1990-whatever back then. It's hilarious how dated the references are. Matt Dillon, MTV, Vanilla Ice, Coke towel... the list goes on. I love the 90s, though, so I'm not complaining.
Okay, so, I know you only came here for the deaths, so I won't delay!
Let me see if I can remember all the characters in both time periods. Well, the relevant ones. In 1956 we have Maria, Amy, Buddy, Stuart... I think that's it. In the 90s we have Ashley, Brad, Ross, Kip, and Lucy. You can see some parallels in the names. The killer in 1956 is not a mystery. We find out right away that it's Buddy, because he LOVES killing, and he tells the reader that. "It's so easy," he says. What happens is Buddy gets caught in the ocean one day, and Stuart and a friend (don't remember his name) steal his swim trunks. Maria and Amy laugh at him. Buddy takes his anger at this to the extreme. He decides his "friends" need to PAY.
First is Maria. Buddy lures her out in the water in the middle of the night. He's a strong swimmer, but she isn't. He swims with her very far out, and then he takes a knife and cuts her to lure the sharks that are nearby. Buddy swims back and leaves her for the sharks. A few days later Amy finds Stuart dead on the beach with his head bashed in from a tree trunk (how Buddy managed that one on his own, we may never know). Finally, there's Amy. She almost makes it... but Buddy traps her in the Beach House one day. There is a secret to it that Amy never gets to find out. What she does find out is that she's about to drown soon, because Buddy hits her over the head with a shovel and ties her under the Beach House to drown (it's raised on stilts, so the ocean's tide comes up under the house).
Back in the 90s, there isn't a killer... yet. But there is a mysterious, handsome guy named Brad. He has a thing for Ashley, which is a problem for Ross, her current boyfriend. They are all out in Dunehampton (where the book is set) for the summer. They discover the beach house one day as Ross and Ashley use it to make out. Turns out Kip and Lucy have the same idea. But one day Kip and Lucy go missing. Ashley finds her scarf in the closet of the beach house and is thoroughly freaked. Meanwhile, Brad hosts a soiree in his incredible mansion and Ross grows more and more jealous of the time Brad is spending with her. Ashley, as an independent 90s woman, is having none of it. She breaks up with Ross - for good, she says. She and Brad continue to go out while Ross spies on them from afar. Then one night Brad wants to show her a "secret" in the beach house. But first, on the steps of the beach house, he launches into a speech about his family history and why he is so rich. He talks about his brother, Johnny, and how he always loved to explore houses. Brad wanted to be just like Johnny, so he went exploring too. And he explored the Beach House. He wants to show it to Ashley. She's a little perplexed, because she's already been there, but Brad leads her inside into the closet of a bedroom. Well, he forces her in, because she protests the whole way. As soon as they are in the closet a mysterious orange and yellow light flashes in front of Ashley's face. It turns out it's Mary, the maid of Brad's family. But something's wrong, because Mary is calling Brad Buddy. This part wasn't surprising since I had read New Year's Party recently. Ashley demands an explanation, and the truth comes out. Mary is - no shocker - Maria from 1956.
Honestly, the most shocking thing is how she survived that shark attack. She tells Ashley that Brad is really named Buddy and in 1956 he killed (or thought he killed) her and her friends one by one. Apparently Maria was rescued by some fishermen, but her skin took years to heal. She pulls off her maid uniform to reveal the ugly purple and yellow scars on her chest. (Stine mentions her BRA- scandalous!). Then the twist comes - the secret of the Beach House is that a time travel tunnel exists in the closet they are standing in!! That's how Buddy literally got away with murder. He traveled to the 90s and became rich Brad. Maria finally figured out his secret one day, and she, too, came to the 90s to seek her revenge. This time she refuses to let Brad leave the closet. She wants him to go back to 1956 and face up to what he's done. Obviously there's no way Brad/Buddy is going to do that, but luckily Maria came prepared this time. She has doused the house in gasoline, and she is carrying a torch (very convenient). She lights Buddy on fire and then lights the house on fire, right at the time Ashley realizes she may die too. Luckily, the beach house explosion just sends her flying onto the deck but otherwise unharmed. Of course creeper Ross is there waiting for her.
Methinks Ross and Ashley still need to work out his stage-five clinger issues. And now Ashley has a burning hatred for oldies music. But otherwise, all's well that ends well! (Unless you are Buddy, Maria, Kip, Lucy, Amy, or Stuart).