After watching History's series Unidentified, I thought it might be a good idea to go back and reread the final volume of Jacques Vallee's "Alien Contact Trilogy," Revelations.
I was initially impressed by Unidentified, but less so as I realized the producers had about enough material for a two hour documentary and padded like mad by reshowing the so-called "go fast" and "gimble" videos that had been released by the military a few years ago (Navy gun camera film that reputedly showed UFOs that were shadowing our carrier task forces) over and over and over, diving back into the Rendlesham Forest case (mysterious but done to death), and running endless scenes of Luis Elizondo for some reason shot in a mirror (why?!). Initially impressive, a lot of it was a mess.
And most interesting is the presence of Chris Mellon in the middle of this. Mellon, after all, a very calm, level headed, well-educated man, is also a professional spook, a former Deputy Assistant Secretary of Defense for Intelligence, among other positions. What made his presence even more interesting are the pervasive rumors that Luis Elizondo is not what he claimed to be - the former head of a very shadowy Pentagon program called AATIP (Advanced Aerospace Threat Identification Program). Whoever Elizondo is, and he seems to have been a special ops operator of some kind, Mellon was clearly in a position to blow his cover and did not.
That's a lot of typing to say, I suspect that what we have here is a government attempt to, once again, influence the discussion on UFOs and possibly at the same time boost defense spending. It's been done before, as Vallee argued in 1991 in this book.
Revelations is good reading, and useful because a lot of the material Vallee discusses in detail here - the UMMO case, the Majestic 12 documents, the shrieking about underground bases full of aliens and vats of human body parts (!), the odd case of Kirk Allen, Carlos Allende and his "revelations," etc., are largely forgotten or have never been heard of by younger people following the UFO question today. Vallee himself is not a believer in the extraterrestrial hypothesis; he believes UFOs are largely some kind of interdimensional phenomena. He has a wonderful talent for defusing true believers (one of the funniest scenes in the book is where Vallee dryly asks a True Believer in the "underground alien bases" theory, "Who takes out the trash?"), and as a scientist and computer expert his view is detached: he didn't have to make a living on UFOs, he had the ability to most of the time make it a hobby. In Revelations, Vallee argues that a lot of "mysterious" cases may have been entirely the creation of intelligence agencies, or the interpretation and reception of them may have been nudged by same to push serious researchers either out of the field in disgust or towards truly insane speculations that basically discredited the entire field.
There's a lot to digest here. The book is a little disorganized but it's packed with interest. Almost 30 years ago, Dr Vallee wrote "The time has come to restore some sanity to this field of research. It may prove to be a difficult task." It didn't happen then, and how hard it will be, in a time of steeply deepening public irrationality, to do it now. There is a genuine UFO mystery of some kind. But right now I suspect we're being force-fed another pile of crap and a historical look back might prove very useful.