This became of book of two halves: whilst I relished in the claustrophobic, “locked room” murder mystery, I was also frustrated by how far-fetched the story turned. By the end of the novel I had lost interest and felt the revelations were a bit of an anti-climax.
The novel moves equally between the friends’ weekend on the boat, to ten years previous. In this past timeframe, we watch Pete and Harry meet the other people in their group, their university days and how a secret in their past appears to be haunting them on the yacht. Initially I struggled to keep track of the identities of the group; I was grateful for the flashbacks because they helped to establish the different characters.
One by one, it would appear that the friends are being targeted, haunted by an enemy from their past. As the university narrative develops, I enjoyed watching how Pete and his friends are driven to extreme actions. Yet, the most enjoyable element of this timeline was the depiction of university life, prompting me to reminisce on my own experiences. I think Hunter really captures this student living and the temptation of a social life versus studying.
I grew to dislike Sophie’s character and all that she represented. This was where I thought the story started to become unrealistic. How she treats the rest of the group and how she manages her landlord felt rather wrong and I disliked how accepting everyone was. Furthermore, the tenancy agreement that Pete and their friends blindly sign was irritating, especially as Pete is studying law. Their collective naivety and treatment of Sophie was annoyingly dismissive and I disliked how Sophie was presented as the tool to ensure everyone’s protection. Even though Hunter gives more of a backstory to help us understand Sophie’s past, I really was unimpressed with her actions and what she comes to represent. She seems more of a leader of the group and her influence is to just suit her all the time. Her selfishness is reflected in those around her.
By the end of the novel, I was a bit bored by how the story was unfolding and thought the mystery was slowing down in pace. I did not get a sense of danger and tension because of how ill-formed the characters were behaving: not like they had ten years on their university selves, but like they were still fresh from leaving home. The quickness to hide the truth is something that always grates on me with stories and this became no different.
I liked how the story opened with a mystery and a secret, enjoying discovering the truth about what really happened a decade previously. However, I believe this mystery and suspense was lost as I grew irritated by the naivety of the characters.
With thanks to Boldwood books and NetGalley for providing me with a copy of this book in exchange for an honest review.