Jump to ratings and reviews
Rate this book

Not So Normative #1

An Epic Construct

Rate this book
This is an adult LGBTQ+ Romance novel.

Is a LGBTQ+ friendly dating app the answer to all of Penelope's dating woes? Her ex-girlfriend turned asexual best friend and roommate sure thinks so. Within a few minutes of swiping, Penelope matches with the mysterious, yet charming Riley, who identifies as queer, but is slow to open up about his sexuality... and everything else.

As Penelope explores dating again, she gets the opportunity to MC a drag brunch, in full drag king regalia. For a long time, Penelope has suspected she might be nonbinary, but that feels like something she'll sort out on her own eventually... right?

The drag brunch is a smashing success, and she meets a beautiful woman in the audience named Taylor. Penelope falls for her hard, and Taylor supports Penelope as she finally begins to explore her gender identity.

Penelope begins to notice similarities between Riley and Taylor, in the way they think, the way they talk, and most importantly in the way they make her feel. What if the two people she's falling for are more than just amazing, what if they're her soul mate?

Follow Penelope's journey as she navigates the ups and downs of dating, self-discovery, and the search for love and acceptance in a hilariously complicated and ultimately satisfying, queer love story.

315 pages, ebook

Published February 25, 2023

Loading...
Loading...

About the author

D.C. Emerson

23 books143 followers
D.C. is an avid board gamer and rock climber who lives on the East Coast of the United States but loves to travel to places near and far as often as they can.

D.C. has always identified as queer, but during the pandemic they came out as nonbinary (they/them pronouns) to family and friends. This book was part of that process, and they have loved exploring different genderqueer identities like their own through their writing, reading, research, and countless hours watching reels and videos on social media.

Their biggest hope in writing queer fiction is to provide at least one other person out there with characters and story lines that they can recognize themselves, or their friends and loved ones in.

Ratings & Reviews

What do you think?
Rate this book

Friends & Following

Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!

Community Reviews

5 stars
42 (50%)
4 stars
34 (40%)
3 stars
4 (4%)
2 stars
3 (3%)
1 star
0 (0%)
Displaying 1 - 30 of 48 reviews
Profile Image for Jessica Rush.
Author 1 book73 followers
March 12, 2023
⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
🏳️‍🌈🐈‍⬛🐇☕🎤

Honestly, this book is everything for a person struggling with their identity needs to read. Even if you identify as cisgender, then you need to read this book just so you know how those who are non-binary, gender fluid or trans feel about themselves, which will teach you how to treat them with the respect that they deserve.

This book is beautiful. It is informative, had a great storyline, and even though I had a feeling where it was headed, it was written so beautifully that when it came about I still cried. (in a good way)

I loved all the characters and how they just merged into one big queer family. I loved how everyone was supportive, always there for each other and helped each other through depressive states. I loved the connection between Nels and Riley. I loved everything. I can't wait for the next book.

I loved how everyone was queer. Pansexual, Nonbinary, Lesbian, Asexual, Bisexual, Transgender, Gay, Genderfluid and not to mention Drag Queens and Kings! This book had everything and it was truly beautiful.

Just like this cover.

Thanks to Dawn Culter-Tran and NetGalley for a copy of the ebook. This review is left voluntarily.
Profile Image for Nikki.
67 reviews4 followers
April 1, 2023
I can already tell this is going to be one of my favourites for 2023.

An Epic Construct follows Penelope as she navigates a new queer dating app as she tries to find love in her late 20's. What follows this is an incredible journey of friendship, love, sexuality, gender, consent, boundaries, communication, self discovery and acceptance. This book has so much depth but is presented in a way that was light-hearted and funny which made it such an enjoyable read.

The characters in this book have my entire heart, although the book primarily centres around Penelope, Riley and Taylor, there were so many incredible side characters who also had amazing representation and diversity. I find with books I sometimes get overwhelmed when there are so many pointless side characters, but each side character in An Epic Construct had a clear purpose and added so much more depth to the storyline and I could imagine the book without them.

I don't think my review could ever show how much I loved this book but I'll be recommending this book to everyone who will listen. An easy 5 Stars and an incredible debut from Dawn Cutler-Tran.

Thank you so much to The Paper House & NetGalley for providing me with this e-ARC in exchange for a voluntary honest review.

I post about diverse & queer novels @niksreadss on Instagram
Profile Image for Sarah.
485 reviews15 followers
January 1, 2024
4⭐️

First of all, thank you NetGalley and The Paper House for the ARC.

“An Epic Construct” is a queer love story that explores various topics such as self-discovery, finding love and acceptance, and mental health.

I liked the relationship between the characters, both the romantic and the platonic ones.
The characters were fantastic and I adored how much supportive they were with each other.

The author's portrayal of depression and anxiety was also well-done.

I highly suggest this book to everyone and I will definitely read both the sequel and prequel.

Representation :
-pansexual nonbinary MC
-queer gender fluid MC
-asexual romantic lesbian FSC
-bisexual MSC
-bisexual FSC
-trans MSC

TW: anxiety and depression
Profile Image for TeeReads.
624 reviews28 followers
March 5, 2025
5 stars

At this point, I am convinced it's impossible for me not to love what D.C. Emerson writes. I absolutely LOVED this book. D.C. Emerson portrays gender identity in a very real and relatable way. It may look a little different from your own journey, but it still feels like something you have felt. The feelings are there with so much real emotion. I especially enjoyed the conversations around intimacy and how dysphoria can affect how it's approached. The communication and consent were so well done. Penelope and Riley clearly respect each other. Their individual journeys were so interesting and played into their relationship dynamic in a very interesting way. All in all, this was wonderful, and I loved every minute of it. I HIGHLY recommend reading this one!
Profile Image for MeMe.
284 reviews33 followers
April 29, 2023
There was something very appealing about the story's overall premise. Despite Riley's anxiety and other issues, such as depression, Penelope handled everything like a pro. I found the lack of communication to be a little frustrating. Almost all the conversations were tedious and I felt they never accomplished anything. Even when they did talk, something always derailed it and it was dragged out. The waiting time Riley took before telling Penelope was almost too long, as I completely understand his anxiety and depression, so I can see why he was anxious. As much as I enjoyed P's sense of humor, I was also impressed with her awareness of being female. As she explored and discovered herself, I was impressed. Maria was delightful to read about and I thoroughly enjoyed learning about Ace Romance through her. It was a pleasure reading the story about Frankie and Diego getting together as well as Diego's past. It was magnificent learning about gender identities.
Profile Image for Molly.
283 reviews
May 3, 2024
This was a lovely book, 3.5 stars rounded up to 4! I really liked the main relationship, and it’s a portrayal of different gender identities I haven’t read about very often in published media! I admit I was worried when I got to the resolution of the conflict, because grand public gestures give me so much second-hand embarrassment so I was relieved to keep reading and see that it didn’t really end up being public. And it made me tear up! I loved them affirming each other. 🥹 I also will say though that something about the dialogue felt...idk, like an overly explain-y tumblr post? Not how real people talk? I mean I’m sure some people do but it took me out of it at times. Still, I really enjoyed this and I was excited to get to the end and see that there’s gonna be a sequel!

Thanks to NetGalley and The Paper House for the ARC, all opinions are my own.
Profile Image for Gray Aether.
84 reviews3 followers
November 13, 2026
Positives:

I think the concept is fun: A genderfluid character meets a pan / bi character. They fall in love, and either one or both of them don't realize the other is the same person they already know, and chaos ensues. I feel like it could've played with dramatic irony and had a lot of humor. But instead, the book played it as a romantic miscommunication, which was just frustrating.

Some of the LGBT exploration / discussion is good. For example, Penelope has some people try they/them pronouns out for her. She thinks they're okay, but doesn't love them (she likes she/her), but she does like that they/them pronouns make her feel like people are recognizing her as nonbinary. That's really understandable, and lots of trans people can relate to acting in certain ways, wearing certain clothes, or going by specific terms, not necessarily because they love them, but because it helps others recognize what they see in themselves.

Another example is that Penelope tries boxers, but she doesn't like wearing them. She doesn't want to wear boxers because:

"I don’t necessarily want to dress in men’s clothes just because they’re men’s clothes. I’m more interested in how men’s style can play off the femininity I do feel, as well as androgyny"

A lot of books would immediately have the boxers and they/them pronouns give Penelope euphoria, but I'm glad this book explores that it's more complicated than that.


Where this book fails is the writing and plot.

Writing:

When people talk, it sounds robotic, as if AI was trying to convey human emotions:

“Riley?” she called softly, turning her hand to slide it down his arm, so their hands were linked again. His jaw flexed, but he slowly brought his eyes back to meet hers. “I just want to let you know how insanely brave I think what you just did was. I think that was probably the hardest question I asked you, and you answered it perfectly—I mean… not that your answer was perfect, but the fact that you were so honest. That’s really all I can ask of you. Thank you, Riley.”

All she did was ask if he was open to sex sometime in the future if they get into a relationship. Calling someone brave for answering a mundane question and the "and you answered it perfectly" sound exactly how ChatGPT tries to compliment you.

“Oh, I mean… I wouldn’t mind? I mean, so long as you wouldn’t mind…” Riley said, glancing hesitantly down at her.

She blinked up at him for a second. “Fine by me, but remember you can always withdraw consent at any point.”

Literal robot.


There's grammatical errors, such as using the wrong there/they're/their, or accidently inserting "a" where it didn't belong:

Penelope sat their frozen, still clutching a pair of leggings to her chest.

She texted Taylor about both the package and her future access to a Diego’s wardrobe.



The word choice the author uses is repetitive, which becomes annoying. The word "melt" is used fourteen times to describe Penelope loving Taylor Riley. Instead of changing up the description, the author just used the same word over and over.

EVERY character uses the word "darling," as if it's a universal term. It always stands out on the page as odd.

One example:

Very rarely would they both stop texting her at the same time, though, so she felt like she was constantly glued to her phone or thinking about the two people she connected with via her phone.

Why did the author repeat phone twice in a sentence? It's clunky.


Taylor Riley is also just.. really annoying. A.... uh... lot of.... I mean— his dialogue.... is written like, er, this... sorry.. because uh.... he's so... anxious.... uh.... and.... uh.... can't.... JUST SPIT IT THE FUCK OUT


Plot

The plot suffers from repetitiveness, plot contrivances, and telling instead of showing.

Penelope and Taylor Riley go on countless dates, and each time, they're like, "We really need to talk.. Let's do it later." Even at the end of the book where everything is revealed, they make up, and they're absolutely in love, they're both still like, "We need to talk, but let's do it tomorrow..."
It's just fucking annoying.

Penelope and Taylor Riley have the same backstory of being best friends with their exes, and the exes acting as background characters.


The book just makes excuses for the plot to continue. Oreo the cat knocks Taylor Riley's phone off the table, and somehow the only thing it breaks is the ability for the phone to have clear audio during phone calls, and the ability for the phone to receive calls from a dating app. The phone can still take normal calls, but not from the app.

This causes Penelope to be frustrated with Taylor Riley for not answering her calls, but nothing comes of it, aside from a short, stupid, annoying conversation:
"Why aren't you answering my calls?"
"Oh, I didn't know you were calling because the cat messed up my phone. But only very specific audio features."

Taylor conveniently never wants to hang out with Penelope, and both of them only see each other from a distance one time.

Despite texting each other photos of clothes lying on their bed, their cat disappearing behind a door, etc, neither one of them recognizes the other's apartment.

Both characters don't want to tell the other about their gender exploration, despite it not making a lot of sense for them to feel apprehension about it.
The book tells us Taylor Riley has trauma and issues, but we don't really know why Taylor Riley is so afraid of talking to Penelope specifically? Even after having many dates with Penelope, and Penelope fully accepting Taylor Riley being genderfluid, AND Taylor Riley considering MARRYING Penelope, Taylor Riley is still scared to tell Penelope when a gender shift happens. Within the story, there isn't a lot of reasons given for it. It's implied to come from trauma with Taylor Riley's parents, but we don't get to see how that applies to Penelope. The book tells us that things trigger Taylor Riley, but we don't actually see what being triggered looks like.
And it makes even less sense for Penelope not to tell Taylor Riley that she's nonbinary. Penelope does not have the same type of implied trauma that Taylor Riley does, and Penelope is very attached to him.

When it's revealed Taylor Riley is the same person, Taylor Riley is upset at Penelope? Taylor Riley runs away and blocks her number. But I don't really get why they were arguing in the first place? Penelope loves both Taylor and Riley. Penelope accepts Taylor Riley as genderfluid and is fine with working it out. I understand Taylor Riley might need a day or two to process the shock or embarrassment about their identity being revealed suddenly, but Penelope and Taylor Riley don't speak for WEEKS. Penelope sends messages through multiple of Taylor Riley's friends to Taylor Riley that Penelope misses them and accepts them, but Taylor Riley just... refuses it despite also wanting to be with Penelope? There's no reason given in the story why Taylor Riley thinks their relationship is ruined. It's just there to make the story go on longer.


There is so much in this story we don't get to see. You'll get descriptions like, "They talked for hours." But we don't get to hear what they talked about.

She thought about this for a moment and then asked if she could borrow Frankie’s laptop. They helped her set herself up on the couch with tea and scones. She spent the next three hours writing two emails to her parents. The first was about her sexuality, and the second was about her gender. Frankie and Diego were in their pajamas by the time she finished, but they sat next to her and took turns reading the letters for her. Diego opted to be the one to edit her grammar and spelling so that Frankie could focus on the content of the letter. By the time he finished, he had tears in his eyes, and he held her in his arms while she cried too. Maybe it was a late-night decision or maybe it was just what Penelope thought she just needed to get it over with, but at one a.m., she pressed send on both emails.

We never see these emails.

So, I’ve done a lot of research on what it means to be nonbinary

We never see her researching. She's just talking about it after the fact.

Taylor had been gently guiding her through some of her thoughts over text, but earlier this week she’d stopped them mid-conversation and sent Penelope a link to a book. It was a graphic novel, something Penelope would never have chosen for herself, but the title piqued Penelope’s interest. She downloaded the eBook copy and read the entire book that night. She ran to her local bookstore, thank god they still had one of those, and picked up a physical copy the next day and she’d spent that night dog-earring almost half of the pages. When she was done, she laid back on her bed and just let herself… feel.

Wouldn't it of been cool to know what in the book Penelope felt so moved by? We're told Penelope is moved by this book. But we don't know what illustrations, quotes, or sentiments Penelope related to.

On Sunday, after she’d given Maria the entire rundown on everything gender that was happening in her life, Maria had dived in headfirst to help her revamp her style.

Maria is Penelope's best friend, roommate, and ex, but we don't get to see this conversation. We don't get to see Maria's reaction to Penelope telling her she's nonbinary.

“You’re... gender fluid?” Penelope asked, remembering clicking on that link and then sending it to—“oh fucking hell, I sent you a link on your own gender identity and asked you to discuss it with me, like a fucking asshole. Oh my god—”

We never actually see this. Wouldn't it of been so fun, and given Taylor Riley so much character, if we got to see what it was like for Penelope to send Taylor Riley their own gender identity, and see Taylor Riley's reaction to that? But we couldn't get that, because the author wanted to keep the readers in the dark about Taylor Riley being genderfluid. So instead, we get this quick one line sentence of an event that happened that we didn't even get to see the text conversation of.


Lastly, there's a plot point that is rather upsetting. Taylor Riley has always wanted a cat, but because they have depression, they often can't take care of themselves. They can't even get out of bed or eat food on their own. Despite being told this, Penelope and Maria push Taylor Riley to adopt a cat.

“You know…” Maria said, purposefully averting her eyes to watch Penelope place the food bowl on the ground. “Poppy and I are pretty good at keeping our little friend here alive. If you ever decided you wanted to get a cat, one or both of us could always stop by on days when you needed a little extra help around the house.” Penelope wanted to throw her arms around Maria. It wasn’t the kind of offer Penelope would have had the guts to make, but she had been thinking almost the exact same thing.
“I… I could never ask that—”
“Oh, you wouldn’t be asking. I’m telling you. We will be there for you. And your feline companion, whenever or if ever you need us,”

Unless you guys have a falling out. Terrible idea.

Thankfully, he had the wherewithal to dump a mountain of food in Oreo’s bowl Monday morning, so he was still being fed throughout the week. He momentarily remembered Maria and Penelope’s promise to take care of Oreo if he fell into a bad depression. Unfortunately, somewhere in the midst of his misery, he managed to lose track of his phone, and he didn’t find it again until Wednesday afternoon.

Yeah wooowww. What a surprise.
Why did the author feel the need to shove cat neglect into their book? There was no need for Penelope and Maria to persuade Taylor Riley into getting a cat, and there was no need for the author to write Taylor Riley being neglectful of it. Why do this?

Also, Penelope and Taylor Riley DO have a falling out. They don't speak for weeks after Taylor Riley's genderfluid identity is revealed. So the thing I was worried about happened within the fricken story.


Off-the-Mark LGBT Discussion

While a lot of the LGBT rep is decent and represented fine, some of it is just.. kinda off?

Hello, my name is Taylor Riley. I’m a gender fluid thirty-year-old who likes chocolate, wine, rock climbing, and, apparently, arcade games. I sometimes go by Taylor and she/her pronouns. When this is the case, I’m known to attend drag brunches, spend exorbitant amounts of money on clothing, and need to be on the go all the time. The rest of the time, I go by Riley and he/him pronouns. When this is the case, I spend more time at home, cuddling up with my cat or my loving friends, watching movies, and cooking nice meals.

Taylor took a huge breath in and let it out in a woosh. “I… am sometimes a woman, in which case I go by she/her and Taylor. And sometimes—well, more often than not, I am a man, and I go by he/him and Riley. And finally… sometimes I am a fucked-up mess of somewhere in between, but that’s called depression, and sometimes in those moments, I’d prefer they/them, but it also doesn’t really matter what you call me then.”

A genderfluid person is just one person. This book acts like Taylor and Riley are separate people. Taylor likes to rock climb; not Riley. Riley likes to cuddle with his cat; not Taylor. It feels more like DID than genderfluidity 😅
This also ties Taylor Riley's nonbinary they/them side to being mentally ill. Which is..... a choice?

Riley pursed his lip. “Oh, wow, you’re right. I’m sorry it was—well... to be frank, it can be a little hard to explain that I’m straight but also a lesbian without immediately outing myself as being gender non-conforming in some way.”

Being gender non-conforming means you don't abide by the stereotypes of your gender. Being genderfluid means your whole gender shifts. You can be a gender-conforming nonbinary person by conforming to the stereotypes people expect nonbinary people to be. Being nonbinary does not automatically mean you're gender-nonconforming. Taylor Riley is actually gender-conforming in a lot of ways. She has her long hair down and wears dresses when a woman, and wears his hair up and wears more masc clothes when a man. I understand the intent, but it wasn't the right word usage.

“I… don’t know. I’ve never really thought about it in this way before, but… I’ve had some bad feelings when my chest has been touched or looked at by men—…Is it weird though, that I don’t mind quite as much when women look at me like a woman, but I’m starting to think I don’t like it as much when men see me as a woman? Something about the female gaze makes me feel… seen? Like I’m not just a sex object or a boob squeeze toy?”

She understood that he would probably feel a bit freaked out if he felt he’d been accused of touching a woman inappropriately. Then again, she’d had many hookups where the guy wouldn’t even ask permission. They’d just go for a touch or feel while making out, and Penelope usually just accepted it.

Why is Penelope's breast dysphoria tied to her being sexually abused by men...? Why did the author not write that she has gender dysphoria there because it makes people perceive her as a woman when she doesn't feel that way, or her breasts just feel foreign to her? The author writing it this way makes it seem like Penelope is just dealing with sexism, feeling unsafe, and sexual trauma, as opposed to gender dysphoria.


Random Stuff

A weird thing is that everyone is oddly close in this book? They will have 4-person cuddle piles with each other. Exes will cuddle each other while being partnered with other people. Penelope and Taylor Riley make-out while Maria is sleeping on them, and Penelope thinks about how Maria wouldn't care, even if she was awake. Maria forces Penelope and Taylor Riley to cuddle with her, even though Taylor Riley said no and wasn't comfortable with touching.
It read more like they were setting up polyamory? Does the author think this is normal?


When the photo didn’t send, she chalked it up to bad cell service and pocketed her phone until they left the store. When she rechecked it later, while walking on the beach, she saw that the text failed to deliver, a sure sign that her number was blocked. So, naturally, she chucked her phone into the ocean. Sadly, her industrial strength case didn’t save her phone this time, so they spent the next two hours sobbing in a phone store.

She is 30 in this scene. This is so juvenile.


He had never seen her shoulder before, and there was something soft and trusting in it that he couldn’t describe

lol wut?

It felt like just enough contact and she liked it, so she did the same for him. She particularly liked the way his warm hand felt on her bare shoulder.

Confirmed. Author is a weirdo


Penelope blushed so hard she thought her face might be approaching purple.
“I can concur! Passing with flying colors thus far!” Maria called from the kitchen.
“Oh my god, I am so sorry about her,” Penelope groaned.
“Are you really?” Riley said, and his tone was light, but his eyes held something serious.
Penelope looked directly into his eyes and took only a second to think before saying, “No, I’m not. She’s amazing and a little overprotective, but I love her more than anything in this world. The fact she’s teasing you so hard means she’s already decided she likes you, so… no. I wouldn’t change a thing. About her or our night thus far.”

Way to make lighthearted banter emotionally serious and kill the mood, Riley. Way to overexplain and give exposition about your friendship with Maria, Penelope.


"Do you ever wear heels?” Penelope asked, eyeing her death trap shoes in the corner of her closet. She was coming to realize that all of her feminine clothes made her feel like she was playing dress-up—badly. Heels, makeup, dresses, purses. It all felt the same.

I don't know how this happens. Suddenly, you dislike the clothes you spent an inordinate amount of money on and specifically curated for yourself. At the age of 30. While living on your own.


Now that she was finally settling into her truth,

cringe


“I… I like the idea of bracelets. Maybe not… pink and blue, though. That feels a little…”
“Simplistic? Lame? Binary? Yeah, for sure. Sorry, I was just joking.”
“No, no, I was just thinking maybe… Maybe something that spoke more to how I felt because I rarely feel all the way blue or all the way pink. Maybe… like lilac, eggplant, black, and white?” Penelope nodded along until Taylor said black, then she got a pensive look on her face.
“Would white be… you’re feeling a little like everything? And black would be neither?” Taylor nodded, smiling softly to herself. Penelope had clearly done some research. These were the colors of the gender fluid flag. She actually wondered if Penelope had talked to Maria about it

Sorry. I am well acquainted with the genderfluid flag. But I didn't recognize it because you threw an EGGPLANT in there, and I lost all sense of myself.
Profile Image for b00ks_in_nature.
989 reviews16 followers
March 24, 2025
I really enjoyed this book! It’s insightful, informative, and thought provoking while remaining accessible, relatable and interesting. It deals with many topics including identity, queerness, acceptance, mental health, respect, boundaries, consent, and romantic and platonic relationships. It features a fantastic group of characters who represent many different gender and sexual identities. This is worth a read, and many rereads!
Profile Image for Tara.
568 reviews
December 23, 2025
For all the people who truly did not recognize Superman was Clark Kent just because of some glasses--

I had heard good things about this book, and it had a LOT to say about gender feelings vs presentation vs pronouns vs how society feels you vs how you feel in your own body, except everything was said like a Tumblr post (and believe me, I was there at the heyday of Gender On Tumblr) and, don't get me wrong, these are really good things to hear and say and internalize if you're someone who needs it! But for the characters themselves, or probably more like how it's written, it's kind of a mess. Which can be pretty true in real life, but isn't really written all that well for a reader. Besides messy gender exploration, the writing isn't there in general - we have lines like, "Her skin was golden brown, thanks to her Filipino parents."

Here's the gist: two people meet via a dating app in very tumultuous times in their own gender journey, and neither of them is in therapy despite very desperately needing it (until nearer to the end and then magically they can just get appointments that same week), and despite the blurb giving the whole deal away, the one character's (Riley aka Taylor) gender journey is obfuscated until about 75% in when she (Taylor) meets the other main character (Penelope, or Pen, or Pen 'n Wink, or Nels, or Lopi, or) despite having texted/called her for weeks (months? timeline unclear) - except of course they've already met, because Riley is pretty seriously dating Penelope to the point of full on couch makeout seshs and the further putting off of Big Conversations.

"So how did Pen(elope) not figure out Taylor was Riley? How did Riley/Taylor not figure out Pen was Penelope?" well! Phone issues of course, and "oh I'll fix it Sunday" my dude you live in modern America and you're putting off getting your phone fixed despite being dependent upon it for your one-sided codependent friendships with your exes AND the girl you're dating AND the (same) girl you're having big convos with as your other self? It's very obviously a plot device to ~keep the mystery~ but too very obtuse and obvious.

And then, even though Taylor and Penelope met in person she didn't recognize her as Riley... because of the distance?, we find out that Taylor doesn't even wear makeup, she just puts on some fashion glasses and wears her hair down and voila, Clark Kenting up in here, totally unrecognizable (no seriously) at least for a few minutes...

Wild that this book just came out in 2023 and I'm supposed to believe the main characters are in their late 20s, it feels like something written in the 2010s (because again, I was there in the Internet Gender Trenches and it feels very much that). It feels a lot more YA, but with characters old enough to get hung over and be responsible for their own broken phones and cat/rabbit adoptions, but also just take off work with no real notice for a week or more despite, checks notes, one working for a non-profit and in the middle of a big campaign, and one working in finance but also especially with the heavy one-sided codependency both characters have on their exes (and in Penelope's case, her brother and his boyfriend who he doesn't even identify as his boyfriend to her, his sister and close friend, for years into their relationship??), people who give and give to them but don't seem to have any sort of mutual give in return - they're mostly flat characters who seem to exist just to take care of Penelope and Riley/Taylor. Likewise, several queer side characters are shoehorned into, "...his rainbow-clad cubicle" and Maria, the asexual bff/roomie/ex bringing up her asexuality several many times which is a weird thing I have seen in several books with asexual characters?

Anyway, I didn't hate it but a good editor or critical beta reader could have shaped up a lot of the issues I had with it (there are also some typos and spacing issues in the published book - I bought a digital copy because the ARC version was unreadable as it was formatted in a way where ff/ffi words all just had those characters disappear), and it may be a good and useful book for people who are very new to their gender journey and don't have the privilege of being around social spaces, whether online or in person, to comfortably explore that.

And one final thing - I know it's Penelope's lack of understanding that being a DFAB person she immediately needed to be a drag king when she did drag but a) ciswomen and DFAB women can also be drag queens! They always have been part of the community and b) there are many more drag styles outside of queen/king, outside the binary.

Thank you to The Paper House and NetGalley for the eARC for review! Even though I bought a copy!
1,304 reviews18 followers
March 22, 2025
A Beautiful story that has wonderful characters exploring their sexualities, and their gender identities.

This is such a poignant story and really important to read right now. This book shows what true acceptance is, and shows how to be understanding and supportive of those who are simply trying to be themselves. Penelope, Taylor, and Riley all have insecurities with themselves due to the actions and behaviors of others, among other things, but along the way they were able to befriend the people who turned into their biggest allies and supporters.

I loved Penelope, she is such an exuberant, confident (at times), and quirky woman who's trying to put herself out in the dating world while also figuring herself out. I adored how much Penelope paid attention to Riley whenever they spent time together, she was so aware of all the nuances Riley's body language gave off and was able to pick up on them and adjust to make Riley comfortable. Her being so supportive and accepting was just so beautiful to read.

I could relate a lot to Riley, he was scared to open up to Penelope in fear of judgement, and then in fear of her leaving him... He had walls around his heart and it took him a while,(and some therapy) before he could open up to her. Throughout the story everything that happens leads up to a very important moment. And while that scene and the chapters after that are heartbreaking, they were absolutely necessary. I can't say too much cause I don't want to spoil anything but... While I was devastated for everyone involved, if that moment never happened, then I don't think Riley, Taylor and Penelope would've ever been able to work together.

Penelope, Riley and Taylor all went through struggling times throughout the story, each of them are trying to figure out who they are, what they like, and what feels right to them. There is a bit of angst in this book but it has a place in this story. Once you read this yourself you'll understand what I mean by that. I learned quite a bit whilst reading this story about gender fluidity and how it's okay to try new things to figure out who you are and who you want to be. I thought this story was really beautiful.

I do want to say I thought the writing itself was extraordinary!! It immediately pulled me in and immersed me into the world the author had created. The characters were dynamic, personable, relatable, and absolutely fantastic! I loved that the side characters are just as important as the MC's, and the bonds that Penelope, Taylor, and Riley have with their friends is Soo beautiful!

While this story is on the more heavy side (at times), I do think this is a lovely, and light romance story. It's what the world needs right now, it's what I need. This was an absolute joy to read and I'm excited for book 2!!
Profile Image for Danielle - drops.everything.and.reads.
304 reviews8 followers
March 24, 2023
Wow. What a fantastic book! I wasn't even halfway through and I was already recommending this book to friends.

This book is a beautiful exploration of sexuality, gender, friendship, and romance. While the book centres around the characters of Penelope, Riley, and Taylor, we are also introduced to their close friends and family, all of whom are incredibly supportive, compassionate, kind, and with the exception of one straight character, are part of LGBTQPI+ community. Penelope, Riley, and Taylor are each on a journey of coming into their best and favourite selves, something I think so many of us are trying to do. In the case of these characters, it is largely concerning their gender and sexuality, but also how to be one's favourite self in a relationship, especially when it's new, tentative, and trust is slowly growing. I also love how the characters are trying new things, for example, Penelope hosting a drag brunch as a drag king. As she steps outside of her comfort zone, she is able to become more in tune with who she is and who she/they want to be.

The relationships that Penelope, Riley, and Taylor have with their friends are beautiful and, I think, something that we all deserve to have. Friends who love us, care for us, support, challenge us, cheer us on and cheer us up, who want the best for us. This book shows how powerful friendships can be, how important they are for our health and happiness.

This is a romance, so I would be remiss if I didn't speak to this element of the book. Well, the romance is extraordinarily well done, and even comes with a bit of a twist! While I clued in on the twist fairly early on, doing so only made me appreciate the writing of the book even more, the details and clues that are present.

Something I was so impressed with is how consent is approached in this book. It is explicit. It is often. There are discussions about boundaries, about needs, about preferences. And the characters are respectful, listen, and change their behaviours accordingly. When a character makes a mistake, even inadvertently, they own it and apologize.

Overall, I love this book. It is fantastic and I will happily recommend it to others. To note, while the characters are in their late 20s, I do think this is a book that people in their late teens could read and enjoy.
I understand there will be a second book and I will happily read it when it becomes available!

Thanks to NetGalley, The Paper House and the author for an e-ARC of the book. Opinions are entirely my own.
Profile Image for Fruzsina Bagin.
280 reviews5 followers
February 13, 2025
"An Epic Construct" is not just a story, but a mirror – a sensitive and honest portrayal of the challenges faced by those in search of their identity. However, it can be valuable not only for those who experience these dilemmas personally – it is also a useful and enlightening read for those who want to understand queer people around them better and learn how to support them with respect and empathy.

The story centres on Penelope, who after many failures tries her luck on a new queer dating app, hoping to finally find love. However, the events that follow are about much more than a romantic search: the novel becomes an emotionally rich and profound journey of friendship, love, sexuality, gender identity, personal boundaries, communication, self-discovery and acceptance.

Although the book touches on serious issues such as depression, anxiety and the struggle with societal expectations, the author delivers it with sensitivity and humour. It was particularly fascinating to see that much of the conflict at the heart of the story stems from a lack of communication or miscommunication – a problem that often makes it difficult to experience self-identity and human relationships in real life.

The characters are absolutely fascinating. Although the novel focuses mainly on Penelope, Riley and Taylor, the supporting characters are just as memorable and full of life. As one big queer family, they support each other, endure hard times together, and are always there for each other. D.C. Emerson has explicitly taken care of diversity, with pansexual, bisexual, gay, lesbian, asexual, non-binary, transgender and genderfluid characters all represented in the story, and even the world of drag queens (and drag kings).

Overall, "An Epic Construct" is not just a novel, but an experience. It is a book that has the power to touch you, to inspire you and to teach you something about yourself and others. Sensitive, humorous, honest and profound, it is exactly the kind of book I would recommend to anyone open to a heart-warming and thought-provoking read.

I received a free copy of "An Epic Construct" by D.C. Emerson via NetGalley and am voluntarily leaving a review.
Profile Image for Issy Waldrom.
Author 12 books60 followers
March 28, 2023
Let me open with the statement that I absolutely loved that story. Really really loved it. It was wonderful, heartwarming, adorable, and filled with so many gender and queer feels. It's the kind of read that leaves you feeling warm and fuzzy inside as you finish it, and smiling stupidly as you read through it, the interactions between the characters something to be envious of.

It's a journey of self discovery and coming out, and being able to share that with others, and finding oneself in the right space to be able to do so. Of being able to find the one for you, of building a relationship with them, and of being accepted and loved, with all of the pain and heartbreak that is felt along the way, along with all of the happiness and joy. The journey isn't always easy, but it isn't a journey made alone either.

The characters, especially the friends are on both sides are wonderful (lots of cuddles!), and I really think everyone's life would be better with friends like that. There is life to them all, and they enrich the story in so many ways. Yes, most of them are queer, but that is part of what makes the book as wonderful as it is. None of them are perfect, especially the mc's, but that really makes the journey so engrossing, and so relatable. Because, for many, what the characters go through and have been through really is quite familiar.

It is wonderfully written, hilarious at times, serious at others, but still managed to keep me immersed and just wanting to read more (and yes, I am very excited for the sequel). It was the sort of story that I knew from the first few pages that I was going to love it, and it did not disappoint.

It really is an adorable story, and one that I am so glad to have found, and eagerly recommend to others. Especially for anyone on the gender spectrum (be it trans, non-binary, gender fluid, bigender etc), as so much of it is relatable.
Profile Image for Janette.
911 reviews22 followers
March 22, 2023
An Epic Construct is unlike most romance novels I’ve read recently. Sure, there’s a love story - maybe even a few - but it’s much more than two people meeting and falling in love. This book is a beautiful journey of introspection, self-discovery and acceptance for both main characters, both of themselves and each other.

When Penelope and Riley first match through a dating app, their connection already feels charged. Dawn Cutler-Tran infuses their interactions with flirty banter but also a healthy dose of vulnerability. Both characters harbor uncertainties and insecurities, and it’s this sense of wanting more yet holding back that sets the stage for what I can only describe as an intensely complex and fragile budding romance.

The mental health, gender and sexuality representation in this novel are outstanding. I’ve had this on my TBR and decided to make it my first read of the #transrightsreadathon, and I’m so glad I did. I’ve read books with trans or gender fluid characters, but rarely do they acknowledge or display what that lived experience looks like the way it happens in this book. Pen and Taylor Riley’s thoughts, emotions and behaviors are conveyed genuinely and unmistakably true to who they are. I wish more stories showed this level of intricacy, sincerity, sensitivity and awareness when portraying these characters.

As much as this book is about love and acceptance, it’s also about communication. I sincerely wish real life was full of the honesty & ability to openly share your needs the way Taylor Riley and Penelope do with their chosen support networks. Not that they don’t have fears & anxiety - they do. But knowing someone is there with that type of unconditional love and understanding isn’t something everyone has despite the fact it’s something we all need.
Profile Image for ABG.
36 reviews1 follower
June 13, 2023
A beautifully written story about finding yourself, and finding love. This is one of most diverse casts I’ve ever seen in a book, with characters of various races, genders, ages, sexualities, and backgrounds. The representation was very well-done - this book clearly made the distinction that its characters weren’t stereotypes, but characters will full lives of their own, and for all identities that I can speak for (I’m nonbinary and asexual), I must say that the representation was respectful and relatable. I loved seeing Penelope meet Riley and the two of them work on each other and themselves through the course of the narrative. Penelope’s conversations with Taylor were something that I haven’t often seen - characters talking about their queerness so frankly and in such depths - and it was really well done. Each POV felt distinctive, the characters were likeable and if not relatable written to be understandable. The plot moved forward naturally as did the relationships - I never once found myself bored. The author has a lovely writing style that seamlessly blends dialogue, thoughts, and actions, and it was a joy to read. I will say, though, that you definitely have to be reading with a keen eye! I skimmed some parts of the earlier chapters when I was in a hurry and suffered a little for that later. Take the time to read this one - it’s definitely worth it. I would recommend it to anyone who likes romance novels and wants to learn more about the LGBTQ community, and anyone who is in the community - you’ll surely find yourself or a friend in some characters, or see how their experiences are different to yours.

I received a free copy of this book from NetGalley in exchange for an honest review. All opinions are my own.
Profile Image for The Bookish Chimera - Pauline.
594 reviews9 followers
March 15, 2025
“Like you’ve been trying to think of a word you’ve forgotten your entire life, and when you remember it it’s a huge relief.”

I adored An Epic Construct, probably because it resonated very deeply with me. This story has the perfect balance between emotions. Taylor Riley and Penelope are anxious, but the book is also full of (queer) joy. Even though they question who they are –sometimes with tons of self criticism– hope and joy prevail.
This book is like a cozy blanket that helps you pass the darkest hours of winter, and should be read by people questioning, and even by anyone, because the author makes something I love in all their works: they humanize the characters, trigger empathy, and even though queerness is the core of the book, it also isn’t. Characters are. Humans are. I can’t say how deeply I love it (and have trouble putting it into words, sorry).
Everyone’s experience is of course different, but I’ve read some of the most relatable things I’ve read until now, especially (but not only) regarding anxiety. Such books help feel less alone in the world, help understand that no one is alone, even though everyone is unique. That makes them invaluable.

Thank you to the author for the gifted ebook. My opinions are my own.
Profile Image for Aimee .
1,251 reviews14 followers
February 26, 2023
Sweet story

I really loved the overall premise of the story. I loved how Penelope discovered herself more and how she handled all of Riley’s anxieties and other issues, like depression.

It was a little frustrating for the miscommunications to go on for so long. I felt like they had almost too many talks and it was frustrating that the times they did get to talk, something always happened to derail it and nothing was accomplished and it was dragged on. I totally understand Riley’s anxiety over telling Penelope and it spiraling into depression, so I can see it taking a little longer for him to tell her, it just felt almost too long.

I loved P’s sense of humor and I loved how she knew she was female and not trans, not male but more neutral. I liked how she explored that and discovered who she was. I absolutely adored Maria and learning thru her about ace romantic. I loved Frankie and Diego and the little side story of them getting together and Diego’s past. Sham Pain was a delight!!

I loved the story and I loved learning about all these gender identities. The author did a really amazing job telling this sweet story.
Profile Image for Rose.
160 reviews
April 21, 2023
If you have ever questioned your sexuality, or even moreso, your gender expression and gender identity, read this book. Even if you haven't questioned it, if you enjoy discussions of it, read this book.

Penelope gets pressured into a dating app by her asexual roommate and quickly becomes interested in Riley. Riley is very sweet, but struggles with anxiety and depression and disappears for days at a time (though is extremely well supported by other friends). In the meantime, Penelope's brother begs her to emcee at his cafe's drag brunch, where she meet Taylor. Penelope and Taylor quickly strike up a deep texting relationship, particularly discussing gender. Is Penelope falling for both of them?

Honestly, the romance aspects in the books almost feels more of a cover for the large discussions around sexuality and gender, but I am 100% here for that. And I really like a lot of the characters. I'm looking forward to seeing what the next book in the series holds for us!

Note: I received a free review PDF of this book courtesy of NetGalley and the publisher, but reviews are my own.
4 reviews
March 16, 2023
Honestly, I don't typically read any type of romance and wasn't sure how much I would actually enjoy this book, but I was excited to support my best friend anyway. Even though I had read parts of it before it was published and knew generally how the story was supposed to go ahead of time, I found myself pleasantly surprised by how quickly I became attached to the characters and how much I enjoyed seeing the different story lines weave together. I don't personally identify as LGBTQ+ so it was also enlightening to read about so many characters with life experiences different than myself in so many ways, but seeing that at our core we do have some similarities - like
how we all want to be loved and accepted by those around us. It was especially meaningful considering that I know the author was pulling from lived experiences as she built these multi-dimensional characters, both her own and from other people she has met and gotten to know along the way. I would recommend this book to anyone who is looking for a sweet romance.
Profile Image for Heather Burt.
188 reviews9 followers
May 1, 2023
In the modern era of online dating, Penelope is talked into using an LGBTQ+ app that her asexual bestie and roommate tell her about. While getting to MC a drag brunch, she meets a beautiful woman in the audience named Taylor. They begin forming a deep connection in their queerness and Taylor supports Penelope as she finally begins to explore her gender identity. Penelope isn't sure if she is non-binary, but feels she needs to find who she is in the journey of introspection, self-discovery and acceptance for both main characters, both of themselves and each other.
Penelope meets Riley through the dating app, and they soon grow a relationship with each other. They both have insecurities and anxiety, but help each other get through it.
This book is a great example of unconditional love with someone who has flaws. Their communication with each other is one of the prime requirements in a relationship. Communication isn't a huge importance in many romance books, and that won me over.
Profile Image for Aleksander Petit.
Author 2 books14 followers
August 17, 2023
An Epic Construct is a highly enjoyable and meaningful read. The LGBT+ representation, mental illness representation, and the ways the two intersect is relatable in a way that I don't often see in media. I have a million and one praises to sing about this book and can't articulate all of them, but it boils down to An Epic Construct being a validating experience for me as a queer, mentally ill twenty-something. It addresses the layers of how scary dating can be in a way that makes failed past experiences feel less like outright failures and more like bricks in the path towards something happy later on. And the book also has charming, sometimes even ridiculous moments that will make you laugh and smile. Also cute pets. Overall, an amazing book about the importance of open communication but also taking things at your own pace in both your relationships with others and your relationship with yourself.
Profile Image for S. Jeyran  Main.
1,667 reviews143 followers
October 31, 2023
‘An Epic Construct’ is a fictional LGBTQ+ story about Penelope’s dating life and how her friend thinks she will have a more successful dating experience if she joins a dating app. As Penelope is also trying to figure out her own identity and suspects her to be nonbinary, she meets Riley, who identifies as queer. Every other character she meets and interacts with becomes more challenging and dynamic as the story unfolds.

The author ensures the reader’s intrigue and introduces a very diverse and exciting tale that enables the reader to understand what it’s like to be sexually challenged and how to navigate the ups and downs of dating.

I appreciate the self-discovery and searching for love regardless of sexual orientation. I recommend this book to those who like fictional and dating stories.
Profile Image for Anna.
168 reviews19 followers
May 7, 2023
Rating• ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️

•This is an adult LGBTQ+ Romance novel! It is such a cute story!! The characters were adorable together and I was so excited to get to see how their story played out!!

Mini review:
•This was such a cute story! It shows the story of two people who meet on a dating app who end up having a hard time deciding and sharing what their sexuality is.

•There was a plot twist in this story and I was a little shocked! As soon as it happened I instantly wanted to finish the book to see how the rest played out!!

•A small breath escaped his lips. "I... make you melt? When I..." he stopped and just blinked down at her. "Yes, sweetheart. You do. And surprisingly, it seems that I like melting.”

•"I want a chance at forever with Nels."
Profile Image for Donna Robinson.
1,111 reviews2 followers
November 19, 2025
This was a wonderfully romantic story between two people who are struggling to figure out their identity. Riley was a deeply personal character, as he was uncertain about a lot of things regarding himself and struggled with opening himself up to Penelope, our other protagonist. Penelope was very open and accommodating with the open struggles of Riley, while also exploring her own gender by briefly becoming a drag king. The pacing was slow, but that didn't take away from the format of the two's relationship. Overall, the author does a fantastic job of talking about gender and sexuality in an open and inviting manner that really helps with giving readers an understanding of their own questions about any of these topics.
Profile Image for Jasmine Shouse.
Author 10 books91 followers
March 18, 2023
An Epic Construct is a sweet story about dating, gender, and self-exploration.

Penelope and Riley independently decide to start dating again using a queer app and they match together. From the first date, their respective anxiety helps break the ice while they start to learn more about each other and themselves.

I love their support networks and how healthily they communicate, even when they miscommunicate. Respect and consent are huge to them both, and it shows.

Rep: Sapphic, Achillean, Asexual, Pansexual, Bisexual, Trans, Nonbinary, Gender-fluid, Anxiety, and Depression

Thanks to NetGalley and publisher for the opportunity to read and review!
Profile Image for mikayla.
115 reviews4 followers
May 21, 2023
Thanks to NetGalley and publisher for this ARC!!

An Epic Construct was a very good read. It followed Penelope, Taylor, and Riley as they find themselves and go on dating adventures.

An Epic Construct was entertaining, cute, heartwarming, and enjoyable. It was an easy and fun read. I enjoyed the characters and how they all had very good support systems. There was so much queer representation as well! The plot twist was pretty predictable. The writing was amateurish at times but overall decent.

The book did cover some darker topics like depression, so fair warning for that and please check the trigger warnings!
Profile Image for Grace.
566 reviews10 followers
February 22, 2025
I don’t think I have ever felt so seen by a book before. To quote my own notes: I am Penelope and Penelope is me. I related so hard to their gender journey. They had such an amazing support network for it too, with their friends being so amazing. I especially loved Maria and Penelope’s friendship and how unconditionally they loved each other. Overall I was so invested and so proud of Penelope. I was also very invested in the romance. It was so sweet, and they were such a perfect match. I am so glad it was multi pov and I got each of their thoughts and feelings. They were both anxious and awkward, yet willing to put in the work. They also balanced each other well. I liked how they included their friends in the development of their relationship as well. So for the most part this was such a wholesome read. However, there was some very intense angst that had me sobbing. It was so well written but heartbreaking. Thankfully there was an amazing, very happy and hopeful ending. So overall I adored this book and cannot recommend it enough.
9 reviews1 follower
August 10, 2024
Thank you to NetGalley and the publisher for the ARC of An Epic Construct.

This book was so unique and relatable, taking its time exploring the challenges of entering a relationship for anxious people, especially when there are identity struggles happening. It was so refreshing to read characters who are careful and intelligent and empathetic in their communication. Highly recommend!

The only downside is the formatting in the ARC copy was an absolute mess and made the book quite challenging to read… many letters being left out, and some sentences randomly getting scrambled so I had to decipher what the true order of the sentences should be.
Profile Image for Raven and Chris.
3,664 reviews34 followers
February 25, 2025
I felt so seen reading this book. As someone who has never felt 100% comfortable in my own skin, I could relate to both Penelope and Riley. I absolutely loved this book. Both MCs are struggling with their identity and being honest in their life with who they are and expressing themselves as such. I fell in love with both of them. I also love the fact that they both have friends and family who accept them just as they are. Such a good story and I can’t wait to see how their relationship develops.
Profile Image for June.
266 reviews
February 26, 2025
I love how queer DC Emerson's books are! They're light, they're fun, but at the same time they dig deep into queer identities. I love how understood and not-alone they make me feel.

If there's a trope that many of us hate (with good reason), it's a love triangle. Though I love it when authors take on the challenge of twisting the idea and turning it on its head. Without spoiling the plot, this is exactly what DC Emerson does here, and they've done a great job!!

Penelope has a hell of a time trying to navigate her feelings for beautiful and badass Taylor, and for sweet and skittish Riley. At the same time she's also starting to question her own gender and what that means for her relationships.

Emerson brings us a drag queen, drag kings, multiple found families, healthy relationships, and a conversation on gender that felt incredibly personal to me. This is a really positive book and I think a lot of us "what the hell is gender anyway?" folks would enjoy reading it.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 48 reviews