I love stories from the Hebrew Bible, having studied them way back in university and I love the Book of Esther which has one of the most interesting of all the stories, but this felt a little flat to me.
I understand the author was trying to stay as close to the source material as possible (even putting the exact biblical references as the bottom of the page), but having read a few historical fiction books about Esther (including one I read last year that was fantastic and one I’m currently reading), on top of the actual Bible story, this lacked the depth I’ve seen in other stories.
It’s very short and isn’t entirely clear in terms of showing the passage of time. One moment Esther’s just showing up to be trained to meet Xerxes and the next page it’s already been a year and she’s having her first meeting. And then a panel later, he’s asking her to be queen.
I feel like if you haven’t read the Book of Esther and/or know the basic story, there are parts that aren’t really explained as well as they could be. There’s not much done to fill in gaps and could leave some people confused.
It tells the story just fine, but isn’t as well composed as I think it could have been. And I wasn’t a huge fan of the art style.
So all in all, a solid 3/5.