I wrote this review for the sole purpose of defending Filipinos.
Okay, fine, the book review first. At the beginning, I loved it. The writing was sort of good, the graphic depiction of Paris was inspired. The characters of Lydie and Patrice were fascinating. The disintegration of Lydie and Michael's marriage was heartbreaking, but I respected Michael when he told her about his affair rather than went on with it behind her back. How Luanne Rice described how they grew apart was great and heartbreaking. All of it built up to an awful conclusion though, so shame.
However, there was one bit I'd rather rave about - the depiction of the Filipino housekeeper Kelly.
First of all, Luanne, what's this about Kelly being named after Grace Kelly? Most Filipinos are not aware who Grace Kelly is. It is true that those from the province love to name their children after actors and actresses (This is actually pretty funny. They'd name children Elvis Presley Santos or James Bond dela Cruz etc.), but come on, over here, most people from the province don't have cable. That means, they haven't watched Casablanca or Gone with the Wind or any of your favorite classic black and whites. If I go to the province and talk about Paul Newman or Olivia de Havilland, they won't know what I'm talking about. Okay? They would've hardly heard of Clark Gable, or Ingrid Bergman, or Joan Fontaine, or Vivien Leigh or Cary Grant or James Stewart. Okay?! Had she been named Audrey Hepburn Merida, I would've bought it!
Second, what was that about the Philippines being an awful and poor country? Given, this is a third-world-country, but it's not fucking drought here. There certainly are parts of the country that are dirt-poor, I'll give you that, but you cannot generalize that. It's like saying Americans are racists because some of them treated African-American people as slaves a few centuries ago. Also, honestly, I'll accept poor (it is a third world country after all) but awful? If you think it's such an awful country, stop writing characters who came from it!
Third, what's this about Kelly being an accountant and settling for a maid? Are you insinuating that our level of education here is crap? Accountancy is a five-year program, and once you graduate from that you take the Certified Public Accountant board exam to be called an accountant. What era is this novel in anyway, 1950s? No way would an accountant settle for a job as maid just to be in Paris in the 90s. No way would an accountant dream of going to the states and building a fishing market without any concrete plan in the 90s. Filipino accountants don't equate to high school graduates in America. All right? You made her out to be an accountant who's as naïve as a 12-year-old. This is very very insulting.
Fourth, what's this with Kelly being a witch? WTF? This is the most ridiculous and outrageous thing she's written in the novel. Where was she from, Capiz? All right, let me give you a background there: Capiz is the capital of aswang and mangkukulam. We have these things embedded in our culture and tradition, where people believe in witchcraft and in people who become flying monsters who eat fetuses and internal organs at night etc. - which are all unfounded but still entertaining to this day. It wasn't enough that Kelly's named after Grace Kelly and the Philippines was an awful and very poor country and Filipino accountants become maids in Paris - you have to make her sister a mangkukulam? Absolutely laughable garbage.
It seems to me, Luanne, that you researched about Filipinos a little bit and collected all the stereotypes and put them in your novel. This is nothing but an insulting, outrageous crap. I hope no one believed your depiction because you ruined my country's culture in this novel and that's unforgivable.
You see, I still gave you two stars for Secrets in Paris, because I didn't discount your writing style and the plot of the story in rating it. I find your depiction of the Filipino character and her country repulsive and denigrating, but that doesn't affect your style of storytelling and the story you wanted to tell.
Your ending was awful though.
Not recommending.