My 2006 edition of this classic has a great introduction by Edward Lee, stating how much this book inspired his own works; after reading it I understand! Shirley did not attempt some 'mainstream' horror here, he went far off the grid into hardcore territory. Lee also states that Shirley pushed the boundaries and opened the door for the horror genre to really become what it could be, or at least the subgenre known today as 'extreme'. Cellars contains some truly gruesome scenes for sure, but what sets it apart concerns the fairly sophisticated plot, the vivid imagery and the just plain 'in your face' narration as events unfold.
Our protagonist, Carl Lanyard, writes for a rag that focuses upon the supernatural, but his voice there serves as the sceptic. While from the West Coast, Carl starts the novel in NYC, where he had been attempting to get and interview with Madelaine, an avowed psychic, and while they did strike up a relationship, no dice on the formal interview. While waiting at JFK for his plane home, some cops pick him up and take him to a subway; there he finds a police inspector and a brutally butchered body of a young woman. It seems the head cop, Gribner, knows about Carl from his column, and asks for some help on solving the case. Obviously, some sort of ritual took place around the dead woman, and she was not the first. Carl wants nothing to do with it, but he calls his boss in San Francisco and he offers him 150 grand to help out, and get the scoop for the rag. Well, Carl takes it...
I really do not want to focus on the plot here other than stating the obvious-- some cult or something is killing people underground, employing the same rituals. The cops find no clues and are stumped. Carl really has no idea either, except he recognizes some of the runes involved as a Persian god. Meanwhile, Madelaine, an aspiring actress, invites Carl to a dinner/celebration for one Joey Minder, a producer, one she hopes will give her a big role in an upcoming play. Pretty quickly, we know Joeys the antagonist and things start to get very interesting...
I really liked this and loved the depiction of NYC before the bankers et.al. gentrified the piss out of it. Shirley gives you the Lower East Side gritty, mean and dirty. Good stuff, and so far, my favorite by Shirley by a long shot. 4.5 hardcore stars!