This is a cute book but only a 2 star...sorry. The pictures are cute and story is cute, and I would give it a 3 if I was reading it for an avid swimmer or swimming class or maybe even Father's Day story but it was just so,so. I know RUDE!
I feel badly only giving this three stars given how intensely my daughter loves this book. I think it is just meh, and the art isn't great, but it has a deep hypnotic pull on my two-year-old.