What do you think?
Rate this book
Unexpected Seasons #2
An Unlikely Proposition
A standalone companion to An Improbable Season , this Regency romance ― perfect for fans of Bridgerton ― is about following your heart, pursuing your dreams, and falling head over heels in love.
Eleanor did not come to London to be proper and boring. After the death of her husband and a year of mourning, the seventeen year old wants nothing more than her independence and to have a little fun. She’s hardly looking to remarry, despite pressures from her late husband’s nephew, who is keen on obtaining her inheritance. Eleanor quickly devises a plan that includes a fake engagement. What’s not a part of the plan? Falling for a dashing, quiet man outside of her social circle – a man who is not her betrothed. Can she survive the Season with her heart and her fortune intact?
Thalia is determined to begin afresh after a disastrous first Season in London. No romantic distractions, but only her work as a poet and newfound companion to Eleanor. Determined to get her poems published, she struggles to be taken seriously as a female writer. As the spring progresses, Thalia does not expect to take interest in a man from her past (a man who is engaged to her employer, no less!), but some feelings demand to be felt even if the timing isn’t quite right.
Rosalyn Eves's An Unlikely Proposition is a transportive Regency drama that captures the sparkle of London, thrill of friendship, and swoon of new love.
Eleanor did not come to London to be proper and boring. After the death of her husband and a year of mourning, the seventeen year old wants nothing more than her independence and to have a little fun. She’s hardly looking to remarry, despite pressures from her late husband’s nephew, who is keen on obtaining her inheritance. Eleanor quickly devises a plan that includes a fake engagement. What’s not a part of the plan? Falling for a dashing, quiet man outside of her social circle – a man who is not her betrothed. Can she survive the Season with her heart and her fortune intact?
Thalia is determined to begin afresh after a disastrous first Season in London. No romantic distractions, but only her work as a poet and newfound companion to Eleanor. Determined to get her poems published, she struggles to be taken seriously as a female writer. As the spring progresses, Thalia does not expect to take interest in a man from her past (a man who is engaged to her employer, no less!), but some feelings demand to be felt even if the timing isn’t quite right.
Rosalyn Eves's An Unlikely Proposition is a transportive Regency drama that captures the sparkle of London, thrill of friendship, and swoon of new love.
298 pages, Hardcover
First published March 5, 2024
31 people are currently reading
1319 people want to read
About the author
Rosalyn Eves
8 books710 followersRosalyn Eves grew up in the Rocky Mountains, dividing her time between reading books and bossing her siblings into performing her dramatic scripts. As an adult, the telling and reading of stories is still one of her favorite things to do. When she's not reading or writing, she enjoys spending time with her chemistry professor husband and three children, watching British period pieces, or hiking through the splendid landscape of southern Utah, where she lives. She dislikes housework on principle.
She is the author of the BLOOD ROSE REBELLION trilogy, BEYOND THE MAPPED STARS, and AN IMPROBABLE SEASON
Review policy: I only review books that I enjoyed and would recommend to others (hence the predominance of 4-5 star reviews).
She is the author of the BLOOD ROSE REBELLION trilogy, BEYOND THE MAPPED STARS, and AN IMPROBABLE SEASON
Review policy: I only review books that I enjoyed and would recommend to others (hence the predominance of 4-5 star reviews).
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 173 reviews
January 6, 2024
Writing reviews usually comes easily to me. I read, and I make notes, read and make notes. And then, all of a sudden, I’m reading a book without writing anything down. And when I open my notes app, words get stuck in my brain, and I can’t get them out. Maybe this is what writers call a writer's block. And this is what happened while reading An Unlikely Proposition.
So bear with me. First of all, I liked this Regency romance about two teen girls, Eleanor, a young widow, and her new companion, Thalia.
An Unlikely Proposition is a light romance for anyone who wants to dream away for a while and even wants to read a book in just one sitting. Think of Bridgerton and even more Queen Charlotte. Imagine sitting in front of a fire, a blanket wrapped around your body, or with your face in the spring sun, taking your thoughts back to that era. Envision that smile growing on your face and rooting for Eleanor and Thalia. This is such a book. Light and easy, as if you’re floating across the dance floor.
Sometimes, we just need light and easy reads. Actual rating 3.5 stars, rounded up to four.
Thanks so much, Rosalyn Eves and NetGalley, for this ARC!
Follow me on Instagram
So bear with me. First of all, I liked this Regency romance about two teen girls, Eleanor, a young widow, and her new companion, Thalia.
An Unlikely Proposition is a light romance for anyone who wants to dream away for a while and even wants to read a book in just one sitting. Think of Bridgerton and even more Queen Charlotte. Imagine sitting in front of a fire, a blanket wrapped around your body, or with your face in the spring sun, taking your thoughts back to that era. Envision that smile growing on your face and rooting for Eleanor and Thalia. This is such a book. Light and easy, as if you’re floating across the dance floor.
Sometimes, we just need light and easy reads. Actual rating 3.5 stars, rounded up to four.
Thanks so much, Rosalyn Eves and NetGalley, for this ARC!
Follow me on Instagram
March 1, 2024
4.5 stars.
Once again, this book delivered from start to finish.
If you want a book with historical tones, dazzling characters, imperfect choices and double the romance, then add this to your list!
One woman...a young widow with independence wanting to soak up her freedom for all that its worth and the other...a woman who has her sights set on making a name for herself in a man driven field. Both were so passionate and endearing in their own right....with love interests to match them perfectly.
I love that this book feels like a true YA historical romance that is accessible for all ages. Both points of view were equally as engaging that I never felt the others loss when it switched. The characters themselves are bright and witty and blaze with passion and personality.
The double romance only amplified this book and I loved seeing how the conflicts resolved themselves only to bring people together. I thought it felt original while still staying true to the genre.
An overall just really good time and I loved that I never wanted to put it down. Definitely recommend reading these in order to get the best experience, but can be read as standalones as well.
Once again, this book delivered from start to finish.
If you want a book with historical tones, dazzling characters, imperfect choices and double the romance, then add this to your list!
One woman...a young widow with independence wanting to soak up her freedom for all that its worth and the other...a woman who has her sights set on making a name for herself in a man driven field. Both were so passionate and endearing in their own right....with love interests to match them perfectly.
I love that this book feels like a true YA historical romance that is accessible for all ages. Both points of view were equally as engaging that I never felt the others loss when it switched. The characters themselves are bright and witty and blaze with passion and personality.
The double romance only amplified this book and I loved seeing how the conflicts resolved themselves only to bring people together. I thought it felt original while still staying true to the genre.
An overall just really good time and I loved that I never wanted to put it down. Definitely recommend reading these in order to get the best experience, but can be read as standalones as well.
March 4, 2024
What a beautifully written and charming YA Regency romance! I thoroughly enjoyed it!
A 17-year-old widow, Eleanor, finds herself in a predicament. Despite her late husband's fortune, she is unable to remarry due to restrictions left in his will, and she’s constantly being hounded by his greedy nephew about it. In an effort to get him to leave her alone, Eleanor establishes a fake engagement with a friend.
Thalia answers an advertisement placed by Eleanor and goes to London to work as her companion. While there, she continues to pursue her quest to become a published poet. Not an easy feat in a very male dominated world.
I enjoyed both of these characters and was so invested in their experiences. I felt their frustrations with gender inequality, class differences, and their individual doubts and fears. I loved the way they evolved and grew through the story, and became true to themselves.
The romances they had with their unlikely suitors were sweet and charmingly portrayed. Owen and Henry were the perfect partners for these two unique women.
The overall story has the traditional terms, settings, and elements of a typical regency novel, but with a bit more modern dialogue. That in no way took away from the pleasure of the story.
An Unlikely Proposition is a fun read for regency romance lovers who enjoy YA fiction with complex characters and storylines, and kisses only romance.
Thanks to NetGalley, Rosalyn Eves, Macmillan USA, and Austenprose PR for providing me with an early copy. All opinions expressed are completely my own.
A 17-year-old widow, Eleanor, finds herself in a predicament. Despite her late husband's fortune, she is unable to remarry due to restrictions left in his will, and she’s constantly being hounded by his greedy nephew about it. In an effort to get him to leave her alone, Eleanor establishes a fake engagement with a friend.
Thalia answers an advertisement placed by Eleanor and goes to London to work as her companion. While there, she continues to pursue her quest to become a published poet. Not an easy feat in a very male dominated world.
I enjoyed both of these characters and was so invested in their experiences. I felt their frustrations with gender inequality, class differences, and their individual doubts and fears. I loved the way they evolved and grew through the story, and became true to themselves.
The romances they had with their unlikely suitors were sweet and charmingly portrayed. Owen and Henry were the perfect partners for these two unique women.
The overall story has the traditional terms, settings, and elements of a typical regency novel, but with a bit more modern dialogue. That in no way took away from the pleasure of the story.
An Unlikely Proposition is a fun read for regency romance lovers who enjoy YA fiction with complex characters and storylines, and kisses only romance.
Thanks to NetGalley, Rosalyn Eves, Macmillan USA, and Austenprose PR for providing me with an early copy. All opinions expressed are completely my own.
March 3, 2024
This is a fun and sweet standalone novel in the Unexpected Season series. The story alternates between Eleanor and Thalia's stories as they spend a season in London and learn to follow their hearts.
A seventeen-year-old widow, Eleanor comes to London with a newfound independence and a desire to have some fun. Eleanor knows she can't remarry or else she loses her inheritance to a greedy nephew, but she enters a fake relationship to get her nephew off her back. She's a dynamic protagonist, and I enjoyed her growth over the course of the story. While trying to fulfill her husband's dying wish, she learns so much about herself, her life, and what she wants for her future.
Thalia is a companion to Eleanor, but she has hopes of becoming a poet. I was happy to see Thalia again after loving her character in the first book in the series. While in London, Thalia tries to ingratiate herself into the literary community, and it is an eye-opener. I love how the author integrates literature, poetic philosophies, recognizable artists of the time, and literary analysis into the narrative. These conversations are very revealing, especially in relation to many men's perspectives on women at the time. They also show just how fierce and intelligent Thalia is. She's definitely a woman ahead of her time, and her friendship with Eleanor, though it goes through a few bumps, is lovely.
I enjoyed both women's stories, and the romances were great, too. Both find love in the unlikeliest of places, and with social and economic obstacles, as well as their own doubts and fears, their road to happiness is filled with bumps. It's interesting to see how they face these and other struggles.
As much as I adore historical romance, I haven't read many that are geared toward young adults. I think I need to change that because I'm really enjoying this series. It's charming and fun, and the banter and dialogue are fantastic. I can't wait to read the next book in the series!
A seventeen-year-old widow, Eleanor comes to London with a newfound independence and a desire to have some fun. Eleanor knows she can't remarry or else she loses her inheritance to a greedy nephew, but she enters a fake relationship to get her nephew off her back. She's a dynamic protagonist, and I enjoyed her growth over the course of the story. While trying to fulfill her husband's dying wish, she learns so much about herself, her life, and what she wants for her future.
Thalia is a companion to Eleanor, but she has hopes of becoming a poet. I was happy to see Thalia again after loving her character in the first book in the series. While in London, Thalia tries to ingratiate herself into the literary community, and it is an eye-opener. I love how the author integrates literature, poetic philosophies, recognizable artists of the time, and literary analysis into the narrative. These conversations are very revealing, especially in relation to many men's perspectives on women at the time. They also show just how fierce and intelligent Thalia is. She's definitely a woman ahead of her time, and her friendship with Eleanor, though it goes through a few bumps, is lovely.
I enjoyed both women's stories, and the romances were great, too. Both find love in the unlikeliest of places, and with social and economic obstacles, as well as their own doubts and fears, their road to happiness is filled with bumps. It's interesting to see how they face these and other struggles.
As much as I adore historical romance, I haven't read many that are geared toward young adults. I think I need to change that because I'm really enjoying this series. It's charming and fun, and the banter and dialogue are fantastic. I can't wait to read the next book in the series!
February 29, 2024
This is a sweet and clean Regency romance that reminded me of a Georgette Heyer novel. It is the second book in a series, though I have not read the first, and it reads perfectly as a standalone story. There are two female main characters, Eleanor and Thalia, each with their own seemingly unrequited hopes for love. Eleanor is a young widow, at not yet 18. She’s come to London after a year of mourning and is anxious to be happy and independent. She hires Thalia as her new companion. Thalia had her own disastrous first season last year and now is focusing on her literary aspirations of becoming a published poet. It’s a light and easy Regency romance that I thought was very entertaining. My fellow Regency and Heyer fans will find much to enjoy.
I received an advanced copy of this book via NetGalley. A positive review was not required and all thoughts are my own and voluntarily given.
I received an advanced copy of this book via NetGalley. A positive review was not required and all thoughts are my own and voluntarily given.
February 16, 2025
3.5
It had me, lost me, then had me again.
It had me, lost me, then had me again.
February 6, 2024
This was a really fun and quick read! It’s a companion novel to the author’s first historical romance, An Improbable Season, but it can definitely be read as a standalone too!
I loved the regency romance vibes and the two lead characters were so enjoyable in their own ways. I really liked that we got a dual POV story between Eleanor and Thalia. I was equally invested in both of their storylines and relationships.
The drama felt high stakes and entertaining. There were so many good twists and turns and I was so eager to see what happened next.
I really hope this author writes more books like this!
Thank you to NetGalley, the author and the publisher for providing me with an early copy of this book in exchange for an honest review.
I loved the regency romance vibes and the two lead characters were so enjoyable in their own ways. I really liked that we got a dual POV story between Eleanor and Thalia. I was equally invested in both of their storylines and relationships.
The drama felt high stakes and entertaining. There were so many good twists and turns and I was so eager to see what happened next.
I really hope this author writes more books like this!
Thank you to NetGalley, the author and the publisher for providing me with an early copy of this book in exchange for an honest review.
September 8, 2025
Me han parecido dos historias bonitas. Me gusta como se entremezclan y como se van alternando los capítulos entre ambas protagonistas. Aunque el final se me ha quedado cortito y he necesitado más💛
March 7, 2024
Thank you AustenProse PR and Fierce Reads for the gifted book.
CHARMING.
BLOG || INSTAGRAM
I really enjoyed this! Another charming and delightful read in this standalone series. I love the London atmosphere and the balls and intriguing romances that come about.
Eleanor and Thalia both had a lot of character and I liked seeing their growth throughout the book. Eleanor needed to learn to lean on others and I was so happy to see how things worked out for her in the end. Thalia meanwhile, gained confidence in her writing and the courage to pursue her passions. Add in two handsome men and this brought a smile to my face.
A few small tidbits that kept me from that full five stars, but a genuine enjoyable read nonetheless. I like the voices the author creates for these characters and the drama and hope that flows throughout. If you’re needing something on the lighter side with a bit of swoon, I would absolutely recommend this (or book one! Which can be read on its own too).
Overall audience notes:
- YA Historical Romance
- Language: none – low
- Romance: kisses
- Violence: low
- Trigger/Content Warnings: loss of a spouse (recounted), attempted sexual assault (one brief incident)
CHARMING.
BLOG || INSTAGRAM
I really enjoyed this! Another charming and delightful read in this standalone series. I love the London atmosphere and the balls and intriguing romances that come about.
Eleanor and Thalia both had a lot of character and I liked seeing their growth throughout the book. Eleanor needed to learn to lean on others and I was so happy to see how things worked out for her in the end. Thalia meanwhile, gained confidence in her writing and the courage to pursue her passions. Add in two handsome men and this brought a smile to my face.
A few small tidbits that kept me from that full five stars, but a genuine enjoyable read nonetheless. I like the voices the author creates for these characters and the drama and hope that flows throughout. If you’re needing something on the lighter side with a bit of swoon, I would absolutely recommend this (or book one! Which can be read on its own too).
Overall audience notes:
- YA Historical Romance
- Language: none – low
- Romance: kisses
- Violence: low
- Trigger/Content Warnings: loss of a spouse (recounted), attempted sexual assault (one brief incident)
August 14, 2025
Hoy vengo con "Una propuesta inesperada, segunda entrega de la serie Amores de temporada. Es una novela que me ha dejado con una sonrisa permanente y la sensación de haber viajado a un Londres de 1818 lleno de paseos por parques, encuentros fortuitos y conversaciones tan ingeniosas que se disfrutan como un buen té caliente en día lluvioso.
La historia nos presenta a Eleanor Lockhart, una joven viuda de apenas diecisiete años que, lejos de buscar un nuevo matrimonio, quiere saborear su libertad y vivir la temporada londinense sin que nadie la controle. No lo tiene fácil porque hay parientes interesados en su herencia y pretendientes que la ven como un “partido” más que como una persona. Su plan es tan arriesgado como divertido, fingir un compromiso para mantener a raya a cazafortunas… aunque el corazón no siempre obedece a los planes.
En paralelo conocemos a Thalia Aubrey, una aspirante a poeta que, después de un desastroso debut en sociedad, consigue un puesto como acompañante de Eleanor. Lo que empieza como un trabajo se convierte en una amistad llena de confidencias, miradas cómplices y pequeñas aventuras que, a su manera, desafían las normas de la época. Ambas mujeres buscan algo más que cumplir con lo que la sociedad espera de ellas, una quiere conservar su independencia y la otra hacerse un hueco en el mundo literario.
Me ha encantado cómo la autora retrata la amistad femenina y el deseo de decidir el propio destino en una época en la que las mujeres tenían tan pocas cartas para jugar. Hay diálogos afilados, escenas de teatro, paseos por parques, un joyero encantador y más de un encontronazo con personajes que despiertan sonrisas o sospechas.
Es un romance dulce, sin escenas explícitas, pero con toda la química y la tensión bien servidas. Rosalyn Eves sabe mezclar la ambientación de Regencia con un ritmo ágil y personajes que se sienten vivos, cada uno con su propio mundo interior.
En definitiva, "Una propuesta inesperada" es perfecta si apetece una historia luminosa, con humor, enredos, un toque de intriga sentimental y protagonistas que no se resignan a ser lo que otros esperan. Una lectura que se disfruta de principio a fin y que deja con ganas de seguir acompañando a estas dos mujeres en todo lo que les depare la vida.
La historia nos presenta a Eleanor Lockhart, una joven viuda de apenas diecisiete años que, lejos de buscar un nuevo matrimonio, quiere saborear su libertad y vivir la temporada londinense sin que nadie la controle. No lo tiene fácil porque hay parientes interesados en su herencia y pretendientes que la ven como un “partido” más que como una persona. Su plan es tan arriesgado como divertido, fingir un compromiso para mantener a raya a cazafortunas… aunque el corazón no siempre obedece a los planes.
En paralelo conocemos a Thalia Aubrey, una aspirante a poeta que, después de un desastroso debut en sociedad, consigue un puesto como acompañante de Eleanor. Lo que empieza como un trabajo se convierte en una amistad llena de confidencias, miradas cómplices y pequeñas aventuras que, a su manera, desafían las normas de la época. Ambas mujeres buscan algo más que cumplir con lo que la sociedad espera de ellas, una quiere conservar su independencia y la otra hacerse un hueco en el mundo literario.
Me ha encantado cómo la autora retrata la amistad femenina y el deseo de decidir el propio destino en una época en la que las mujeres tenían tan pocas cartas para jugar. Hay diálogos afilados, escenas de teatro, paseos por parques, un joyero encantador y más de un encontronazo con personajes que despiertan sonrisas o sospechas.
Es un romance dulce, sin escenas explícitas, pero con toda la química y la tensión bien servidas. Rosalyn Eves sabe mezclar la ambientación de Regencia con un ritmo ágil y personajes que se sienten vivos, cada uno con su propio mundo interior.
En definitiva, "Una propuesta inesperada" es perfecta si apetece una historia luminosa, con humor, enredos, un toque de intriga sentimental y protagonistas que no se resignan a ser lo que otros esperan. Una lectura que se disfruta de principio a fin y que deja con ganas de seguir acompañando a estas dos mujeres en todo lo que les depare la vida.
March 24, 2024
It was cuuuuute
April 7, 2024
4.5 stars I liked it, but I found it hard to get into it until the end.
March 22, 2024
Thank you @austenprose, @fsgyoungreaders and @rosalyn.eves for the #gifted copy. All thoughts are my own.
Out of mild frustration and a desire for absolute independence, widowed Eleanor hires a young and malleable companion to lend propriety to her household. Thalia joins Eleanor in London with dreams of sharing conversation and inspiration from other more widely known poets. Neither wants nor needs a man. But love finds its way to disrupt both of their plans.
Thalia’s character and experiences are what I was hoping for after the first novel. I enjoyed her page time quite thoroughly. Eleanor was a little hard to love but she got there in the end. Rosalyn’s voice is easily bingeable and her books are perfect for any teen or adult looking for a sweet and occasionally sassy historical romance. I'd love to see a third book!
This absolutely can be read as a standalone (it introduces some new characters and is well rounded for those featured from An Improbable Season).
Out of mild frustration and a desire for absolute independence, widowed Eleanor hires a young and malleable companion to lend propriety to her household. Thalia joins Eleanor in London with dreams of sharing conversation and inspiration from other more widely known poets. Neither wants nor needs a man. But love finds its way to disrupt both of their plans.
Thalia’s character and experiences are what I was hoping for after the first novel. I enjoyed her page time quite thoroughly. Eleanor was a little hard to love but she got there in the end. Rosalyn’s voice is easily bingeable and her books are perfect for any teen or adult looking for a sweet and occasionally sassy historical romance. I'd love to see a third book!
This absolutely can be read as a standalone (it introduces some new characters and is well rounded for those featured from An Improbable Season).
April 8, 2024
It's my understanding that this is a standalone companion novel and can be read without ever having read the first book. However, despite this, I couldn't help but feel as if I actually needed to have read it to fully connect with Thalia as a character. From the synopsis of the first book alone, it seems like Thalia was even one of the main characters? Or strong supporting?
I think it was made even worse with Henry and Thalia having met in the first book as well. I don't necessarily mind that they met before, just that considering how fast the two fall for each other in this book, maybe it was important, again, that we read the first book.
This is not necessarily what made this book an eventual 2.5 star read, but the slight disconnect persisted throughout the book.
I had originally settled on 3 stars. This was OK, nothing too special nor noteworthy but not a bad book either. Once I got to the end and took a step back, I realized just how surface-level this actually was. Everything felt told, rather than shown: Eleanor and Thalia's friendship, the clear attempt at the found family trope, the romance(s). Nothing was happening even when things were happening.
For a historical romance, the romance was severely lacking. I've read many a historical romance and they're typically associated with high passion and heat (its personally not a dealbreaker for me if its not! I used to read a lot of no-steam hr). This is YA so I understand the lack of heat but what about the lack of substance? The pairs barely say a few words to each other before they're in love. At least Thalia and Henry spent some time together and were cute sometimes, Eleanor and Owen were so bland it actually made me angry. She meets him, finds him attractive, asks him to help her out with Albert's work, he refuses, she convinces him to reconsider, he works for her now, she's in love. The entire time it felt like she was pursuing him and being kind of clingy while he kept a professional distance. There were only a few glimpses into what he may have actually felt for Eleanor and they were completely overshadowed by their painfully awkward conversations that were clearly meant to feel like a burgeoning romantic connection but instead felt like an employee wishing their employer would stop trying to cross boundaries. Even at the very end he rejects her when she confesses but then suddenly decides that he loves her and wants to make it work when she lets him go out of love. I just couldn't buy their romance at all, it didn't feel like Owen actually loved Eleanor and I didn't think their formal conversations warranted the declarations of love at the end. If the two pairs had said they just liked each other and wanted to see where things went, I'd view their romances with less disbelief. Eleanor and Owen, at least, laid off the love a bit with Owen not having said it back by the end. But Thalia and Henry? They were fully in love with each other, ready to get married. I can actually move past my reluctance with them bc they had better moments but even with less intensity, Eleanor and Owen were just disappointing.
I also thought it was interesting that Owen and Henry's ages were never mentioned. Thalia is 19 and Eleanor 17-almost-18, the men seem to be at least 3-4 years older. I think 4 for Eleanor would be weird but even weirder (and creepier) if Owen were in his mid-20's. I'm just going to believe the two men were early 20's with Owen being 20 or 21...
It was weird how much Albert got away with marrying a 16-year old girl, despite her circumstances. If they stopped at him just trying to help her out of a bad situation, I would ignore it but he also kissed her a few times. And if he hadn't died earlier than expected, I have no doubt they would've consummated their marriage as per the times. I acknowledge that Albert changed Eleanor's life for the better but that doesn't mean we have to praise him or essentially blame Eleanor for marrying someone much older. A lot of the negativity about what happened surrounds Eleanor's expectations of how other people would react to her having married a much older man (presumably for his fortune) and nothing at all for this much older man marrying a teenager. I know this is "the era" as a lot of people would say (ew) but are we really going to pretend historical romance authors don't take a bunch of creative liberties when they write these? Is it sooo bad to have Eleanor or someone at least comment on the wrongness of a 50+ year old man taking advantage of a teenage girl, especially when she's vulnerable? He's never made out to be the bad guy, in fact he was described as someone who cared about Eleanor a lot and she spends a lot of the book with Owen who's trying to fulfill Albert's dying wish for his work. I found it disturbing that he's let off the hook so easily - I'm not blaming Eleanor for being the victim but what about the man?
I know that Albert isn't necessarily important as a character, only his death in how it set up the events that happened in this book. However, that doesn't mean he should get a pass. Normally heroines who marry much older men are widowed and their relationship with their deceased husband is described very briefly, but due to the large role that Albert's death plays, we get more detail than we'd usually get. Since it had to go that point, why not use some of it to highlight the grooming and ped0philia involved? If not from Eleanor, than her older friends? I'm repeating myself at this point but it left a bad taste in my mouth.
None of the characters are remarkable enough for me to comment on any of them. There was hardly any depth to the story or relationships and sometimes I found myself confused by all the people in the cast. Conflict was resolved pretty easily so I'm assuming it wasn't meant to be taken too seriously. With a bare bones plot, hardly any substantial romantic developments, and surface-level characters, I can confidently conclude that I didn't enjoy this and will actually dock it down to 2 rather than 2.5.
I don't imagine I'd read another book by Rosalyn but I wouldn't say never.
I think it was made even worse with Henry and Thalia having met in the first book as well. I don't necessarily mind that they met before, just that considering how fast the two fall for each other in this book, maybe it was important, again, that we read the first book.
This is not necessarily what made this book an eventual 2.5 star read, but the slight disconnect persisted throughout the book.
I had originally settled on 3 stars. This was OK, nothing too special nor noteworthy but not a bad book either. Once I got to the end and took a step back, I realized just how surface-level this actually was. Everything felt told, rather than shown: Eleanor and Thalia's friendship, the clear attempt at the found family trope, the romance(s). Nothing was happening even when things were happening.
For a historical romance, the romance was severely lacking. I've read many a historical romance and they're typically associated with high passion and heat (its personally not a dealbreaker for me if its not! I used to read a lot of no-steam hr). This is YA so I understand the lack of heat but what about the lack of substance? The pairs barely say a few words to each other before they're in love. At least Thalia and Henry spent some time together and were cute sometimes, Eleanor and Owen were so bland it actually made me angry. She meets him, finds him attractive, asks him to help her out with Albert's work, he refuses, she convinces him to reconsider, he works for her now, she's in love. The entire time it felt like she was pursuing him and being kind of clingy while he kept a professional distance. There were only a few glimpses into what he may have actually felt for Eleanor and they were completely overshadowed by their painfully awkward conversations that were clearly meant to feel like a burgeoning romantic connection but instead felt like an employee wishing their employer would stop trying to cross boundaries. Even at the very end he rejects her when she confesses but then suddenly decides that he loves her and wants to make it work when she lets him go out of love. I just couldn't buy their romance at all, it didn't feel like Owen actually loved Eleanor and I didn't think their formal conversations warranted the declarations of love at the end. If the two pairs had said they just liked each other and wanted to see where things went, I'd view their romances with less disbelief. Eleanor and Owen, at least, laid off the love a bit with Owen not having said it back by the end. But Thalia and Henry? They were fully in love with each other, ready to get married. I can actually move past my reluctance with them bc they had better moments but even with less intensity, Eleanor and Owen were just disappointing.
I also thought it was interesting that Owen and Henry's ages were never mentioned. Thalia is 19 and Eleanor 17-almost-18, the men seem to be at least 3-4 years older. I think 4 for Eleanor would be weird but even weirder (and creepier) if Owen were in his mid-20's. I'm just going to believe the two men were early 20's with Owen being 20 or 21...
It was weird how much Albert got away with marrying a 16-year old girl, despite her circumstances. If they stopped at him just trying to help her out of a bad situation, I would ignore it but he also kissed her a few times. And if he hadn't died earlier than expected, I have no doubt they would've consummated their marriage as per the times. I acknowledge that Albert changed Eleanor's life for the better but that doesn't mean we have to praise him or essentially blame Eleanor for marrying someone much older. A lot of the negativity about what happened surrounds Eleanor's expectations of how other people would react to her having married a much older man (presumably for his fortune) and nothing at all for this much older man marrying a teenager. I know this is "the era" as a lot of people would say (ew) but are we really going to pretend historical romance authors don't take a bunch of creative liberties when they write these? Is it sooo bad to have Eleanor or someone at least comment on the wrongness of a 50+ year old man taking advantage of a teenage girl, especially when she's vulnerable? He's never made out to be the bad guy, in fact he was described as someone who cared about Eleanor a lot and she spends a lot of the book with Owen who's trying to fulfill Albert's dying wish for his work. I found it disturbing that he's let off the hook so easily - I'm not blaming Eleanor for being the victim but what about the man?
I know that Albert isn't necessarily important as a character, only his death in how it set up the events that happened in this book. However, that doesn't mean he should get a pass. Normally heroines who marry much older men are widowed and their relationship with their deceased husband is described very briefly, but due to the large role that Albert's death plays, we get more detail than we'd usually get. Since it had to go that point, why not use some of it to highlight the grooming and ped0philia involved? If not from Eleanor, than her older friends? I'm repeating myself at this point but it left a bad taste in my mouth.
None of the characters are remarkable enough for me to comment on any of them. There was hardly any depth to the story or relationships and sometimes I found myself confused by all the people in the cast. Conflict was resolved pretty easily so I'm assuming it wasn't meant to be taken too seriously. With a bare bones plot, hardly any substantial romantic developments, and surface-level characters, I can confidently conclude that I didn't enjoy this and will actually dock it down to 2 rather than 2.5.
I don't imagine I'd read another book by Rosalyn but I wouldn't say never.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
February 28, 2024
Eleanor, a 17-year-old widow, fresh out of mourning, has the world at her feet. Her husband left her a fortune, but seemingly made it so she could never remarry, something that she is consistently reminded of by his nephew. What is a girl to do except swear off marriage and set up a fake engagement. Add to that an equally inexperienced companion who had a failed elopement and you have a duo trying to navigate the ton who are less than strictly proper. Thalia wants to be a writer of poetry and comes to London in order to meet the writers of the day.
This was a well written romp in Regency England, if not strictly proper. Some of the language felt a bit more modern, but the story was well written and I didn't mind. I am used to Regency novels being strict in their propriety so it is fun to have one that just hits a bit differently from time to time.
I liked these characters and the growth that each experienced, both in their personal journeys and in their romantic ones as well. They each found something in each other and their chosen gentlemen that was unexpected and something that felt undeserved., This story could definitely attract a younger audience, though it was a good story all around. I love when authors include a bit of mystery to be solved or a problem to be fixed.
I think Eleanor's growth was the most poignant as she had to decide what meant most to her. I love a good Happily ever after, but I also love it when the lead comes into her own and comes out stronger. This story had both.
I received an early copy from the publisher through NetGalley and this is my honest review.
This was a well written romp in Regency England, if not strictly proper. Some of the language felt a bit more modern, but the story was well written and I didn't mind. I am used to Regency novels being strict in their propriety so it is fun to have one that just hits a bit differently from time to time.
I liked these characters and the growth that each experienced, both in their personal journeys and in their romantic ones as well. They each found something in each other and their chosen gentlemen that was unexpected and something that felt undeserved., This story could definitely attract a younger audience, though it was a good story all around. I love when authors include a bit of mystery to be solved or a problem to be fixed.
I think Eleanor's growth was the most poignant as she had to decide what meant most to her. I love a good Happily ever after, but I also love it when the lead comes into her own and comes out stronger. This story had both.
I received an early copy from the publisher through NetGalley and this is my honest review.
March 6, 2024
Reasons to read:
- Two romances
- Regency Era
- Found Family themes
- Fake Betrothal
- Refreshing cast of characters
- Quick, light hearted read
My Thoughts:
My first book by Rosalyn Eves proved to be a winner. I loved that this book provided a fun, but heartfelt reading experience featuring friendship, misadventure, and love.
A Regency that reads like a true YA, An Unlikely Proposition features a lively and dynamic cast of characters. I appreciated that both female leads, Elenor and Thalia, were intelligent and independent, though each faced her own unique challenge due to a dramatic change in life, they took it in stride. I enjoyed the friendship that developed between them, despite Elenor’s hard personality and refusal to let anyone close.
The romances happened gradually and were paced brilliantly, thanks to a fake betrothal. This plot was a refreshing twist to a popular trope and added just the right amount of angst for one couple, all the while allowing Elenor the freedom she craved to experience for a time. Each romance was unique, with a chemistry singular to that couple. It was so much fun being invested in both romantic storylines. I also have to give thanks to the author for her balanced writing in allowing each character the opportunity to grow outside of the romance.
This is the feel good regency that I’ve been craving, and Eves has earned herself a new fan. I cannot wait to see what comes next.
𝐂𝐨𝐧𝐭𝐞𝐧𝐭 :
Romance: Kissing only
Trigger warning: unwanted advances
*I received a complimentary copy of this book. The opinions expressed in this review are entirely my own.
- Two romances
- Regency Era
- Found Family themes
- Fake Betrothal
- Refreshing cast of characters
- Quick, light hearted read
My Thoughts:
My first book by Rosalyn Eves proved to be a winner. I loved that this book provided a fun, but heartfelt reading experience featuring friendship, misadventure, and love.
A Regency that reads like a true YA, An Unlikely Proposition features a lively and dynamic cast of characters. I appreciated that both female leads, Elenor and Thalia, were intelligent and independent, though each faced her own unique challenge due to a dramatic change in life, they took it in stride. I enjoyed the friendship that developed between them, despite Elenor’s hard personality and refusal to let anyone close.
The romances happened gradually and were paced brilliantly, thanks to a fake betrothal. This plot was a refreshing twist to a popular trope and added just the right amount of angst for one couple, all the while allowing Elenor the freedom she craved to experience for a time. Each romance was unique, with a chemistry singular to that couple. It was so much fun being invested in both romantic storylines. I also have to give thanks to the author for her balanced writing in allowing each character the opportunity to grow outside of the romance.
This is the feel good regency that I’ve been craving, and Eves has earned herself a new fan. I cannot wait to see what comes next.
𝐂𝐨𝐧𝐭𝐞𝐧𝐭 :
Romance: Kissing only
Trigger warning: unwanted advances
*I received a complimentary copy of this book. The opinions expressed in this review are entirely my own.
February 26, 2024
An Unlikely Proposition by Rosalyn Eves is a sweet Regency romance that is stand-alone companion to An Improbable Season. Eleanor comes to London after the death of her husband. She is seventeen years old and desperately wants her independence. She is trying to survive the season, and figure out how to move forward as widow. Thalia is trying to start fresh in London and wants to be a published poet. She becomes Eleanor’s companion and their stories become intertwined.
This was a wonderful Regency read with romance, a compelling story and excellent historical details. I felt like I was visiting London and I did not want to leave. The alternating points of view with Elanor and Thalia made this an interesting read and helped me to feel very invested in the characters. The historical details were fascinating and gave the story depth. The book truly sparkled and kept me up late reading.
I adored An Unlikely Proposition by Rosalyn Eves is filed with wonderful characters, sweet romance, and the setting of Regency London is fabulous. . This will be one of my favorites this year. I highly recommend.
I was given a copy by the publisher and not required to write a positive review.
This was a wonderful Regency read with romance, a compelling story and excellent historical details. I felt like I was visiting London and I did not want to leave. The alternating points of view with Elanor and Thalia made this an interesting read and helped me to feel very invested in the characters. The historical details were fascinating and gave the story depth. The book truly sparkled and kept me up late reading.
I adored An Unlikely Proposition by Rosalyn Eves is filed with wonderful characters, sweet romance, and the setting of Regency London is fabulous. . This will be one of my favorites this year. I highly recommend.
I was given a copy by the publisher and not required to write a positive review.
December 17, 2023
I loved the second installment of the Unexpected Seasons series, An Unlikely Proposition! This book followed some of the same characters from An Improbable Season but also introduced some new faces. It was fun, romantic, and fast-paced- I stayed up way too late to see where the story was going to go.
I love how Rosalyn Eves writes her characters- they are all complex and realistically imperfect while still inspiring readers to cheer them on. I felt this especially in this story with the character of Eleanor- she made a lot of choices throughout the story that I didn't necessarily agree with, but as she grew as a character, she was able to see how she had erred and made things right. I haven't seen this happen much with protagonists in books, and it was refreshing to see something that accurately portrayed the human condition. We will all make mistakes, and we have to learn how to apologize and grow.
I also loved being able to see Thalia's story continue. She is such a strong and ambitious character, and I loved seeing how she came into her own even more throughout this book.
The romance was top-tier, and I am sure I will return to the Regency world Rosalyn Eves has created many times over!
Thank you to the author and her team for providing me with an e-ARC!
I love how Rosalyn Eves writes her characters- they are all complex and realistically imperfect while still inspiring readers to cheer them on. I felt this especially in this story with the character of Eleanor- she made a lot of choices throughout the story that I didn't necessarily agree with, but as she grew as a character, she was able to see how she had erred and made things right. I haven't seen this happen much with protagonists in books, and it was refreshing to see something that accurately portrayed the human condition. We will all make mistakes, and we have to learn how to apologize and grow.
I also loved being able to see Thalia's story continue. She is such a strong and ambitious character, and I loved seeing how she came into her own even more throughout this book.
The romance was top-tier, and I am sure I will return to the Regency world Rosalyn Eves has created many times over!
Thank you to the author and her team for providing me with an e-ARC!
March 4, 2024
Fans of An Improbable Season won't be disappointed by this follow-up! I enjoyed getting to see the continuation of Talia's story and meet some new characters.
An Unlikely Proposition comes back to the world of the ton we saw in the first book but explores class and relationships in a way that the first did not. While romantic relationships are a part of the story, friendships, and family also play a key role. There is also a theme of self-discovery that I think lots of younger readers will relate to.
I tend to be more one for a character-driven story but in this case, I really enjoyed the plot. I liked how the situations the characters managed to get themselves into brought clarity to their relationships and feelings. I would have liked to see a bit more of Eleanor and Owen's connection. It felt a bit shallow and based on physical attraction. However, I did love the friendships that all the characters developed and the sense of family we are left with.
Thanks to Farrar, Straus and Giroux and Netgalley for providing me with an advanced copy. All opinions are my own.
An Unlikely Proposition comes back to the world of the ton we saw in the first book but explores class and relationships in a way that the first did not. While romantic relationships are a part of the story, friendships, and family also play a key role. There is also a theme of self-discovery that I think lots of younger readers will relate to.
I tend to be more one for a character-driven story but in this case, I really enjoyed the plot. I liked how the situations the characters managed to get themselves into brought clarity to their relationships and feelings. I would have liked to see a bit more of Eleanor and Owen's connection. It felt a bit shallow and based on physical attraction. However, I did love the friendships that all the characters developed and the sense of family we are left with.
Thanks to Farrar, Straus and Giroux and Netgalley for providing me with an advanced copy. All opinions are my own.
March 10, 2024
In her latest novel in the Unexpected Seasons series, author Rosalyn Eves has crafted a fun and engaging Regency romance that readers will adore. This story will appeal to fans of not only Jane Austen, but also those of Bridgerton (but a much cleaner). An excellent addition to the series, Eves brings her story to life by continuing the story of Thelia Aubrey as she attends a Lonon season as a Lady’s companion for the young widow Lady Eleanor Lockhart. This story is about two independent women and their unexpected romances. A dazzling story that readers will devour.
Series: Unexpected Seasons
Genre: Regency, romance
Publisher: Farrar, Straus and Giroux
Publication date: March 5, 2024
Number of pages: 302
Books in the series:
1-An Improbable Season
2-An Unlikely Proposition
Disclosure statement: A complimentary review copy of this book was provided from tour groups, publishers, publicists, authors, and others, including NetGalley, OR was borrowed from the library, including OverDrive, Or borrowed from Kindle Unlimited, OR borrowed from Deseret Bookshelf, OR pre-ordered/purchased for review, including Audible. A review was not required and all views and opinions expressed are my own.
Series: Unexpected Seasons
Genre: Regency, romance
Publisher: Farrar, Straus and Giroux
Publication date: March 5, 2024
Number of pages: 302
Books in the series:
1-An Improbable Season
2-An Unlikely Proposition
Disclosure statement: A complimentary review copy of this book was provided from tour groups, publishers, publicists, authors, and others, including NetGalley, OR was borrowed from the library, including OverDrive, Or borrowed from Kindle Unlimited, OR borrowed from Deseret Bookshelf, OR pre-ordered/purchased for review, including Audible. A review was not required and all views and opinions expressed are my own.
March 25, 2024
Lots of characters and everyone is intertwined in a way that is fun, but doesn’t lend itself to really developing any relationship super well IMO. We’d get a sweet interaction between one couple and then it would switch to another person or another storyline. This made it feel like the relationship progression was too fast. I found myself thinking, “Wait! You love him already?” because the interactions still felt like they were in the “getting to know you” stage verses the “full blown feelings” stage.
May 11, 2024
2,5 stars
"Even were he free, he could hardly want to be with someone as difficult and sharp as Thalia"
I think Thalia is neither difficult nor sharp..
Everything so far is predicable (doesn't have to be bad necessarily...)
In the end.. I didn't really care for the characters or their love interests.
There were also a LOT of people/names. I understand you need to use first and last names in this erra, etc. But let's not introduce al 20 (I'm exaggerating) at the same time.
"Even were he free, he could hardly want to be with someone as difficult and sharp as Thalia"
I think Thalia is neither difficult nor sharp..
Everything so far is predicable (doesn't have to be bad necessarily...)
In the end.. I didn't really care for the characters or their love interests.
There were also a LOT of people/names. I understand you need to use first and last names in this erra, etc. But let's not introduce al 20 (I'm exaggerating) at the same time.
Read
July 13, 2024At about 8 chapters in, I have DNFed this book. With language that tried to mock that of the regency era, I understand how this can be appealing to both Bridgeton and historical fiction readers, but I don’t believe was crafted well. I am a fan of rotating POVs, however there was an abundance of characters introduced with a lack of character and plot development - there are times where too many elements muddles the work.
April 30, 2024
This was cute but I struggled liking one of two main characters storyline and mostly enjoyed the other chicks storyline better which sadly felt like it was a little slower especially in the romance. I feel like both of the romances felt felt very underdeveloped and not very deep. I just wanted there to be more romance. It was a little slow at times and I was ready to be done by the end. It was a cute, light read tho!
August 29, 2024
This wasn’t a bad book, but I also wouldn’t read it again. I liked the premise of the two characters, but I think I was anticipating something more like Bridgerton and what I got was, respectfully, the Aldi’s version. It all seemed a bit rushed at the end and some of the rules of regency weren’t quite followed. It almost seemed like the author wanted to full send it but then didn’t and we were only left with closed door make out sessions. Again, concept was there but the execution left something to be desired.
Read
November 30, 2023Thank you to the author and NetGalley for the eARC!
March 28, 2024
3.5 it was sweet.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
Read
July 18, 2024DNF@ 70%. Factual inaccuracies galore.
May 12, 2025
4.5 stars rounded down🥹
July 8, 2025
Didn't finish - I only read a few chapters, but it just wasn't my vibe. I found the main character to be a bit annoying, and both of the main female main characters had this very modern, I-don't-care-about-the-rules attitude that I found irritating. It could have been better later on, but I had a lot of other books I wanted to read, and frankly just didn't care enough to keep going. I'm sure it's fun, but it wasn't what I was looking for at the moment.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 173 reviews