There can be few European communities more soaked in their bloody history than the Province of Ulster, but the Catholic and Protestant communities' faulty understanding of their past has had ruinous effects on the lives of its inhabitants. In The Catholics of Ulster, Marianne Elliott slices through this dense thicket of obscuring myth, lies, and half-truths and emerges into the relative clarity of history. Some of Elliott's provocative claims There was no such thing as a Gaelic Catholic race. The Catholic gentry was decimated through conversion to Protestantism, not exile and dispossession. Catholic landowners often welcomed Scottish and English tenant farmers in Ulster. The English were not as culpable as previously claimed in exacerbating the Potato Famine. Arriving at a fragile juncture in the uncertain peace process, The Catholics of Ulster is sure to spark great controversy, inflame passions, and provoke spirited debate.
I must be honest - I didn't read much of this book - I wanted to, I borrowed it from the library and set about reading it's many pages and almost instantly I was overcome with a sense of unease. Although Ms. Elliott is a well respected historian and this ostensibly a history, and has the proper academic paraphernalia of footnotes and bibliography, this wasn't just a history but an attempt to explain a particular group of people at a particular time - the Catholic population (not the nationalists) in the UK province of Northern Ireland (not Ulster because not all of Ulster is in Northern Ireland) in the 1990s after the various peace accords engineered with the help of, amongst others, president Clinton.
The problem is that history is only guide not a scientific explanation of current events. People's and the places they live, the history they have experienced and even more so the history they believe and use to explain themselves and their times change all the time. H2O always is the chemical composition of water - what makes you catholic, nationalist, Irish or Ulsterman changes all the time. I could not read in 2022 a book designed to explain why Catholics in N. Ireland were what they are in 1990s. The world has moved on - how does someone of Catholic parents born the year this book published feel about being catholic? How do even there parents feel in the light of the scandals have rocked the Catholic on both sides of the border? I do not have the answers to these questions, but then neither does this book. By trying to use history to explain a situation topical at the time of publication the author has inevitable written journalism not history. And that is why I couldn't finish the book.
As this book (published in 2000) ends with considerations on the long-term outcome of the Good Friday Agreement, I’d love an addendum on the surprise Brexit development. Come on, Mazza, shoot us a few lines!