This is the 12th and final entry in the Blandings Castle series and, as with all four of the entries post 1960, it was of incredibly high quality for being written so late in P.G.’s career. P.G. trying to finish the story while in the hospital at age 93. Unfortunately, P.G. was unable to finish and left us with 16 chapters of his planned 22-chapter novel.
Those 16 chapters serve as an effective setup and include all the traditional Wodehouse trademarks including, frustrated current love, long-ago lost love, imposters, misunderstandings. For the third straight novel, Lord E’s brother Galahad serves as the master of ceremonies as he tries to direct activities to bring happiness to the cast of characters arriving at Blandings. He has the young couple, Vicky and Jeff to unite despite Vicky’s mother and Threepwood sister Florence’s opposition. He has Vicky’s uncle/watchdog and former Galahad Pelican Club buddy Sir James Piper to spark with reminders of past romantic days with old flame Diana Threepwood.
Will Galahad succeed? While P.G. did not finish the book, the answer is obvious to the experienced Blandings reader. But knowledge of the eventual outcome aside, the true fun is in the “how we get there.” P.G. did leave notes on how he hoped to finish the book in the last 6 chapters. These notes are included and analyzed as an additional section to the novel entitled “Work in Progress.” Unfortunately, reading these notes felt clinical and insufficient to even approach the fun of experiencing the humor and thrills of the usual Wodehouse denouement.
I generally dislike other authors finishing unfinished novels left by a dead author. However, here I did find myself wishing that someone had written a Wodehouse-like final 6 chapters based on these notes. While I probably would have grumbled about that attempt, if it had been written with any ear for the Wodehouse humor, I think it would have made me feel more positive about the story. As it is, I don’t think I will remember this storyline as much as I remember the others in the Blandings series.
I was also a bit disappointed with the other parts of the added information for this novel. Besides the Work in Progress section, this edition contains two other sections containing comments and details about “The Castle and its Surroundings” and “The Trains Between Paddington and Market Blandings” that respectively help the read locate characters and events in various locales within the Castle, and help the reader locate where Blandings might have been located within the Shropshire area. While I appreciated the information, again it felt too dry and clinical to be that entertaining. It was informative without providing any smiles. I prefer my Wodehouse reading experience to contain more smiles.
Based on the unfinished storyline and the clinical nature of the additional information, I rate this Wodehouse novel at 3 stars.