I would like to thank Netgalley and HQ for an advance copy of Slaughterhouse Farm, the second novel to feature CSI Ally Dymond, set in North Devon.
72 year old Miriam Narracott is found wandering on a dark road with a knife in her hand and blood soaking her clothes. At her farmhouse her son Gabe is found stabbed to death. Ally is on compassionate leave after the events of the previous novel, Breakneck Point, but DI Harriet Moore, recently transferred from the Met, wants her local knowledge and keen forensic eye. With Miriam catatonic they have to dig in to the family history.
I wasn’t overly enthusiastic about Breakneck Point, but not one to judge a series by one book, I thought that I would try again. Slaughterhouse Farm is for me a much better read as it maintains more mystery, like no early revelations of who did what. I find a read more immersive if there is a need to know element to keep me turning the pages. Now, all the author has to do is improve the personality of Ally Dymond. I don’t like her and find her first person narrative grating. She’s controlling and thinks that she can do better than a roomful of seasoned detectives, when she can make some enormous blunders.
The plotting in the novel is good. There is the initial murder and all sorts of seemingly unrelated incidents that come together in a final big twist. I was surprised by the identity of the perpetrators (more than one crime), but disappointed that the perspicacious Ms Dymond didn’t clock on sooner, although that would have spoiled the outcome. Throughout the novel there are flashbacks to Miriam’s younger self. These are heartbreaking and, to be honest, the star of the show. I particularly liked the final twist in this story and mourned the waste of a life spent believing lies.
Slaughterhouse Farm is a well written thriller.