World War II submariners rarely experienced anything as exhilarating or horrifying as the surface gun attack. Between the ocean floor and the rolling whitecaps above, submarines patrolled a dark abyss in a fusion of silence, shadows, and steel, firing around eleven thousand torpedoes, sinking Japanese men-of-war and more than one thousand merchant ships. But the anonymity and simplicity of the stealthy torpedo attack hid the savagery of warfare -- a stark difference from the brutality of the surface gun maneuver. As the submarine shot through the surface of the water, confined sailors scrambled through the hatches armed with large-caliber guns and met the enemy face-to-face. Surface and Destroy: The Submarine Gun War in the Pacific reveals the nature of submarine warfare in the Pacific Ocean during World War II and investigates the challenges of facing the enemy on the surface.
The surface battle amplified the realities of war, bringing submariners into close contact with survivors and potential prisoners of war. As Japan's larger ships disappeared from the Pacific theater, American submarines turned their attention to smaller craft such as patrol boats, schooners, sampans, and junks. Some officers refused to attack enemy vessels of questionable value, while others attacked reluctantly and tried to minimize casualties. Michael Sturma focuses on the submariners' reactions and attitudes toward their victims, exploring the sailors' personal standards of morality and their ability to wage total war. Surface and Destroy is a thorough analysis of the submariner experience and the effects of surface attacks on the war in the Pacific, offering a compelling study of the battles that became "intolerably personal."
I purchased my copy of this book used in hardback at the Glenwood Antique Mall in Overland Park, KS in July 2023. It has taken me a while to get around to reading it, but once I cracked it open I was engaged. This book tells of a fascinating chapter in the naval War of the Pacific: it is entirely devoted to engagements between submarines and surface craft where the submarines attacked using their guns. Most of the engagements covered involved US Navy submarines but British and Dutch efforts are also mentioned. When most people think of WW2 submarine warfare they envision attacks on large ships using torpedoes. I was amazed to discover the large number of incidents where surfaced submarines engaged and destroyed small surface craft using their guns. In some instances the small craft were destroyed by boarding parties from submarines employing demolition charges. The craft destroyed were almost always small (less than 500 tons) and lightly armed: sampans, barges, patrol craft, fishing vessels, etc. Late in the war, as the Allies destroyed more and more of their large seagoing cargo vessels, the Japanese came to rely on small coastal craft to move personnel, fuel, food, and war materiel. These small vessels couldn't effectively be engaged with torpedoes, leading submarines to engage them on the surface using their guns. As the war neared its end, US Navy submarines began to be more heavily armed with guns to engage small vessels, transforming them in effect into gunboats with two deck cannon, multiple 40mm and 20mm guns, and machine guns. Some of the storage space formerly used for torpedoes began to be used for storing cannon ammunition. The nature of these surface engagements was vastly different from stand-off torpedo attacks: most occurred in daylight and were up-close-and-personal affairs where the submarine gunners could directly observe the devastation their ordnance wrought on the crews of the vessels being attacked. I found the book to be well written and very interesting throughout. It you are interested in US Navy history, particularly the War of the Pacific, then I can recommend this book for you. Five out of five stars.
I am actually about halfway through this book and find the material fascinating and the presentation lively and readable. Not a dry nonfiction history lesson! Why did I pick up this book? I am fascinated by submarine warfare as a subject, this time period in particular, because my father served on four war patrols aboard the USS Atule in the World War II in the Pacific. In fact he served on the diesel boats through the early 60s in Key West, where I was born, and Charleston, where my sister was born.
Many an evening he regaled me with his "war stories" from the sub service and his time in the US Navy. Sadly he passed in January 1996, so all I have are the memories....
An interesting treatise focusing on submarines using their deck guns in surface attacks, with some diversions into the comparative morality of torpedo and gun attacks, the increased empathy with crews of vessels destroyed in surface actions, and the overall fit of these missions into the "big picture" of World War 2.