If you read my prior review of Riposte, you'll notice that I mentioned my hopes of that book being a necessary "stumbling block" in order to get to the best of this trilogy. I'm glad to say, that this is the case with the Warrior trilogy, and boy oh boy was it worth the push to get here.
The second book was a slog for me. That being said, there was a lot of vital information that led us to this book's conclusion. I don't think I would've enjoyed this book as much as I did unless I read Riposte. However, I still stand by my review for that book. I didn't like it, it's pacing was rough.
Warrior: Coupe dives into the Fourth Succession War swinging. Any pacing issues we experienced in Riposte are thrown out the window. It is an absolute roller coaster ride from start to finish. This was a book I simply could not put down as conclusion of all of the plot threads were coming together. Let's start with my boy, Justin Xiang, or should I say ALLARD! This was by far my most favorite character in the entire trilogy. Toward the end of the book we did experience some dramatic plot twists that had my head spinning. I have to wonder though, did I like the twist? The aspects that I really enjoyed about Justin's character were that he was flawed and unpredictable due to his unstable emotions caused by his betrayal. I really loved seeing him align himself with a new faction that aligned with his motives, but then in this book we are slowly shown another path for Justin. And then WHAM! You find out and it knocks your socks off. I'm not going to lie, I didn't hate Justin's conclusion, but I'm also curious if it would've served his character better to remain bitter towards his resentments and find a path that suited him in that avenue. I wasn't entirely satisfied with his ending, not because of the twist, but because I really wanted to delve more into how his actions and choices truly impacted the characters that he interacted with. Overall, Justin's ending was surprising and good. It wasn't at all what I expected, but that's because Stackpole wrote in such a believing way during Justin's chapters that he had us all convinced in his facade. I don't know if I hate this or not, but it defiantly made the surprise an actual surprise, and again, I had a positive reaction to it. So props to Stackpole here, he did something right that really entertained me.
Dan and Andrew have always been OK to me. However, Andrew's story arc had a massive upgrade to with the integration of Morgan Hasek-Davion being added into the plot. Andrew always felt like a vessel to the forefront of the war. He had a connection with Justin, and that was mainly it for me other than his skills of a Mechwarrior. His chapters though involving the defense of Kathil were absolute page turners. Andy was built up in the previous two books, so seeing the desperation of their fight against a superior force really made the book much more engaging. He grew on me. Dan, eh....not so much. Dan's relationship with Melissa's double was more interesting in this book. Dan's cool. But his resolution with Justin was snubbed. I hated this. Dan really looked up to Justin, I really wanted more out of him versus what we got in his action sequences.
Clovis, a character from the first book, really was a fun character that took me by surprise. His arc was really well built and I really enjoyed his conclusion. I haven't mentioned him at all in my previous reviews, because he felt so insignificant for me in the greater plot. However, his outcome was extremely entertaining in this book.
Now, one of my biggest gripes with this trilogy is that I don't really understand the hype with Morgan Kell and Yorinaga Kurita. They have a revolving plot device in this trilogy involving the two and their mystic ways of fighting, but there is never an answer to this. Does there need to be? No, not necessarily. However, so much was built up in the last two books that their final conclusion was very underwhelming for me. Some cool aspects, but it followed with confusion. Yorinaga's battle with honor and what's right and wrong in his eyes is very confusing to follow. I just am baffled that the two Mechwarriors just couldn't sit down and have some tea to hash things out but I guess where would the fun be in that, right? Still, it was OK. The Kell Hounds are in fact cool. However, they are power house, making it difficult to find weakness, which makes them really uninteresting to me. I guess you could say Morgan's obsession with this final battle between him and Yorinaga was their weakness, but in conclusion it doesn't expose it really.
Another problem I have with this book is House Liao. I feel like they get curb-stopped every which way possible. Especially when we go into more depth about Justin's character. House Liao are defiantly depicted as the bad guys through and through. I liked having Justin there because he showed the unfairness in the Fed Suns, giving the basis that no one has more moral high ground than the other, but the ending changes this, alters the perspective of Liao completely. Hanse Davion has a cool moment where he questions himself as being a ruthless dictator as much as his critics claim him being. Hanse defiantly does some messed up stuff in this book. However, he pulls the ultimate power move almost eliminating a lot of his flaws that made him a questionable leader. He really is "The Fox." I don't know, it felt that it lessened the impact of House Liao and made them just the cliche bad guys of the trilogy versus having the convoluted question to the reader of who are the good guys. It used to be both were messed up, by the end, it looks like the Fed Suns prove to be more of the good guys. I wanted more equal ground seeing the flaws more in each faction instead of just beating away at House Liao.
The action in the book improved. Stackpole dwells more on the battle scenes versus the sped up battles that I experienced in Riposte. I really appreciated what he did here. Every battle was a fun read. I especially loved the hovercraft militia pulling punches on mechs. That was a fun ride. All of it was a fun ride. This book out of the three had the most entertaining battles for me. The Stalaris battles take a very close second.
This book gets 4 stars for me. I'm still not sure where I sit with Justin's resolution, but I didn't hate it and it worked for me for the most part. I loved the pacing, and the action was there when it was necessary and it was good. It was a fantastic Battletech book, and I was entertained from beginning to end. A vast improvement from the previous entry.
In summary, what did I think of the Warrior Trilogy? It started great, its middle dragged HARD, but the push through it made it a worthy read. Stackpole's writing does improve throughout the trilogy, but the second book really dragged me back from engaging more with the story. It is worth reading the Warrior Trilogy. Justin's arc is the selling point. There are some side characters that have some awesome moments. The Kell hounds are cool, but just uninteresting to me in general as was Morgan Kell's story.
It's defiantly that series where you encourage your friend to push through the second book because it does in fact get a whole lot better. I would say skip Riposte, but I can't say that because there are in fact some vital scenes that play into the conclusion that you will need to know. That said, I liked the trilogy, I give it a 3 1/2 star review. The second book definitely being the series' detriment along with story arcs that to me felt unused or not developed enough. There is a LOT going on in the Warrior Trilogy. I applaud Stackpole for concluding it in a grand way, but it felt at times the books were drowning in characters and subplots. I wanted more time with characters and their conclusions.