This is my first Mary Higgins Clark novel, and one thing that I appreciated about this book is that I was wrong in who the killer was. The author does a really great job of making it seem as if the killer can be anyone in town, and even better when I think I know who it is, I'm certain I know who it is, and am just waiting for the big reveal and... well, damn. I was wrong.
And that's a GOOD thing.
The only reason, really, why this didn't get more stars from me is because I just couldn't buy into a recent divorcee, who happens to be a criminal defense attorney, being the one to solve not just a series of murders from the past four years, but the series of murders from over a century ago, too.
Like, despite the house that Emily Graham buys and moves into being in her family for over a century, she's STILL NEW TO THE NEIGHBORHOOD. She's not there even a week before she's apparently got people giving her their family belongings just because two bodies were buried in her backyard. She's a complete stranger to Spring Lake and she doesn't interact with ANYONE unless she needs something.
I mean, she goes out to dinner twice with the local real estate agent, and she does go to brunch with a soon-to-be coworker in the new law firm that she'll start working at once her "vacation" is over, but that's about it. She interacts with maybe one neighbor, a Dr. Wilcox, who's a former college president and is doing some major research for a book that he's writing, but like I said, that's only when she needs/wants something. She just asks to borrow some books and Wilcox hands them over, no questions asked.
And then, AND THEN, later on in the book, Wilcox visits Emily at her home and for some unknown reason, she's afraid of him and there's really no explanation why. She just cowers away from him, seemingly inconspicuously, and I just don't understand what the point of the scene was, tbh. Maybe she suspected Wilcox was the one doing the killing, I don't know, but I don't even remember why he visited her in the first place.
All in all, it was definitely an interesting read. I enjoyed learning the history of Spring Lake, though I would have liked it more had the author spent more focus on the town and the time instead of the people (but I understand why she didn't, I just wanted more information). If you're a fan of Mary Higgins Clark, I think you'll enjoy this, if you haven't read it already. If not, I think it's still an interesting concept and if the synopsis grabs you in, maybe give it a read.