I don’t know where to start. I haven’t read a ton of hard case crime books, but I’ve read at least five, maybe six, and this isn’t just my least favorite, it’s miles. MILES. behind whichever is second to least. This was one of the worst, if not the worst, books I’ve read in my whole adult life. It makes a mockery of good literature, and art in general. It spits on the neo noir, crime, and serial killer genres, all of which this book lent aspects from, and tells them to go screw themselves; when, in fact, this book is the one that should go screw itself.
This book was, time and time again, a MASTERCLASS on how to write completely INSUFFERABLE characters. I literately just hoped, throughout the entirety of the book, that everyone would just die. The cop was the only one who was tolerable, but that’s only because we only spend like 20ish pages with him. And even he is still as cliche as they come. It tried to write the serial killer character as a “charming”, doesn’t give an f, edgy “cool” guy, who (well, really the writers) completely relies on all his victims being totally brain dead stupid morons, and also never try to defend themselves. I guess he’s just wayyyy too fast and clever and cool 🙄🙄🙄🙄🙄🙄🙄
And speaking of the serial killer, it occurred to me at some point around the 2/3 point that he somewhat reminded me of another literary, edgy and angsty, serial killer from some books written at about the same time as this one was. Stephen King’s Brady Hartsfield from the Bill Hodges trilogy (or the Mr. Mercedes books as they’re more well known). That’s a great example on how TO write a character like that, and make him actually pretty creepy and disturbing, instead of like someone you want to just constantly slap the ever loving crap out of. Literally. The entire book.
Everyone in this book is almost comically arrogant, to the point where I suspect that it may’ve been intentional? I genuinely couldn’t think of a reason as to WHY you, as a writer, would WANT to go about intentionally trying to piss your readers off (in a bad way), and make them never want to read your books again, which then leads me to the idea that it must NOT have been intentional. Really, you couldn’t pay me to pick up another book for as long as I live written by either of these hacks.
And don’t even get me started on how the writers kept trying to interweave the word “like” into dialogue and the character’s internal monologue, but I swear it couldn’t have felt LESS natural. It made the characters that much more, like, unbearable.
I hope to god that these men that wrote this worthless piece of crap retire immediately as writers (I do realize that this book is 15 years old, humor me), if only to save the poor trees that would have to be cut down in order to make the paper for their books.
And don’t even bother trying to pick at little details like time passing at different rates for different characters for storylines happening at the same time; or simple math not adding up for how much money a NYC penthouse would cost.
Ultimately, what really yanks my chain is this: I love books, more than almost anything. BUT, I am a very slow reader, so I try to pick wisely what I read vs. what I listen to on audio. I admit, I picked very wrong here. So what I guess what I’m most angry about (well not really, this book pissed me off in more ways than one) is that these dipshits made a fool of me, and wasted my time. And for that, they can piss all the way off.
P.S. I’ve seen at least one or two reviews on here giving the book a fairly low rating, but saying something like “it was bad but I had fun while reading it” or “dumb but fun”. However, I refuse to give these moronic writers even that much. Not even to mention that I DIDNT have fun while reading, and I’m not really sure how someone would even go about doing that while reading this scum.