2.5 Stars
I had a very difficult time reading this book, because I liked it and didn't like it at the same time. I really loved the characters (though, sadly, my favorite character didn't end up with the man -- which is the only non-spoiler way I can think of saying it), but at the same time, I felt like the characters were lost in translation. By that, I mean that the poor writing got in the way of their personalities coming completely forward. I think it must be specific to this book (IMO), because I have read previous works by this author that were very smartly written. Most of the prose and dialogue just felt awkward -- filled with words no one would use in conversation (especially Cade, Mark, and Jake), way too heavy with the "frat speak" (though some amount does suit the three men), and dialogue full of exposition to the point where the characters seems to be preaching morals or constantly "teaching" the reader. I've seen this pretty often with coming of age stories, but this kind of writing makes it seem as if the author were writing to gay teens. Still, I liked the plotline, and though I'm still not sure if I really enjoyed the turn in the plot towards the end, I still enjoyed the story enough to keep reading. Now, if only my favorite character had really gotten his happy ending. He was by far the most interesting character, in my opinion.
This is a book that many people will like. It is sweet and cute, but I wish that more time had been spent editing it.