Those who follow my cookbook reviews know I usually love an Emeril Lagasse cookbook. I liked this one - his first - yet didn't love it. That isn't to say there aren't great recipes in here. The Smoked Salmon Hash with Poached Eggs = amazing! The Paneed Chicken = so versatile and delicious. The Crawfish Pies = outstanding. Yet, there were just as many recipes I made that were good but not great: Chocolate Chunk Cookies, Pumpkin Walnut Bread Pudding with Bourbon Sauce (which I'm also sure had a error in the ingredient list as to amount of bread to use), Jalapeño Cornbread, and Andouille Gnocchi with Spicy Tomato Sauce among others. Only 1 recipe I made was bad, the Potato Shallot Custards, which had an OK flavor but a very off putting texture.
Maybe because it's his first one, the tone is also different than later collections. All the recipes have specific plating instructions but no substitution recommendations (common in his later cookbooks). That's important for when you don't live in an area that sells crawfish, even frozen, or veal, or fresh oysters. Several of the recipe instructions assume a higher level of cooking knowledge and experience than his later works written with home cooks in mind. Many don't have amounts of basic seasoning like salt and pepper, which is typically included in perfect amounts in his later books. I also found it repetitive. For instance, there are 3 roasted chicken recipes, 4 skillet steak recipes, 2 bread pudding recipes - a lot of the same general recipe over and over.
This is still a solid cookbook. It is well worth the $1.50 I paid for it at the vintage store for the Smoked Salmon Hash alone. There are several recipes I still plan to try, meaning this will be one I keep. Yet, I think most of his later cookbooks are better.